Rotation Officielle - P8

#2392

Left as is:
@7020517 - Pjfsamora - The map is ok, but it is quite boring to build on in my opinion, especially in normal/hard mode. Anticlouds are just overused and this map doesn't bring anything new/interesting.
Besides, cooperation doesn't seem to be needed here. So you should propably try to do something more interesting and challenging.
@1154628 - Jotatavo - Apparently not a map made for rotation.
@6704816 - Krato - In divine mode, the map can be complete with three portals. There's nothing new here, and unfortunelty this kind of map aren't interesting enough anymore.
@1478459 - Viniciusdara - Well, in my opinion the map doesn't have any replay value, it's pretty boring. The block of ice only requires a box and I think having two cheese is pointless.
Moreover the cheese area has a lot of grounds so it's quite cramped of those grounds are mostly useless. I don't think the building is intersting enough here.
@1803787 - Viniciusdara - I like the concept and the design of the map, but cowebs are very frustrating for shamans, especially when you can't avoid them. Here mice can't avoid them, and a mouse w/ a cheese in a coweb is just not enjoyable for the mouse and for the shamans. It will be too messy.
@6743343 - Pratton - I like the map and its design, but with the Recycling skill the map won't be that interesting. Moreover I don't think cooperation is needed.
@7042698 - Framnm - I don't like the map that much, it doesn't require much construction with those clouds, shamans can just put planks on it. And same here, cooperation is not needed.
@7008188 - Framnm - I don't really get the point of the planks, I mean shamans only has to shout them with a bullet and that's all, Also the map doesn't have anything very interesting, the construction needed is quite simple.
@7043783 - Pudimcb - No, people hate antigrav map and this one is particularly complicated. If you really want to keep trying something in antigrav remember that it has to be very very simple. Antigrav is already complicated enough for most.
@7043790 - Bataatiinha - The map looks nice, but shamans can't be creative here, they have to follow the only path they had. Moreover the map requires many little ramp/bridge buildings, but it is pretty annoying to do for the shamans.
@7044397 - Mousechris - I like the concept, but with the actual skills that alomost everyone has today, it will not work properly in public.
@5921754 - Tryhardracer - Overall the map is ok, but there're few things that need to be improve: First the gaps are too tight, and it will mess up the buildings at a point or another. Secondly, I dont' think the clouds near the cheese is needed, or at least it should'nt be that big - it makes the area cramped, that's annoying.
@7026054 - Shamapas - It is an okey map, but it looks like many others, it doesn't have anything very interesting. Besides I feel like the scrolling is more annoying than usefull here.
@7024046 - Kyclet - People don't like cowebs, and people don't like death tokens so I can't even imagine both together in rotation. Moreover death tokens seem randomly placed, And even if there're not many cowebs, mice will have to go throught it after grabing the cheese and it will be annoying.
@3133713 - Sekui - Les souris peuvent wall jumper sur les sols gris, donc techniquement elles n'ont besoin de l'aide du chaman que pour aller du premier sol en bois au deuxième ; elles peuvent ensuite attraper le fromage seules et monter sur le deuxième rectangle gris.
Par contre il est impossible de rejoindre le trou juste en poussant le rectangle (enfin une souris ne peut pas toute seule en tout cas - peut être qu'a 20 ca passe), le chaman devra certainement utiliser un boulet.
Mais l'aide du chaman reste quand même très limitée, les souris peuvent faire le plus gros tout seul - il n'y a clairement pas besoin de deux chamans.
@7047406 - Poteerfotter - The map is ok, but I feel it is a bit boring, the concept is overused, and this map won't bring anything new into rotation.
@6333742 - Jfrl - To be honest, I'm not a huge fan of those big clouds, and many shamans aren't either. It kills the creativity, shamans don't have much place left to build properly.
@5702311 - Jfrl - In divine mode, the map can be complete with three portals, this kind of map don't work anymore in public with skills and divine mode...
