Rotation Officielle - P8

#2690

Left as is:
@7054724 - Maxislow - In my last review, I suggested that you should add more to your map to give the shamans some more obstacles to go through, because currently the map is pretty easy. Moving the cheese to the upper right adds some to the gameplay, but not much. I still stand by my previous review, add more to the gameplay and we'll see
@7116265 - Maxislow - The route on this map is pretty limited and boring. On shaman maps, you want to offer multiple paths towards the cheese and hole, and this map obviously only has a single route, which restricts the shamans' creativity in terms of building. Also, this map is not really a two shaman effort
@7163948 - Fosoundkems - I understand what you did with the newly applied edits, however, you've taken your map from pretty easy to pretty dull. The gameplay only really consists of a big V shape build with ramps on each end, making the gameplay on this map boring to shaman on
@7162184 - Fosoundkems - This map is definitely getting better, but we're not quite there yet, we still need to do a few more edits to this map before even considering. The first issue is that a giant bridge along the bottom would be the easiest route, and then placing a bunch of ramps up to the cheese. Another issue is that the gameplay is a little boring, please do something about that
@7173304 - Thegbc - Your map doesn't need two shamans to complete, in fact it might be a little easy for a single shaman as well.
@7165954 - Pingouuu - The added stone + moved spawn below the cheese will definitely help, but the major flaw is that the gameplay is pretty boring. The only task each shaman would have is to just build a bunch of ramps going upward, all the way to the hole.
@4560789 - Uuviinhasz - Your map seems to have random grounds, there's no theme to your map, although that isn't a big issue. The main problem with your map is that the gameplay is boring, and rather bland. The map doesn't encourage shamans to be creative
@4391577 - Uuviinhasz - Same as your other map, this map doesn't encourage shamans to be creative because the map only consists of building a bunch of ramps all the way to the top. Try to give your maps fun gameplay, without compromising interest
@4464907 - Pgmsule - You have improved this map a little since the last review, and it definitely shows, however, this map is still pretty boring to build on. The bottom only needs a bridge, and then the shamans would simply need to remove the planks and build 2 ramps to the hole. Nothing interesting so I would suggest trying something new
@6222906 - Pgmsule - I see that you tried at least to make the map better, however the map is still pretty dull. On the right side of the map, a shaman would just have to build two ramps to get up, and on the left, the other shaman would have to build a support and then a ramp. The gameplay is not interesting enough for public rotation.
@7000012 - V_Ntage - The players on the top right are still as isolated as the last review. The bottom shamans will always go for the bottom mice first, and then a ramp to the cheese, then hole while leaving the mice in the top right to wait the entire time. Waiting is boring, please try to find a way to fix that problem
@6682193 - Zeleny - The map's gameplay is not that interesting, one shaman would build a hang support under the cheese and the other would cannon the wood and then a simple ramp to the hole. Nothing fun in this
@7000610 - V_21 - I see what you tried to do, but the cloud doesn't really give much of a difference between your last version and now. A lot of shamans won't get discouraged from it, but instead use a small plank to create a small bridge right through it. Try to come up with something that will help balance the map out
@6991669 - V_21 - The right side of the map is a lot easier than the left, making the map very unbalanced for the shamans
@7173971 - Gamog - The gameplay on this map isn't very interesting. Both shamans would just need to build a bunch of ramps on both sides, which can be very dull and boring to build for both shamans.
@7107714 - Yuugiooohhhh - The shamans were able to complete the map within 40 seconds, making the map pretty simple for two. You should try submitting this for P4 and see what those guys say
@7149662 - Yuugiooohhhh - This map is pretty similar to a lot of maps that are already in rotation. That being said, this map doesn't offer anything new that is better than the ones in rotation
@7110496 - Framnm - Majority of the shamans who play on this map will end up taking the same route everytime, which is taking the bottom route to the cheese, and then going left to the hole. This map doesn't offer much, making the gameplay bland
@6517484 - Obsyt - The map requires a lot of ramp building on the cheese side and to the hole, which can get very boring for the shamans to have to build
@6556315 - Obsyt - This map only offers one route for the shamans, making the gameplay on this boring. Also, this map doesn't need two shamans to complete

P1'ed:
@6290095 - Framnm - The bottom cheese may be a little too hard but the map offers various amounts of space for a lot of different builds
@7116969 - Pjfsamora - Your map gives a lot of freedom for shamans to build however they like, but your map isn't enough for a P8

P8'ed:
None

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue