Just like the vanilla and racing rooms, this 'Protected' room would only play maps from the P1 (Protected) category.

One reason is that in normal rooms the same maps are often repeated with some categories such as P8 and P9 having less than 200 maps, whereas the P1 category has over 33000 maps and is growing quite quickly compared to other categories, so maps won't be repeated as often.

Also, although P1 is only a weak perm, many of the maps are still very good and are definitely playable. So in this room, all of the maps that are played will be of at least a decent standard, instead of seeing some of the maps that are in rotation which aren't to the highest standard and often receive criticism from mice within the room.

This room could also lead to some P1 maps becoming recognised, and maybe becoming stronger perms, since the maps are more likely to be seen and mice from the mapcrew could see the maps in action and the reaction of other mice.

Other Permanent maps from other categories could be added, but as it would be randomly generated maps, these maps wouldn't be played so often, or it could be purely P1.

Just an Idea. Sorry if it has already been suggested.

Supporters:
Brainsneeze
Schelewillem
Shamousey
Ponystar

This seems pointless, P1 maps are often less qualified, how about a room for good shaman maps?

But surely the same maps would be repeated too often, and would get boring very quickly.
Also there is room shaman.

Depends, most vanilla maps would be in rotation, a lot of maps with mechanisms require a shaman, and the permed shaman maps would get more competetive to be added to rotation.

/support

I see a lot of the same maps like art and mech,
p1 room would be fun to play and a lot of deversity

Hatoncat a dit :

Depends, most vanilla maps would be in rotation, a lot of maps with mechanisms require a shaman, and the permed shaman maps would get more competetive to be added to rotation.

But my main point was that in normal rooms maps are often repeated, so in a 'good shaman map' room, maps would be repeated more often than in normal rooms as there would be less maps.
Thats why a purely P1 room would offer a good variety of maps which would be less likely to see maps being seen twice or more in short amount of time.

And like i said in my previous point, there is room shaman.

@Catonhat
The discussion if a room with shaman maps would or would not be better than a P1 room is completely out of the question. This is about the pros and cons of whodat's idea: a P1 room.

Personally, I am in favor of both these rooms, for all of the reasons called above me.


ps: I would also love to see a shaman-room, so why not both?!

I dont like cats
or hats

I don't know why we don't have specific rooms for all the higher perms and P1s yet. I know this has been suggested before, but I can't find a topic about it, so I'll support here.

This room would be hated so much..

Shamousey a dit :

I don't know why we don't have specific rooms for all the higher perms and P1s yet. I know this has been suggested before, but I can't find a topic about it, so I'll support here.

This. Support.