@7047814 - Kimsterjay - Looks like some maps we arleady have and to be honest I don't like having such a big cloud in the middle of the map, it's too annoying for the shaman.
@7047847 - Kimsterjay - It's super annoying to build on, it is too cramped and the building needed is not interesting enough in my opinion. Many mice will struggle.
@7048051 - Jampavia1119 - Doesn't require much building, it is not a shaman map - especially not a cooperation map.
@7000607 - Victorgabino - The map is alright, but the death tokens are more than useless in my opinion, mostly because the mouse are spwanning in the bottom, and shamans can easily move with skills or whatever. Also, I'm not sure cooperation is needed. But it is nice to build on it in divine mode.
@7000606 - Victorgabino - The clouds are annoying for shamans, the mech thing seems useless and is very annoying too in my opinion. Honestly I think it's a very boring map to sham on.
@7050619 - Poteerfotter - The map is not very interesting, the grounds seem randomly palced, the clouds are useless, and the construction is not very interesting to do. It just seems too random.
@7050738 - Therocksong - The map has too much grounds to be interesting in my opinion; the path is generic and shamans can't be very creative and the ice obstacles are boring, an anvil is enough to go through it.
You should let more space for the shaman, having only one path is not good.
@7053575 - Yuugiooohhhh - I think the two ice blocks make the map boring, I understand that it supposed to make the map more challenging but it's too big to be enjoyable.
@7053662 - Yuugiooohhhh - The map looks great, but many shamans don't like water, and most of them struggle with it. It will be difficult for many to reach the hole with the water.
@6972350 - Frejkuon - First of all, I think the grounds could be better aligned, then the map is quite boring to do, the path is generic and the shamans can't be creative on it. It doesn't bring anything new.
@7056477 - Liipeisback - The map is ok but honeslty it doesn't bring anything, it doesn't worth an high perm in my opinion it just looks like many others.
@6923025 - Tarptiflo - The map is fine as P1, it doesn't worth an higher perm, it's not very interesting.
@7059091 - Branqueliton - It's not enough for a shaman map, it must be more challenging. Here the cloud is completly useless and doesn't bring anything to the map. Look at the actual P8 in rotation to understand what is expected.
@5757031 - Ratufufu - The concept could be interesting but I think it is not well executed here, I think a ground is not enough, there should be more than that.
@7062461 - Thermitez - Nice symmetry, but the area where the mice spwan is cramped and we already have a lot of symmetrical P8 in rotation.
@875944 - Rikkeshang - The map is ok, but in my opinion it doesn't look very good and in divine mode, you can complete it with three or four planks, so I don't think it worth an higher perm, especially for cooperation.
@765989 - Rikkeshang - As I said to some other maps with portals before, you can complete the map with three portals here if you're in divine mode or if you have the right skills. If the portals is well put, you can grab the cheese and then fall on the wood, no construction needed.

P1'ed:
None

Will be discussed:
@6914931 - Pjfsamora - We'll see what the others think about this one.
@7042885 - Okpatinhos - The path is maybe too linear and simple, but still, I like it.
@7042911 - Okpatinhos -
@4980792 - Reppam - Quite simple but nice design.
@4971494 - Reppam - Nice simple concept.
@7043175 - I_Eat_Cheese -
@1132318 - Sekui - Le concept en soir a déjà été utilisé dans plusieurs autres cartes auparavant, mais c'est assez sympa, on va voir ce que les autres en pensent.
@7000035 - Pratton - I definitly like this map - it might be a bit too complicated for newers tho.
@7045316 - Shamapas - I don't really get the utility of the cloud, and I'm not sure cooperation is necessary here, but I think it's great enough to worth a discussion.
@7058789 - Tioyudis - Nice design.
@6989128 - Mquk - Je ne suis pas convaincue de l'utilité du sol en bas à gauche, mais la map est bien dans l'ensemble.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue