Rotation Officielle - P8

Rotation Officielle - P8 - Deux Chamanes

(The review was not done by me. )

Left as is:
@7608416 - Blackout#6525 - The first problem I see, is the fact that there are not good supports for shaman start building in the map. Also, the map would bring nothing new or interesting to rotation.
@7627502 - Faizoz#6668 - Nothing outstanding in this map. We have already seen some maps like that in the past years. Besides, you don't need to do anything but a bridge and use the portals.
@4651014 - Sekui#0000 - The map seems to be fun, however, the mechanism is unstable, try to fix it and submit the map again. To be honest, I believe there is no need of two shamans in this map, I recommend you to submit the map for Shaman (P4) rotation once it is fixed.a
@6375905 - Ork#0015 - The map is quite boring because it uses the same build structure for both the cheese and the hole. All the shamans has to do is build a bridge and a ramp on both sides and given the restrictive nature of the route, the build will look similar without much variation
@7630723 - Cyanny#0000 - The map is very hard for rotation, the most of players won't be able to complete due to this fact. In addition to this, the map is confusing to understand what is needed to be done, for example: the dynamic ground looks like an anti-cloud ground.
@6367739 - Fram#4747 - Nothing interesting in this map, it can be completed by a bridge and a ramp up to the upper platforms. Good as is (P1).
@7110496 - Fram#4747 - First of all, the map is confusing. It is not as clear as it should that all ice grounds can move. It can ruin the shaman's building. Also, the ice grounds are very big which is not a good thing since the main challange for maps like that is building. P22.
@2915048 - Semaj#1533 - The map layout itself is cramped, which means, it is going to be hard to build. In reggarding to this, the space available to pass thru the skulls it's not enough, in other words, it is going to lead to mass death.
@7636553 - Wed#0000 - There isn't supports to start building. You can use both the left and right sides and the middle part of the map which are all empty to add different paths to follow and interesting obstacles which is going to increase the map gameplay. On a side note, the anti-clound grouds wasn't a great addition to the map.
@7635554 - Deadlag#0095 - Playing in maps which uses the cobwebs like that are very annoying. In addition to this, the map can be completed building a bridge and a ramp up to the cheese and hole.

P1'ed:
None

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#3562

@7639363

#3563

@7639390

#3564

@3151428

#3565

@7636030

#3566

@7641141

Dernière modification le

#3567

@6091213

#3568

@7641706

#3569

@7642068
@7593019

Dernière modification le

#3570

@7630723

#3571

@7643955

#3572

@6128896
@6117506

#3573

@5839754

#3574

@4262316

#3575

Left as is:
@7639363 - Smutny_Nalesnik#0000 - Map is too simple for a single shaman, let alone two shamans. Although there is freedom to build using different paths, they're all very simple.
@7639390 - Miminou1#0000 - This is not a P8 map. It's a mechanical map, and even for a mechanical map, it's very generic.
@3151428 - Konohs#0000 - This map plays more like a divinity map rather than a normal rotation map. Most shamans might find it hard to build here, as there is hardly anything to support the build. It's boring as well.
@7636030 - Semaj#1533 - There is hardly anything challenging in this map, even if it were intended for P4 instead. All what the shaman has to do is to place a plank for standing below the cheese, and then to use the portals.
@7641141 - Darkphoenix#7764 - The map lacks any challenge. Not only is it linear, but most of it is just building ramps up and down and placing anvils for the mice to make it over the ice. The middle part seems too gimmicky and unnecessary,
@7641706 - Miminou1#0000 - The moving platform with the cheese in the middle seems quite unnecessary because regardless of the positioning of the ramp leading to it, the player will be able to reach the cheese. Rest of the map is very linear and has one-plank-solutions.
@7642068 - Wed#0000 - Map is generic and wind makes it annoying to build in. If something goes wrong and blocks the passage, there is no other path to follow.
@7593019 - Wed#0000 - Some players may get stuck at the spawn. Besides, the map's concept is overused and can just be solved without the other shaman.
@7630723 - Ahmed5206#0000 - Submit your own maps only.
@6128896 - Fram#4747 - It's fine as it is.
@6117506 - Fram#4747 - It's fine as it is.
@5839754 - Cilacapenjoy#0000 - Although the supports are nice, the map is too easy. Shamans will always resort to using the lower ones.
@4262316 - Namelessh#0000 - It's nice that it encourages more use of short planks. However, the map is not interesting and can be finished with just one shaman.

P1'ed:
@6091213 - Cilacapenjoy#0000 - This map is good because there are different paths to take, and not only that, but they also have different challenges.

Will be discussed:
@7643955 - Sewdycreatooor#0873 - The concept is very unique.

Ignored:
None

#3576

@5897208
@7645882

Dernière modification le

#3577

[Modéré par Etyla, raison : Double post]

#3578

@7642068
@7593019
-Edited

#3579

@7648295

#3580

@7651614

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue