It's an issue with the cache of the forum. You'll have both show up.

So i made an icon and i tried to upload it but now i have this icon that is ages old- FROM A SITE THAT THREATENED ME!!!!! Now im kinda screwed this this lame icon and i try to change it but this toyger cat with a white backround keeps popping up!!!

Mine took like 45 minutes to load. Just have patience, it'll show up soon

okay then