Basically, you say one thing that would be in a haunted house. Then the next person says whether it's scary or not.
Example- Person 1: Cobwebs
Person 2: Not scary
Bats
Person 3: not scary
Jason
and so on

First game thread I've ever made =P

I'll start-

zombies

dies
i want my brain ty

uh um
scary

GHOSTS

Scary

Some nakkid guy

disturbing, not scary

a dead, hanging dog from the ceiling

Creepy

Angry Celestia

LOL
SCARY

chaosquake

not scary (make it so that others can reply plz)

transformice server restart

um scary if i was in the middle of a REALLY important thing


Moderators that troll

Not scary unless they've got a banana

Brokenstone

not scary unless she/he has their guns with...


Tigerstar

i realized I should have named this just as 'scary things', because this is getting completely off topic ^-^ll

scary in the Dark forest

burnt waffles

Not scary unless they're your size

A unitato

scary...

Zombie cats that jump out at u?

not scary

bubbleess x3

Seriously?

Herobrine eue

scary

falconfrost

not scary unless you give Falcon a donut

Sephiroth

ghostly puppys?

Not scary

Myself with a chainsaw

Yo Face is scary ;c Jkjk. Probably, quite scary
Slender Man ;3 ~