Rotation Officielle - P10

#4937

Left as is:
@5639315 - Ilovejipsy - This is still too similar to what we have discussed.
@5617288 - Maxkkk - The edits have made me realise that the map is just too cluttered and there's really stands out.
@5639381 - Maxkkk - This map has a nice flow to it, but the rotated grounds just feel squashed in place and it really isn't much fun to try and survive on.
@5642245 - Maxkkk - This map's layout reminds me of other survivor maps.
@5645117 - Maxkkk - This map feels also quite cluttered and also outdated. Layout is similar to @307930
@5647603 - Maxkkk - Generic.
@4754296 - Brunoav - Looks very nice, but is quite unfair for mice as it is now. Pyramid-type killing is not very fun, especially if they're unable to get back up in this case. Perhaps move the shaman spawn to the bottom right so that they can use the water. This will allow for cannon jumping so that mice have more opportunity to survive.
@4796246 - Framnm - The design is similar to @489470 but not used as well.
@5641411 - Srdorego - Big bulky grounds and generic layout + alignment could be better.
@5694255 - Srdorego - Generic.
@5641774 - Hea - Not a very entertaining map. As I said earlier, pyramid-type maps are quite frustrating for mice. An experienced shaman can spam hotkeys down the slopes and kill everyone quite fast.
@5637795 - Riptusembra - Visually unappealing, bad alignment and poor gameplay.
@5645922 - Introsc - Every ground is transparent which can be quite annoying for mice. Many mice will try to climb the top middle ground as it doesn't appear to be frictionless which can be quite frustrating.
@5646263 - Nidhalpiw - Generic.
@5647768 - Mariodanci - Generic.
@4849311 - Kemaliya - Unsuitable.
@5649392 - Derkbx - Hole and cheese.
@5559219 - Derkbx - ^ When making survivor maps, do not include a hole and cheese. Export your map as a tribe house.
@5557021 - Joseventus - Not very appealing. Alignment could be better in some areas. Borderline generic.
@5669806 - Joseventus - Looks more like a shaman map than a survivor map. Alignment could be better in some areas. Shaman and mice spawn in the same area which is a no no. A meep at the start will kill everyone.
@5652926 - Yukired - Very cute art, but not very survivory. Mice can walljump and go offscreen. Also the art starts falling. The layout of the map is quite generic.
@5654358 - Opovinha - Mice will camp in the top left and right areas. Alignment could be better But this map is impossible for a shaman to win.
@886932 - Iandme - The colours aren't very appealing and neither is the box the shaman spawns in. Quite a boring map.
@5265602 - Purcha - Fake grounds and some give the impression that collision is turned off but it isn't. The layout isn't very original.
@5656869 - Houterstreq - Unsuitable.
@5656489 - Ricardopzxd - Too easy for the shaman. Hardly ground for the mice.
@5657542 - Lenkashowx - Unsuitable.
@5657687 - Sekakmad - A cluttered mess of grounds.
@5658305 - Riptusembra - Space hasn't been used very well. Not fun to shaman on.
@5647857 - Spektorn - There are maps with similar layouts.
@5647894 - Spektorn - A copy of @276534
@5650700 - Neyrton - There's a map with a similar layout already. The top trampoline coloured ground is useless.
@5441169 - Neyrton - No longer useless, but the map doesn't play very well. The bottom ground saves mice.
@5659290 - Neyrton - Without the cobwebs, this map is quite generic. It relies on the cobwebs too much.
@5661758 - Hurleypsa - Looks confusing and mice have too much free range that it's be hard for the shaman to keep up with them.
@5662132 - Marquitosbj - The grounds are unnecessarily bulky and the middle part of the map is useless and won't be used.
@2723249 - Thegbc - This map is too easy to survive on due to the slopes. Mice will camp on them.
@1467860 - Thegbc - The water grounds are unnecessarily long and mice will camp in these and propel themselves upwards constantly. Not a fun map for the shaman.
@4933359 - Thegbc - The grounds are bulky and the map relies on walljumping which makes it quite unfair for the mice.
@5660319 - Hiisaan - I don't see a point to a lot of the grounds being where they are. The trampoline on the shaman's side for example. The gravity + the trampolines makes this map just plain annoying for the shaman.
@5326279 - Smgn - So I like the way you've placed the water but I think the other grounds could use some more work regarding the layout to make the map look even more interesting.
@5680455 - Smgn - All the sloped grounds make for annoying headsurfs. I just don't see people enjoying this map.
@5698250 - Smgn - Very interesting map, but it feels like there just aren't enough grounds, possibly due to the rotation of most of them. I encourage you to work with this concept, though. I like the middle ground and how it affects the bottom grounds.
@5702363 - Smgn - I'm still not a fan of this map. What I said in the last review still applies.
@5510059 - Smgn - Same as above.
@5668402 - Sfxsex - Poor alignment and gameplay.
@5668634 - Sfxsex - Same as above
@5668656 - Sfxsex - Afk death.
@5668839 - Sfxsex - The shaman can't reach mice if they're cannoned onto the floating grounds above without using skills. Poor alignment.
@5668860 - Sfxsex - Bulky grounds are not visually appealing. Poor gameplay.
@5669419 - Leafinnjake - Generic.
@5636504 - Xconvictedx - If people fall into the water, they're dead anyway because the cheese stops you from floating so the water is just useless. Spamming cannons will kill everyone and make them fall down there.
@5674224 - Salvamk - Not much gameplay, just a race to the top for mice.
@5674288 - Salvamk - Not fun and quite annoying for the shaman being stuck in a box above the mice. The trampolines are hard to hit. and don't work very well.
@5677546 - Salvamk - A lot of mice die trying to jump onto the other grounds. The map is not very visually appealing and doesn't play well.
@5677579 - Salvamk - This map has nothing going for it. Nothing interesting or appealing.
@5679062 - Unparagoned - Generic.
@5679094 - Unparagoned - There are similar P10 maps already.
@5153186 - Wollacy - The map is easily broken and the tokens don't add much to the gameplay.
@5680913 - Leafinnjake - Bulky circles and not much gameplay.
@5680936 - Mrkurt - Mice fall to their death thinking the cloud ground is solid. The colours make the map quite confusing.
@5682491 - Nebelwolfi - Generic.
@5683611 - Addershade - Randomly placed grounds and cheese.
@5683882 - Djvenontrix - Not very fun for the shaman and the alignment could be better.
@5648468 - Layk - a cannon stays in gameplay forever, making the map quite chaotic. Mice also jump onto the trampolines without realising the collision is off.
@5685528 - Marquitosbj - I really like the design but the layout is simple. Change the layout and give the mice a bit more freedom maybe and then resubmit.
@5686231 - Uiuloco - Hole and cheese
@5621623 - Gobbek - Too frustrating for the shaman having the mice jumping back and forth constantly.
@5689067 - Gamog - Mice have too much freedom and can easily avoid the shaman. Too easy for mice.
@4645242 - Dragonitto - Reminds me of other P10 maps. The alignment could be better.
@5691167 - Blluwpens - Cheese and hole. I don't understand the map at all.
@5691650 - Fidnaq - Unsuitable.
@5692907 - Andrumyce - Unsuitable.
@5692276 - Darkicarax - Alignment could be better. Mice don't have much of a chance at surviving because there aren't many grounds.
@5692612 - Darkicarax - It's a nice concept but it's quite chaotic and doesn't work very well. The alignment could be better.
@5405682 - Paranola - I've already reviewed this.
@5694267 - Paranola - Same as above.
@5694341 - Paranola - Too confusing.
@5693184 - Paranola - The despawning is nice, but I don't like how a cannon can bounce back and potentially kill the shaman. Also, the chances of it happening are slim, but the grounds separating the shaman from the mice aren't high enough and a mouse could cannonjump onto it and be offscreen.
@5692963 - Fakedoaero - There are just too many grounds and the despawning grounds have no friction which can allow for easy kills if someone falls and can't get back up. The spawn area is enclosed and a fast cannon can pin everyone and make them all fall.
@5692970 - Curinfake - Mass death.
@5175883 - Curinfake - Generic.
@5175862 - Curinfake - This map is similar to other P10 maps.
@5175821 - Curinfake - The tokens don't add much to the gameplay and I don't see the mice reaching the top.
@5165657 - Curinfake - The shaman can accidentally kill themselves in the chaos. It's also easy to camp if you stand near the trampoline grounds.
@5694175 - Gguiguie - Generic.
@5694320 - Andrumyce - Unsuitable.
@5694322 - Gggppppp - Hardly any gameplay. I don't see mice making it to the circles and they can go offscreen on the top left circle.
@5694345 - Andrumyce - Afk death.
@5694467 - Enesceylanka - Cheese and hole.
@5694988 - Gggppppp - 1 ground to survive on and the concept is ruined if mice run to the right.
@5693051 - Leafinnjake - Generic. Alignment could be better.
@5695116 - Eliaspdc - A pain for the shaman with the transparent grounds. Easy to camp on due to the slope.
@5695224 - Gggppppp - There is really no gameplay here.
@5696019 - Marquitosbj - Everything is ice making it super easy to get fast kills. Too easy for the shaman.
@5696065 - Marquitosbj - The layout is okay, but there's nothing interesting about this map.
@5696873 - Adymices - Poor alignment. Not a fun map for mice or shaman.
@5698442 - Diezone - Easy to camp on the left due to the collision as well as the ice. I only see half of the map being played on.
@5700007 - Diezone - an afk shaman/laggy start will kill the shaman because they're spawning in water. Again, I only see half of the map being played on, mostly due to the huge gap in between the grounds.
@5700766 - Diezone - Basically the same as above.
@5701884 - Erasestr - Generic.
@1026100 - Viniciusdara - The collision with grounds is quite confusing for both shaman and mice. The gravity makes this map a pain for the shaman as mice will just run circles around the grounds on the right.
@5704286 - Viniciusdara - Confusing at first and the grounds are quite bulky and visually not very appealing. Mice have too much freedom and can easily avoid the shaman.
@5702951 - Darkicarax - Fun to survive on but really annoying for the shaman. The slopes make it quite easy for mice to avoid the shaman and if all else fails they can just camp in the long strip of water.
@5651376 - Zhouajie - If you could make those conveyor belt grounds transparent so that mice know they'll die if they try to talk on them it may make a good map.
@5702397 - Darkicarax - Quite boring and easy to avoid the shaman by jumping in between the water grounds.

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue