Leopardspots a dit :

Having a cruel mentor and an abandoning father is no exuse for murdering everyone. He probably would have turned bad anyways. Remember when he beat up Tiny because he was there? He created a villan that nearly destroyed the forest. Remember Stonefur?

Anyways,

Shallooww a dit :

Omg i did not think of that!

Shallooww a dit :

I know, but when you said "Remember when he beat up Tiny because he was there?" Actually, THISTLECLAW comanded him to do that.

Garnetnum a dit :

Really? O.O I have read all de books..

Doyouhaveabonehill?

Shallooww a dit :

I know, but when you said "Remember when he beat up Tiny because he was there?" Actually, THISTLECLAW comanded him to do that.

Leopardspots a dit :

Commanded?
"Let's see what my apprentice thinks."
"I think we should teach him a lesson"

Smoofey a dit :

usually, cats make clans from their first name
so since the cat was wing it should be WingClan...
but whatever. good luck.

Leopardspots a dit :

I was not aware that EchoClan is EmberClan
Or SapphireClan is SilverClan
or RapidClan is SquirrelClan
I don't think anyone actually does that, really.

Smoofey a dit :

Ember is not the first leader. i think the first leader was in breezeclan and i think it was tigerpelt
and Emberstar is not even Ember's name.

Leopardspots a dit :

I was not aware that EchoClan is EmberClan
Or SapphireClan is SilverClan
or RapidClan is SquirrelClan
I don't think anyone actually does that, really.