Rotation Officielle - P8

Rotation Officielle - P8 - Deux Chamanes

#3221

@7414377
@7414379

#3222

@5437764

#3223

@4077906

#3224

@6821615

#3225

Some maps might have been skipped by the tool so please stop putting quotes in your comments or your map won't be reviewed.
Left as is:
@7398618 - Papelio%230000 - Already in discussion.
@7404599 - Bushmeister%230000 - The map is way too cramped, the shaman can barely build on it. The clouds are mostly unecessary.
@7405006 - Meigyn%230000 - I get the idea of the map but some areas are a bit cramped in my opinion and mostly the path is too generic/boring to do. The replay value is low since the shamans will always have to take the same path.
@7195285 - John%239081 - The map is ok but remind me very much many grass/ice maps we already have in P8 rotation. The lack of variety is an issue, especially because this map only requires a long bridge and two ramps.
@7405797 - Matzi%231510 - The map is too cramped, death tokens are too numerous and make the map really unfunny to build on.
@7405826 - Matzi%231510 - The map would be ok without the cloud on the hole which is killing the gameplay right now. Although, I do think the map has some potential.
@7401337 - Fastyle%230000 - Here the map mostly requires a long bridge and two ramps, and to be honest the wind makes it quite annoying. I feel like it lacks of originality.
@7406346 - Nullalkeed%231259 - Once again the map is too cramped, the shamans will have huge troubles trying to build on it and the clouds are very useless here. Plus there's only one path so the replay value is pretty low.
@7408274 - Nullalkeed%231259 - Same here, the map is lacking of originality, it only requires a bridge and too ramps, the top part of the map won't be used and it's just too generic overall.
@7391882 - Brenow%234577 - As much as I think the map is interesting, antigrav map are way too hard for the average players, and this one will be almost impossible to complete for them.
@7407613 - Fakedoaero%230000 - The map is pretty confusing, the grounds suggest they're not colliable with objects but they're so it's weird. Moreover there're a lot of things in this map but it ends up being cramped and uninteresting to do.
@7367145 - Urook%231131 - The concept is interesting but there're too much death tokens and it's pretty complicated to build here without blocking everything especially in the cheese area. For now it'll only be a mass death.
@7410529 - Stefanmocarz%230000 - Too cramped, the clouds are not necessary and the wind is way too strong for the map to be playable.
@7411185 - Stefanmocarz%230000 - Same as above, the clouds are not necessary, the huge amount of water doesn't bring anyhting to the map and the path is way too generic.
@7411486 - Teuvmt%230000 - Way too cramped near the cheese especially and hidden ground under; grounds should not be hidden like that.
@7071615 - Taleguguy%230000 - Same, too cramped, clouds are not useful, and the only path is pretty boring.
@7264036 - Fram%234747 - The map is to generic to be truly interesting, it mostly requires a bridge and some ramps, which is honestly quite boring to do.
@7410155 - Deadlag%230095 - The map pretty much only needs a bridge and a ramp, the shamans won't have much to do, and it's not very innovative.
@7068420 - Mquk%230000 - J'aime bien l'idée et le design de la carte mais je pense que certains espaces sont trop serrés et je n'aime pas trop l'espace à côté du trou qui oblige le shaman à construire par en bas pour le retour. Peut-être que diminuer la taille des plus gros sols pourrait être une solution pour laisser un peu plus d'espace.
@7413917 - Cuphea%230000 - Les cartes symétriques ne sont que peu intéressantes et celle là n'apporte rien de nouveau par rapport à ce qui est déjà en rotation.
@7414377 - Cheezecream%230000 - The map is really minimalist and uninteresting to build on.
@7414379 - Cheezecream%230000 - Same as above.
@5437764- Brunoav%230000 - Too much useless grounds, not enough space to build and mainly too cramped.
@4077906 - Anjodanet%230000 - I kinda understand the concept but it's not interesting, the shamans only have to build a long ramps and a bridge here, it's not enjoyable.
@6821615 - Kavazzak%230000 - Same here, too many useless grounds and not enough space to build properly and be creative. The path is too generic. Besides the hole seems like it has randomly been placed.
@6683315 - Smutny_Nalesnik%230000 - It feels like some grounds are pretty useless and are taking too much space which is then pretty annoying to build around. Overall the map is just too generic and the unique path makes the replay value too low to be interesting.

P1'ed:
@7215807 - Fram%234747 - Although it seems like the map was made a bit randomly the concept is actually pretty interesting.

P8'ed:
@7152665 - John%239081 - Not sure it wil work properly but I'll give it a shot.
@6995238 - Fastyle%230000 - I'm not sure cooperation is needed here but I kinda liked the map and I thought building on it was quite interesting.
@7412502 - Vintage%230246 - The layout is pretty minimalist but the map is still interesting to build on.
@6450000 - Uelintondd%230000 - Not fully convinced by it, mainly because a shaman will have to stay near the mech all the time, but we'll see.
@7400014 - Smutny_Nalesnik%230000 - Ok map I guess.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#3226

@6999945
@7355667

Dernière modification le

#3227

@7405826 - edited
@7337416

Dernière modification le

#3228

@7400014
@7400015

Dernière modification le

#3229

@7418002

Dernière modification le

#3230

[Modéré par Killerlux, raison : Spam]

#3231

@6987179
@7008188

Dernière modification le

#3232

@7195285
@7423781

Dernière modification le

#3233

@7418822 <3

#3234

@4103321
#Edited

#3235

@2781420

#3236

@2621614

edited

Dernière modification le

#3237

@7420408

#3238

@7246438

#3239

@7421971

#3240

@3725649
@3623250

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue