IF YOU HAVEN'T READ THE ENTIRE WARRIORS SERIES THERE WILL BE SPOILERS IN THIS GAME!
Anyway, mods please delete if another game exists like this one.
How to Play Example:
P1: What if Firestar never existed?
P2: Then the clans wouldn't have gotten to the new territories! What if Tigerclaw had killed Bluestar?
So, in your game post, you include your answer or theory about the other person's What-If, and your own What-If, heres the starter.

What if Feathertail hadn't died?

^Hold on a second
Firestar didnt take the Clans to the new territories
Brambleclaw did
.....
-------------------------------------

Crowfeather x Leafpool wouldnt exist, and the Clans would be lost in darkness from the battle between Light and Dark

-------------------------------------

What if Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight had Kits? (They never had in the books)

v I said “what if they had kits”, that doesnt mean that Leafpool didn’t have kits.. eh ouo

Hollyleaf wouldn't have to announce that Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw weren't their real parents and leafpool and crowfeather were.

************************************************************

What if Jaypaw never became the medicine cat apprentice?

He would’ve maybe succeeded in becoming a warrior, either that or gone to the elders den excessivey early

-----

What if Hawkfrost killed Brambleclaw when he set the trap for FIrestar? (Firestar also dies)

Then Firestar would never have killed Tigerstar for a second time and ThunderClan would need a new leader.
Hawkfrost would also have lived longer and possibly be able to take over RiverClan

What if Cinderpelt never gotten into that accident (when she crippled her leg)

She wouldve fulfilled her dream of becoming a warrior, having a mate and kits, and Cinderheart wouldnt have been born


------

What if Tigerstar killed Firestar in The Last Hope? (He cant take over, he isnt alive)

Griffincraft a dit :

^Hold on a second
Firestar didnt take the Clans to the new territories
Brambleclaw did
.....

I know, but Firestar helped unite the clans to go on the journey, :P I'm tired today, so my mind is kinda blank. Sorry.

What if Toadpole's real name was Trolocat?

griffincraft a dit :

What if Brambleclaw and Squirrelflight had Kits? (They never had in the books)

They apparently had kits in "A Vision of Shadows" named Alderkit, Sparkkit, Juniperkit, and Dandelionkit.

---

To above: He still would have died and life would've gone on as usual

What if Jayfeather didn't have the dream about the Ancient Cats planning on going to the forest territory?

He wouldn't have fallen in love with Half Moon, and he wouldn't have known that he, Lionblaze, and Dovewing were reincarnated versions of Jay's Wing, Lion's Roar, and Dove's Wing.

---

What if the rouges never invaded modern Skyclan in "A Vision of Shadows"?

Sandstorm would have never fucking died on that fence
and then she would have been killed by something else

---

What if Firestar died in the battle against Scourge?

idk anything about warrior cats i'll try my best!
Probably that the clan she was in would not be able to survivor? xD

---

What if all the warriors "cats" died
lol srry

Starclan would be miserable, and there would be nobody to continue the generations.
So, rip the clans

What if Moonflower lived?

Probably that the war would be worst? idk

---

What if Firestar got suddently killed in the 3rd episode

Missiclinda a dit :

Probably that the war would be worst? idk

---

What if Firestar got suddently killed in the 3rd episode

Moonflower wasn't evil, there wasn't a war then yet either.

What do you mean by 3rd episode? 3rd book? If so
Forest of secrets was when Graystripe met Silverstream right?
Well if Fireheart died, Gray would be very sad, and through grieving probably wouldn't meet Silverstream anymore. So they probably wouldn't be mates, Silverstream would've lived, Crookedstar wouldn't have seen her go to Starclan, he wouldn't have that talk with Mapleshade, maybe he would live longer, idk ahah. But, Feathertail and Stormfur wouldn't exist, meaning the tribe might've died. And if Fireheart died, he and sandstorm wouldn't become mates, no Squirrelflight or Leafpool, the trip to the sun drown place would be different ( since no squirrelflight or stormfur ) and Leafpool wouldn't have become mates with Crowfeather, so there wouldn't be Lionblaze, and Jayfeather, which means the clans would be doomed basically.
Phew that was a lot.

What if Appledusk hadn't neglected Mapleshade, or he didn't take another mate.

well, they wouldn't hate each other im trying omfg

---

What if wars wouldn't exist?