Offizieller Vanilla Map Making Wettbewerb - April/Mai 2020Официальный Конкурс по Созданию Карт в Vanilla: апрель - май 2020April-May 2020 Official Vanilla Map Making ContestContest Ufficiale per la Creazione di Mappe Vanilla Aprile-Maggio 20202020年4月-5月香草地图制作比赛Concours Officiel de Cartes Vanilla - Avril-Mai 2020Április-Május 2020 Hivatalos Vanilla Pályakészítő VersenyConcurso Oficial de Creación de Mapas Vanilla Abril-Mayo 2020Concurso Oficial de Criação de Mapas Vanilla Abril-Maio 2020أبريل-مايو ٢٠٢٠ مسابقة صنع خرائط فانيلا الرسميةOficjalny Konkurs Tworzenia Map Vanilla Kwiecień - Maj 2020Concurs Oficial de Mape Vanilla - Aprilie-Mai 2020תחרות הכנת מפות וונילה הרשמית של אפריל-מאי 2020Nisan-Mayıs 2020 Resmi Vanilla Haritası Yapma YarışmasıApril-Mei 2020 Officiële Vanilla Map Makers Wedstrijd |
10 | ||
Hello all, We are reading every single response throughout the thread and we will express our view for the final time. There will be no changes made to the shortlist, as this is finalised. We spent more time this year to get the shortlist prepared and the maps were checked thoroughly. We understand some of you may be upset that a lot of time and consideration was put into making your maps. We assure you and want to say we acknowledge your efforts and by no means are we forgetting about that. You are free to post your thoughts here in a civilized way, and we're open to any suggestions and constructive criticism you might have. However, we will not allow any comments that are unnecessary or targeting creators of the maps, as this is against the forum rules. Once again, if you have a general query or any issues regarding why your own map(s) was rejected, please contact a MapCrew member. If you have already contacted one, just wait and you'll get replied. Thank you. |
0 | ||
edited Dernière modification le 1590611640000 |
18 | ||
Lei a dit : I tried to explain my thoughts about the maps of the shortlist but a sentinel edited my post tho. You guys clearly use the "i know you're upset about your maps" to minimize our arguments but maybe its time to understand that the mapcrew doesnt give what the community want. |
1 | ||
Вот типичный пример отношения к игрокам |
Miroslavchik « Consul » 1590611280000
| 0 | ||
Mquk a dit : ^^ |
1 | ||
Mquk a dit : How have you been in their team before? Was everything all right there? Dernière modification le 1590611700000 |
15 | ||
I just played (took a fast look) all the shortlist maps and most of them seemed playable and decent. the idea of dodue is just terrible btw, and most of the maps just don't fit with it for a vanilla, that's like cobwebs, imagine having to make a cobweb map to be in vanilla, lmaoo, that would be even worse maybe because people would never really make the best use of them, but in the category 1, like 3 maps really did. it's a delicate category. I mean, it's not a problem if admins go ahead and play them since they follow vanilla criteria. Of course there are also maps I didn't like at all, but that happens because we can't like everything and that's okay. But the point in here is that most of the maps are fine enough to be looked by admins. Being in a shortlist doesn't mean the map will be added. They will be reviewed, again, but by different people. I don't agree with you if you say that most of the maps are terrible and shouldn't be shortlisted because that's not true. Otherwise, I agree that maybe more playable and decent maps could be added to shortlist so there's more variety for admins to play on, like I said in a post in this thread. We never know what admins really want. I remember an old vanilla contest when I was an active player and I was sure about some maps the admins would probably pick from the shortlist to be vanilla, but then I realized I was completely wrong! They picked maps I never thought they would choose because, for me, there were better ones. That proves that the concept of good is pretty much relative, especially for a category that has only a few maps (compared to normal rotation maps) and only two or maybe three people review (admins). If there are more or way more better maps that weren't included in the shortlist, I won't ever know that because I'm not going to play any other map, but I'm pretty sure there is, at least a few more maps. And these could be included in a shortlist. That's fairer and correct. @mapcrew, That's the whole point why people are complaining here. They are unhappy because they have seen their maps and maybe more maps that are also playable and decent and weren't put on list. The vanilla contest should be treated differently, you all should be less picky while reviewing these maps to make a shortlist. Maybe only filter those worst ones, the ones we know that definitely won't be accepted because they don't follow an specific rule or they are just terrible. Dernière modification le 1590612000000 |
0 | ||
Viniciusdara a dit : indireta pra mim fofa? |
Superyacine « Censeur » 1590617640000
| 0 | ||
Ikke a dit : Unless there has been an update, collecting all three of the dodue cheese doesn't give you three cheese in store. People will at first collect all the cheese because it's new and they are curious to what it does. When they realise that the only thing dodue parameter does is increase the weight of the mouse, then they will avoid it. Only few will collect all three for the challenge, and even then, the dodue maps shortlisted don't affect the gameplay because of the way they are positioned. (@6876958, @7660810 - Hard walljump if you collect all three.) Dernière modification le 1590617700000 |
Qadori « Consul » 1590618120000
| 2 | ||
Superyacine a dit : will count three cheeses when categorized obviously |
Viniciusdara « Consul » 1590618540000
| 1 | ||
Jota a dit : graças a deus voce esqueceu desse contest esse ano |
0 | ||
Superyacine a dit : Nop. You will receive 3 cheese in the store and 1 on the profile. |
Perfecteca « Sénateur » 1590625140000
| 2 | ||
wow, almost all dodue maps are nothing different from no dodue versions but if we take what ikke said into account, things change however, if im not wrong, no one was informed - or properly informed - about that people can get max 3 shop cheese in those maps which would have changed many maps and their fates |
Superyacine « Censeur » 1590627120000
| 0 | ||
I played a dodue map in normal category, collected all three cheese for the fun and only received one cheese in shop |
Bhvana « Censeur » 1590627900000
| 0 | ||
The only maps on the shortlist I have approved are @7705718, @6422193, @6842610, @7697563, @6876958, @7499978, and @7699979 |
1 | ||
I am still disappoint that we couldn't have a vanilla Shaman category with no stupid gimmicks. After going over all the maps a little more thoroughly I can say that, for CAT1, the only map that I actually liked was @7697563. I would like @7720110 as well, but the elevator and bridge would need to be removed. Honestly kind of disappointed with these maps overall. I realize this is vanilla we are talking about but there were too many maps that were just stupidly easy considering the mechanic that is involved. It's almost like the majority people who created maps in this category were only concerned with cheese farming. Some of the maps that would be easy to troll or just plain annoying to do in general. Rush maps, collision maps, and maps that didn't use all 3 cheese shouldn't even be considered valid. No comment on CAT2 or CAT3 as I have no real interest there. Perfecteca a dit : This pretty much sums up everything wrong with this category. Dernière modification le 1590630180000 |
Assassin0 « Citoyen » 1590646080000
| 3 | ||
Triste de ver esses paneleiros se perpetuando dentro do sistema do jogo e as crianças parando de jogar a cada dia... Quando vão entender que esse jogo foi feito pra ser simples ? Pegar o queijo ir pra toca ! Reativem o editor de mapas em tempo real e deixem as crianças usarem suas criatividades,como foi em 2010-2011-2012. E deixem o jogo viver seus últimos dias em paz, Adultos Frustrados ! Dernière modification le 1590646740000 |
1 | ||
I hope the administrators are smart and they will select a maximum of 6 good maps from the shortlist. |
Eremia « Censeur » 1590655440000
| 7 | ||
People are not upset because their maps are not on the shortlist, they are upset because you selected some poor-quality maps and rejected some really good ones. |
Eremia « Censeur » 1590655680000
| 1 | ||
Don't pick maps you like, remove maps that don't follow the rules, bugged/glitched ones, crash maps, etc. Leave all the maps that are playable in the shortlist. Admins are supposed to chose from all vanilla maps submitted, except for the ones with problems described above. |