Concours Officiel de Cartes Vanilla

Concours Officiel de Cartes Vanilla - Avril-Mai 2020

[Modéré par Bog, raison : Unnecessary. You're free to use reaction gifs, but use words as well.]

@6422193 - 2 cheese!

Tdft a dit :
-

Relaxa que eu não tô querendo tirar o mérito de ninguém que foi aprovado não, só acho que as coisas deviam ser mais justas e os mapas mais bem avaliados.

Dernière modification le

#424

Mquk, you're right.. And those maps really don't fit vanilla style.

#425

[Modéré par Lusk, raison : Unnecessary.]

#426

Je crois que tout le monde est d'accord Mquk, d'ailleurs la shortlist devrait carrément ressembler à ça...

#427

Scary.I still didn’t check the maps. I posted earlier my opinion about adding more maps to the shortlist but now that I see some decent critical feedback regarding the quality of the maps, it seems that there’s really something going very wrong here. Its not just a random worry that, lets confess, the mapcrew would say its because some players maps weren’t included and now they are saying bad things... but this never happened in a contest before. Its serious and needs to be considered.

#428

Mquk a dit :
Category 1

Almost no one in the shortlist really used the concept of dodue in their maps, if you don't look at the additional cheeses you get, the gameplay doesnt change if you remove the dodue parameter. So basically everyone will do the map with 1 cheese to get the first and they won't care about the 2 others cheeses. You're just adding the same maps that vanilla already have with the same gameplay but with additional cheeses (dodue).

[removed]

That could be the ideal mapcrew.

Dernière modification le

#429

Uelintondd a dit :
Mquk a dit :
Category 1

Almost no one in the shortlist really used the concept of dodue in their maps, if you don't look at the additional cheeses you get, the gameplay doesnt change if you remove the dodue parameter. So basically everyone will do the map with 1 cheese to get the first and they won't care about the 2 others cheeses. You're just adding the same maps that vanilla already have with the same gameplay but with additional cheeses (dodue).

[removed]

Esse cara sim ainda devia estar na Mapcrew, um dos poucos que realmente sabe fazer ótimos mapas, entende o que é um mapa bom. E realmente, eu fui um dos poucos que usei o modo dodue="" de uma forma q fosse útil @4189609
(fazendo o piso descer com o peso dos ratos, que aumentava conforme mais pegavam queijos, que eu acho que é essa a ideia desse novo modo, se não, não faz o menor sentido você colocar esse modo e espalhar queijo pelo mapa todo como se fossem queijos normais, porque depois que alguém pegar o primeiro não vai ter a menor chance dessa mesma pessoa ir atrás de outro queijo, a menos que seja necessário).

realmente

Dernière modification le

#430

Oxi esse concurso era de mapas vanilla??

#431

Mquk a dit :
Category 1

Almost no one in the shortlist really used the concept of dodue in their maps, if you don't look at the additional cheeses you get, the gameplay doesnt change if you remove the dodue parameter. So basically everyone will do the map with 1 cheese to get the first and they won't care about the 2 others cheeses. You're just adding the same maps that vanilla already have with the same gameplay but with additional cheeses (dodue).

To be honest, I don't agree that everyone will collect only one of the cheeses and will go straighly to the hole. It's up to the player to collect one of all available cheeses around the map and I think mostly of them will try to collect all of them, since they're getting more cheese to buy their stuff. Of course there will be the ones that are hungry for stats and they will only skip the rest of the map, but I don't think you should apply this to ALL players.

I agree that the mapmakers should try to use this new physics better, if I had time (or desire), I'd try to make some puzzle, but it would require too much efforts from me. I'm bit surprised that my map was accept because of how simple it was, but after all, isn't it's what vanilla is after all, simplicity.

Mquk a dit :
Does the gameplay change if you remove dodue ?

My answer would be YES, it changes the gameplay because there is more available things for the players to do. And it's just up to them to complete it or not, which is cool.

XOXO Quack-san <3

#432

[Modéré par Bog, raison : It's understandable you're upset if your map didn't make it to the shortlist, but attacking those who did is against forum rules. You're free to post your opinion here as long as it's in an educated way and it follows the rules.]

#433

This should be considered, indeed. There were some bad comments in other contests, but this one, it's much worse. It would be nice for the maps in the shortlist to be checked again, more strict in terms of rules and gameplay, and also the rejected maps, as some of them have good potential.

#434

We need justice!

#435

Eremiaovidiu a dit :
This should be considered, indeed. There were some bad comments in other contests, but this one, it's much worse. It would be nice for the maps in the shortlist to be checked again, more strict in terms of rules and gameplay, and also the rejected maps, as some of them have good potential.

It seems to me that it’s best to review all the maps from the topic under strict supervision, although this will take a lot of time

#436

After all, there are no map submissions for vanilla, so MapCrew doesn't specialize in it. This might be a reason why these maps were accepted for shortlist. As I said before, it would be much better if Mapcrew removed bugged, messy maps with no gamelay, poor alignment and other major issues. If a map is balanced, doesn't break any rules, it should be in the shortlist. The admins can have a different opinion.

#437

The problem is that good maps that didn’t get on the shortlist without being checked again cannot be returned.

#438

I asked a question - my message was deleted. Mapcrew, strongly)

#439

Hawis a dit :
Vou responder em português pois não sou obrigada.

Todos sabemos que são os administradores que escolhem os mapas vencedores, nesse caso não seria legal mandar uma lista maior de mapas para eles? Há muitos mapas bons que foram deixados de fora das shortlists, e não estou falando isso por causa dos meus mapas e sim de outros jogadores que tinham mapas bons! Vocês escolhem uma pequena quantidade de mapas que VOCÊS gostaram, mas e a comunidade, como fica neste momento? Vocês chegaram a pensar se eles vão gostar dos mapas? E o mais importante, o conceito VANILLA está nesses mapas? Acho que isso é um ponto importante a ser levado em consideração!

Sobre não desconsiderar os mapas que enviados da maneira incorreta, acho que foi um grande equivoco da parte da equipe! Há um tópico explicando as regras do concurso e como enviar os mapas e também foi dito no tópico do próprio concurso como era para se enviar pois pessoas estavam enviando errado. Mas o que posso fazer? Sou um mero jogador.

Bom, fica aqui meu desapontamento com a equipe e com o concurso!

Boa sorte a todos da shortlist e que vençam os melhores!

É ISSO AÍ!!!!!

FOGO NA MAPCREW!

BUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

DEMOCRACIA JÁ

#440

[Modéré par Bog, raison : Not related to the contest.]

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue