Rotation Officielle - P8

Rotation Officielle - P8 - Deux Chamanes

#2021

Left as is:
@6536866 - Obsyt – Grounds seems randomly placed. There is no variety on building and the concept can't offer something new/fun.
@6884014 - Andrelionte - I liked how the map works with a single concept, but tests showed new players can't understand how to use the clouds (even though they have friction). Also consumables can easily ruin the shaman's turn.
@6884028 - Andrelionte – I get what you tried to do with the cloud and the map in the simplest form possible. The problem is that not everyone understands what they should do, some of them place b planks inside the cloud (which ruins everything) and some others waste their turn trying to place the right plank above the cloud.
@6884100 - Perecold - Wong category.
@6884189 - Hakanproft - I understand that the main challenge of the map is getting a stable build with the circles as an obstacle; but it results more annoying than enjoyable.
@6872008 - Godmcb - I liked the edits you made to the cheese part, but tests showed is really lengthy, not even experienced shamans could complete it at time.
@6882858 - Tdpnice - Cute design but the ices at the middle have no use at all. Don't think this can offer something new/fun.
@6883777 - Tdpnice - The gameplay is pretty unbalanced. The whole upper part of the map has no use at all.
@6360633 - Framnm - I have seen a lot of maps with the same design, I don't think this can offer something to P8 category.
@6711291 - Quinzinhojr - You did pretty well with the decoration and the design, but the build is a mess due to the big cloud. There is no variety of building and it results frustrating.
@6887944 - Krzysztof90 - Concept involves only ramp builds which results boring and generic.
@6887967 - Krzysztof90 - I have seen a lot of maps with the same hole, cheese and mice position. Also I don't understand why you used grass with woods (it is unnecessary) and the grass below the cheese it's annoying.
@6889490 - Mousezxcvbn - The map is still cramped. If you really want to use clouds on shaman maps, try to leave a LOT of space between them, since it’s annoying that the only challenge is dealing with cramped spaces rather than being creative or solving puzzles.
@6889531 - Mousezxcvbn - Grounds seems randomly placed. Try to be more creative.
@6801791 - Mquk - Anticlouds have no use at all, you can ignore them without problem. Also this can only offer horizontal/vertical builds that we already have in a lot of P8 maps.
@6872900 - Mquk – Test showed some shamans didn’t understand what is going on with the anticlouds, also you can ignore them and the build wouldn’t be affected.
@6892973 - Fuzzyfirsdog - You mixed a lot of concepts on this map, don't think it could work for normal rotation. Remember that shaman maps are for some new and low experienced players; try keep experimenting new concepts but with simpler maps.
@1623334 - Wangan – I enjoyed the simplicity of this map but we already have enough shaman maps with water, and this one can’t offer something new/fun to rotation.
@6524502 - Wangan - The cheese at the top left seems useless and the map can only offer and horizontal/vertical build which is nothing new/fun.
@6860888 - Viniciusdara – Concept is not well implemented, it feels more like an experiment.
@3916319 - Sekui – It was a good idea adding the scrolling screen but now that I see, this map can’t offer something new/fun. Also the cloud results useless since it’s easier to build from above.
@6855744 - Tennistete – I loved the building but tests went really bad, this results difficult for some players. I would suggest you to leave the hole and cheese part like they already are. Just try to add/edit something so it can be slightly easier for shamans. Maybe you can add a horizontal stone ground somewhere so shamans have enough space to start their build (if you are going to add another stone ground, do your best to avoid cramped spaces).

P1'ed:
@6873041 - Eliaspdc – P1 will be fine for this.

Will be discussed:
@2174093 - Sekui –
@6866988 - Mabste –
@6833334 - Quinzinhojr –
@6334808 - Framnm – I liked the simplicity of this map even though it is slightly generic. I would like to give it a try in discussion
@6840658 - Ujkos – I think it is good enough to put it in discussion. I would ask you to fix shamans spawn; I think you forgot to place them where they were before.

Ignored:
@6883567 - Matheusferei - Blacklisted
@6894038 - Matheusferei – Blacklisted
@6867984 - Fuzzyfirsdog – Still in discussion.

Dernière modification le

#2022

@6896669

Dernière modification le

#2023

@6892973 edited

( Also the map you ignored isn't in discussion any more : ( )

Dernière modification le

#2024

@6711291 - Edit

#2025

@6897085

#2026

@4649979

Dernière modification le

#2027

@6898493

#2028

@6898554
@4362362

Dernière modification le

#2029

@3000460

#2030

@6828888

#2031

@6104593

#2032

[Modéré par Batt_mellamy, raison : Spam]

#2033

@6733400

Dernière modification le

#2034

@6901410
Two shams on the two chocolate grounds

#2035

@272289

#2036

@6658448-edited

#2037

@6840658-Reshman,you forgot to put this map back to P32 or?

#2038

@6861090

#2039

@6855744 -Edited
@6902799

Dernière modification le

#2040

@4999243

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue