I loved the first contest, the idea is absolutely amazing but unfortunately for the second edition, I thought it was just too hard for most people. You guys are not allowing ppl to share their answers but lmao be honest you can't check anything and regarding how hard most of your enigmas are it's not really encouraging people not to cheat. I'm especially disappointed to read Sollyun's comment and how some were disqualified since I believe many others cheated but you can't prove anything.

Also I'm not convinced by the clue about Giovanni creating Mewtwo. And pls stop calling these charades it's not charades x.x

However I really appreciate the efforts you put into this contest and some outfits were really cool and inventive, but if there's a third edition I hope you'll take our feedbacks into account.

Katow a dit :

I loved the first contest, the idea is absolutely amazing but unfortunately for the second edition, I thought it was just too hard for most people. You guys are not allowing ppl to share their answers but lmao be honest you can't check anything and regarding how hard most of your enigmas are it's not really encouraging people not to cheat.

I'm going have to respectfully disagree with the sentiment that the contest was "too easy" when 110 participants got all 51/51 answers correct. A far swing from last year which only had 53 people get all 50 answers correct.

Yes, some charades were hard, but that's part of challenge in this contest. If everyone is a winner, then the contest is too easy and poses no real difficulty.

I didn't get all 51 correct either, and while I'm still a little disappointed in myself for that, I can also acknowledge that the clues were fair. Seeing who the character was for #25 (the only one I didn't get correct), I can see the the clues and image line up just fine. You're allowed to feel saddened that you didn't win, but it's also important to remember that it's not the Fashion Squad's fault that you couldn't find all the answers.
Some nice folk on Discord even revealed to me a helpful webpage on anime characters with red eyes that listed a fitting description of that charade. The answer was out there, as were the answers to many other charades, I just didn't find it. And that's ok.

Karasu a dit :

[...]

My comment wasn't coming from a place of anger because I couldn't find all 51, I actually did.
All I'm saying is that of all these 100+, winners I very highly doubt even 25 of them did everything on their own. So the only thing I'm saddened about it's to see some were disqualified when, truthfully, probably many many others did the same and will receive all their rewards.

I was disqualified for participating in 2 accounts, the rules do not say that you should only participate with only one account, I request to check IP addresses. I did not share answers and I was disqualified

Marcelamill a dit :

I was disqualified for participating in 2 accounts, the rules do not say that you should only participate with only one account, I request to check IP addresses. I did not share answers and I was disqualified

What about siblings who share the same IP adress? Unfair reasoning for disqualifying people who share the same network.

Discovering the charades is really fun, but the way you organize who should be classified or not is ridiculous. I was disqualified for sending the first charades at a time close to someone from my tribe and that was enough for you to say that I shared answers. When the charades came out we would publish on a Discord channel, and what was the problem with sending at a time close to another member when the charades were easy? Even if each one has their own time to decipher them we don't need much.

Another BR person I'm not even used to talking to showed me that he was disqualified because you BELIEVE he had shared answers with me.

I don't really care about the prizes, but you weren't fair last year and this year you made the same mistake! My friend was disqualified because you think we shared answers, in this case I care. I gave him fraises, and I will give him the ear item because it is within my reach, but YOU were not fair. There are people on this year's list of winners who were disqualified last year, and why do you think that changed? I also know that there are people on the list of winners who shared answers.

Congratulations to all who shared answers and the fashion squad didn't BELIEVE you did. See you next year (I hope no)

Karasu a dit :

[...] Some nice folk on Discord even revealed to me a helpful webpage on anime characters with red eyes that listed a fitting description of that charade. The answer was out there, as were the answers to many other charades, I just didn't find it. And that's ok.

Ok, just a question: This isn't considered as sharing answers? If not, something is wrong here if you check other players' case of being declassified for stuff that hasn't solid proofs to say they were sharing... And just reinforces what I said before on the last page.

Fashion Squad screwed up
seems like it happened before too :)