Rotation Officielle - P8

#2278

Left as is:
@3175975 - Reppam - I've already played a few maps with this concept and none of them seemed to work as well. This one, in my opinion, isn't an exception, since treadmills aren't executed in a shaman-friendly way and it's more of something painful than fun or new. Moreover, the map isn't really enjoyable for cooperation - it's quite easy to mess everything up and ruin buildings. Treadmills are misaligned, some of them, like the middle one are placed above the wood ground and shamans can't use them as support. Keeping as it is.
@6995314 - Pjfsamora - The shaman spawn ground and ice are quite useless, plus the map itself looks very random because of the grounds organization, and it's too similar to a lot of maps we already have in rotation. I can't see the map working as a filler because it's very common, even if the simplicity is harmless. Also, I dislike that there is basically no building variety + creativity.
@6936070 - Pjfsamora - Too complicated even for two shamans, cloud is placed in a not very good place to build on, most of the newer shaman will have troubles about building properly there, which isn't fun for the shaman. Try to make a better support for their builds and edit the cloud part, making it a bit easier. The use of portals isn't terrible and maybe after edits it deserves a chance of P8.
@6996862 - Bequerr - Both holes of shaman spawn are visually ugly and not even necessary, plus the planks are quite unneeded too. Overall the map isn't fun for cooperation and wouldn't really offer much for the rotation as a high perm. Gameplay is shomehow repetitive and it's basically the same sort of solution every time. The whole bottom right is completely useless.
@6996493 - Okpatinhos - I'm not a really fan of this map. Firstly, it's obvious that no one is going to build from the bottom of the map since it's easier building through the upper part, which makes the gameplay tedious and repetitive. Also, the grounds are organized in a way that remember a lot of dual shaman maps that already exist; There is nothing really fun or new here to take in consideration.
@6883670 - Quinzinhojr - Found it boring and very repetitive in terms of solutions since it's basically the same every time it plays, which is tedious and not fun for the shaman. Moreover, it doesn't have a cool cooperation aspect, the map is too long and too short at certain points. Overall there is nothing really appealing or fun here, the concept is very common and actually annoying, making the map unneeded for rotation.
@6548868 - Pratton - Firstly, it's not cool the massive deaths in the start - mice keep trying to reach the upper platforms and most of them just die. It's painful for the shamans. However, wind is utilized in an okay way with the simplicity of this map. The map has enough space for build variety and creativity with gaps to use as support, but cooperation still doesn't seem so good for me, plus it's disappointing how the whole upper right is useless.
@5962871 - Tioyudis - Cloud is a very painful obstacle and I'm sure that newer mice and even average ones would have difficulties about building properly since it's too time consuming and require pretty much of experience, which makes it unsuitable for rotation.
@7000939 - Imortaliss -
@3000460 - Sekui - Not a bad concept, but buttons aren't really stable since they keep oscilating for everyone excpet the sync. It's not a really big problem because you can get the cheese anyway but it's kinda boring, would be cool if you fix it. Also, I don't really appreciate too much of vertical building in this map, it makes everything tiring and less fun for cooperation only.
@6597152 - Gobbek - The concept doesn't really work in public, even if it has two shamans. It still causes too many deaths because mice can easily reach the pressure grounds and kill themselves accidentally which is frustrating for the shaman, plus it's a not really good map to build on, the space is too limited and easy to mess everything up.
@7000744 - Pudimcb -
@7002262 - Aj0307 -
@6561401 - Bataatiinha - This map doesn't flow well in public rooms, mostly because it's too cramped and water is a very annoying obstacle and hard to avoid, especially the middle one. I don't like how it lacks in building variety + creativity too, overall it's just not fun to shaman on.
@4698432 - Fernandoooh - Same as above, plus the concept is overused and you basically only have to do slanted buildings everytime which annoys the shaman. Water isn't really useful, or doesn't offer much of an obstacle.
@6991137 - V_21 - Overall there is nothing really appealing or fun here, the concept is very common and actually annoying, making the map unneeded for rotation. Chocolate grounds aren't really useful and the map itself is too repetitive in terms of solutions.
@6996966 - V_21 - The use of clouds is tedious plus the concept itself reminds me of an already existent dual shaman map in rotation. Middle cloud is useless.

P1'ed:
@6888899 - Viniciusdara -
@6966669 - Quinzinhojr -
@6996631 - Mabste -
@7005849 - Krato -
@6780352 - Souris_Fram -

Will be discussed:
@7000805 - Tdpnice -
@7000631 - Tdpnice -
@6462721 - Framnm - Interesting map for creativity and I feel it's correctly balanced (both paths for cheese and hole), which is awesome. It might be confusing for newer shamans to figure out the concept but it's not too complicated at all. This map works fine as a filler, so I'm saving the map code for a future high perm. P32'ed
@1929108 - Aksale -
@7005317 - Shamapas -
@1979005 - Sekui - It's actually a good map for cooperation, the use of buttons is friendly and not so frustrating to handle with. I don't really appreciate the scrolling feature in the map because of the aiming issue, but it's still harmless in my opinion. I'm saving this map for a future high perm as filler, in case of we need it. P32'ed
@4674676 - Fernandoooh -
@6996604 - Mabste -
@6996537 - Ratufufu -

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue