Rotation Officielle - P8

#2479

Left as is:
@7000400 - Pjfsamora - I like the design and I think the map is pretty interesting, however I think some clouds should be deleted/reduced because it kills shamans' creativity, especially in the cheese area. I particularly disliked the cloud below the cheese.
@6924069 - Pjfsamora - Same as above, the map is quite nice but there're too many clouds and some are just useless. It makes the map cramped, and to be honest that's really annoying for a shaman to build with clouds everywhere. The one below the hole seems especially pointless.
@7073755 - Zombiewd - The map is simple but honestly it didn't convince me, only few planks are needed to complete the map.
In divine mode I can complete the map alone in 40s, it wouldn't be better in normal/hard mode. Actually grounds seem to be put randomly, I think shamans will always build the same way around it.
@7086612 - Ratufufu - The idea is good, but I'm afraid most of the players will struggle with it, the anti-clouds make the map really cramped, and even if it make difficult to build on it, especially when you have to build path between them so mice could climb up and go the cheese. Without springs it's tricky and easy to mess up.
@6893153 - Framnm - Well to be honest I didn't like it at all. First the design could be better, then the ground at the left seems useless, even if the shamans can use it to build. Besides the construction is very generic and the map doesn't require cooperation.
@6749884 - Krato - The double mice spawn seems a bit useless but why not. However I didn't like the fact that shamans can't really be creative here, there's only one path, and some area like the cheese's one is tedious. The map is ok, but too boring to build on in my opinion.
@6336666 - Apollopolo - Too many water to be enjoyable. Actually many players struggle with it, and reaching the hole trough the water is easy to mess up, especially in cooperation.
@7085996 - Tarciomaneri - First thing; some grounds like those above the shamans and mice's spawn are useless. Clouds are also annoying. Then the maps doesn't require an interesting building, it only needs few planks or even 2 springs only. You should think at something more enjoyable for the shaman, and more original so shamans will have fun on it.
@3000460 - Sekui - Il a déjà pas mal de maps avec le même mécanisme, La construction n'est pas super intéressante, est un des deux chamans sera toujours plus ou moins bloqué parce qu'il devra resté sur un des boutons (à part si il est en mode divin...). Je pense que le concept peut être mieux exploité que ça.
@3608685 - Sekui - Mouais, la map est ok, mais la grande barre de glace à côté du fromage est super ennuyante pour les shamans, et je ne suis pas sûre que le passage avec l'eau sera beaucoup utilise, il serait plus simple de construire complétement à gauche mais bon... En soit la map n'est pas si mal mais elle est particulièrement ennuyante pour construire dessus.
@7083219 - Maxislow - There're a lot of clouds here that make the map cramped and to be honest there're quite useless. The construction will be tedious because shamans won't have many place to build anymore. Easy to mess up and in the cheese area it is easier to build offscreen.
@7088544 - Yuugiooohhhh - The map is ok the but water on the cheese is totally pointless, it doesn't change anything to the gameplay but it makes things weird. And to be honest the map is not very original, it only needs a large bridge and a ramp.
@7091689 - Yuugiooohhhh - I don't get your think with huge amount of water honestly. Although the map is ok, but not very original and quite boring to do in my opinion.
@6816667 - Tdpnice - The right side is not very useless even if the shamans can use it, but I feel this map doesn't have anything really interesting and we already have a lot of similar maps in P4/P8 rotation.
@6809774 - Tdpnice - I like the design, but basically it requires a large bridge and a ramp, this is not fun for a shaman and it clearly doesn't need cooperation.
@7091502 - Pastalls - Unfortunately the map is not interesting enough for a shaman, the building is too generic, it always be the same construction and it is nor original. Moreover I don't think the map needs cooperation. Try to do something more original and challenging for the shamans.
@367892 - Sarkazm - These kind of strong wind map are not very appreciated by the players. We have few of them in rotation but they struggle with them. Moreover the clouds here add some difficulty, it is not necessary, it will be a mass death. And in divine mode you don't have any point to begin your construction, that's an issue.
@7092810 - Poteerfotter - Simple maps are always enjoyed, but it's too simple to be interesting here.
@7092819 - Poteerfotter - Same as above, not interesting a box and few planks are enough to complete the map. Furthermore both maps don't need cooperation.
@7090900 - Mquk - Il y a déjà quelques maps uniquement compsées de cercle en P4, et même si j'aime bien le concept il est compliqué pour les chamans les moins expérimentés de trouver un point d'accroche stable pour démarrer leur construction. De plus la map pourrait être plus esthétique.
@7092481 - Arthiforum - I like the concept, it's nice thought for cooperation. However I'm not sure it will work well in public. After some tests, it turns out shamans don't understand the concept of the map and everyone die within 40s. Even if a shaman use cannons, it's too hard, the tests were awful.

P1'ed:
None

Will be discussed:
@7084460 - Ratufufu - Simple but has a nice design, I liked it.
@6277112 - Framnm - If built in a clever way, the map only requires few planks. For now the ground in the right side is useless, but I'll put it in discussion for P4 and we'll probably edit the shaman spawn on the right upper ground.
@7036748 - Krato - Wind maps are always a bit tricky but this one seems fine and enjoyable.
@6809385 - Quinzinhojr - Nice original design.
@6300150 - Viniciusdara - I liked this.
@7043790 - Bataatiinha - I don't think the mech is actually useful but I kinda liked it. Nice random gift btw.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue