Map rotation bug |
1 | ||
Although this bug doesn't happen that often, it does exist. The bug existed around in 2012, at the ex-p5 map @3514971(3 out of 10 played maps in rotation were this) and it's back and around for like a year. What this bug causes is a bunch of specific maps keeps playing many more often than the rest in rotation. This can happen in any room that has map rotation, especially in racing rooms. This might as well cause gameplay to getting boring by playing certain maps too many times. Dernière modification le 1478420040000 |
Kimsterjay « Consul » 1478421360000
| 0 | ||
Yes I have seen it happen.. |
Describe « Citoyen » 1478436540000
| 0 | ||
This has been noted before by several people. I know it's been brought to admin attention but I don't recall them finding anything wrong with the randomiser. |
Goondad « Citoyen » 1478514180000
| 0 | ||
I've never thought of this before, so maybe it sounds stupid, but here it comes: If you have 100 maps in rotation, and all 100 of them each play once, there has to be an algorithm in it. If a few maps play more than another few maps it's more random, because then you can be sure there's no algorithm in it. Maybe that's how it works.. |
0 | ||
Edit: This post might possibly not make much sense because this was done before knowing the actual number of racing maps in rotation. I've gathered an example of 150 rounds' mapcodes in the room racing2 on EN. List Round - Name - @code - Number of times played 1 - Ssk - @3579335 2 - Xabq - @3690578 3 - Dollyblue - @627609 4 - Deityexe - @264348 5 - Cilacapenjoy - @5249500 6 - Taman - @146801 7 - Rudiihabbo - @504951 8 - Stinkytail - @138036 9 - Cooxiinhhaa - @1873736 10 - Dollyblue - @1162611 11 - Chlorophylla - @403698 12 - Newmathsz - @1613550 13 - Imune - @441598 14 - Cartigo - @1687268 15 - Frostlegend - @209799 16 - Louans - @4273207 17 - Aneimone - @229834 18 - Redaa - @400429 19 - Bbqchickenwi - @2068543 20 - Dollyblue - @1973574 21 - Poxman - @130763 22 - Xabq - @3690578 - 2 times 23 - Viinisilva - @423062 24 - Soultouch - @319524 25 - Firzywazhere - @441047 26 - Loveeban - @499109 27 - Lovegolden - @2577060 28 - Caiolemoss - @270668 29 - Conterstine - @1143815 30 - Thegbc - @1483155 31 - Elhectordm - @3799857 32 - Xaxadoooooo - @2372538 33 - Hyouraan - @3530855 34 - Expelliarmus - @161730 35 - Lilxmouse - @385203 36 - Taman - @146801 - 2 times 37 - Redaa - @418265 38 - Tinycock - @326585 39 - Edwardmaya - @371076 40 - Zopt - @425349 41 - Ffrr - @669031 42 - Sharpiepoops - @3799951 43 - Xabq - @3690578 - 3 times 44 - Imune - @441598 - 2 times 45 - Deafmaus - @237041 46 - Deviousprodi - @399673 47 - Elhectordm - @4003729 48 - Srmal - @1692628 49 - Danshweger - @1281700 50 - Woppoz - @398081 51 - Redaa - @400429 - 2 times 52 - Srmal - @1692628 - 2 times 53 - Caiolemoss - @270668 - 2 times 54 - Cooxiinhhaa - @1873736 - 2 times 55 - Firestonnne - @734476 56 - Zopt - @425349 - 2 times 57 - Imune - @1539515 58 - Mastercow - @214775 59 - Darkvolee - @1371239 60 - Dollyblue - @1162611 - 2 times 61 - Ikaya - @402214 62 - Cilacapenjoy - @3857914 63 - Viprin - @379550 64 - Ecoo - @144677 65 - Rdgsz - @1623300 66 - Eupossotudo - @551126 67 - Cheerydog - @405497 