Saved 10 mice on a dual sham map with divine and it counted for only saving 1. Not the first time this has happened to me either. Anyone else have this bug?
--Look at top of chat to see bug proof--

Did the other shaman went in before you? That may be the reason why there is that one 'save'. I know for a fact that the save counter has been inaccurate ever since the game launched but if the saves still count in your profile then it shouldn't be a huge problem.