68 - Thegbc - @3209087 69 - Woppoz - @398081 - 2 times 70 - Carneew - @2546484 71 - Kyroon - @250610 72 - Killerbr - @229827 73 - Danshweger - @1845710 74 - Eupossotudo - @551126 - 2 times 75 - Caiolemoss - @270668 - 3 times 76 - Azafreak - @273434 77 - Tabinha - @507308 78 - Sconinja - @248098 79 - Beijodocrak - @1609978 80 - Baconlol - @235651 81 - Killerbr - @229827 - 2 times 82 - Hekie - @327130 83 - Geladohb - @265221 84 - Nhute - @658464 85 - Mingser - @401995 86 - Leave - @382977 87 - Carneew - @2185089 88 - Dogmoos - @1999967 89 - Bowlt - @1923785 90 - Ssk - @337581 91 - Darkressxx - @3120368 92 - Ssk - @337581 - 2 times 93 - Darkressxx - @3120368 - 2 times 94 - Darkvolee - @1371239 - 2 times 95 - Gabriieldo - @361382 96 - Homegood - @330441 97 - Viinisilva - @1857829 98 - Necroseer - @556426 99 - Mushidon - @275514 100 - Redaa - @400666 101 - Xabq - @3690578 - 4 times 102 - Cartigo - @1687268 - 2 times 103 - Viinisilva - @1857829 - 2 times 104 - Redaa - @407746 105 - Aleeeeeh - @1794287 106 - Gurraa - @420956 107 - Ikaya - @402214 - 2 times 108 - Redaa - @407746 - 2 times 109 - Mushidon - @275514 - 2 times 110 - Redaa - @400429 - 3 times 111 - Eili - @3613029 112 - Frostlegend - @407488 113 - Arsimet - @789058 114 - Ikaya - @402214 - 3 times 115 - Poxman - @130763 - 2 times 116 - Dollyblue - @1167734 117 - Diegots - @905496 118 - Newziim - @1665516 119 - Comadre - @214037 120 - Redaa - @360273 121 - Imune - @1539515 - 2 times 122 - Loveeban - @499109 - 2 times 123 - Bloodight - @427300 124 - Superasno - @4035194 125 - Viprin - @379550 - 2 times 126 - Hirocheetos - @232140 127 - Danshweger - @1281700 - 2 times 128 - Arsimet - @789058 - 2 times 129 - Xaxadoooooo - @3595900 130 - Deadnoght - @444964 131 - Poteerfotter - @6771291 132 - Hibr - @185760 133 - Ninguem - @227417 134 - Azafreak - @273434 - 2 times 135 - Frostlegend - @407488 - 2 times 136 - Thegbc - @3209087 - 2 times 137 - Faustosilva - @301315 138 - Viinisilva - @1857829 - 3 times 139 - Eili - @4758350 140 - Ssk - @327254 141 - Deviousprodi - @399673 - 2 times 142 - Theebest - @378826 143 - Hekie - @327130 - 2 times 144 - Winstop - @4489653 145 - Wallacesccp - @260384 146 - Diegots - @905496 - 2 times 147 - Nerdnoob - @407230 148 - Danshweger - @1845710 - 2 times 149 - Imune - @441598 - 3 times 150 - Deadlag - @422509 33 maps out of 150 were played more than once. It would probably be in normal range if one or two maps were played more than once. Despite 284 maps in rotation, why was @3690578 played four times in these 150 rounds? And see the rounds from 90 to 93, how come that happened?. Do you still think there's nothing wrong with the randomiser? Dernière modification le 1488067440000 |
Anythin « Consul » 1488102300000
| 1 | ||
Seems like these statistics are exactly what they are supposed to be... completely random. As Goondad points out, expecting to see maps play only once or twice in the range of 150 maps means there should be some kind of logic behind the rotation, which automatically means it's not random anymore. Does this current randomiser give the desired effect? I don't think it does. But from these stats I can conclude that it is doing exactly what it is designed to do. |