Rotation Officielle - P5

Rotation Officielle - P5 - Art

@7523479

Left as is:
@7577173 - Skymauss#0000 - The layout doesn't provide a good gameplay, also the invisible grounds behind the art have not been placed correctly. Besides, the map is not visually appealing.
@7577425 - Miroslavchik#0000 - The map basicly consists in a boring back and forth map, thins kind of gameplay would affect the replay value. Also, the only obstacle therea is a boring walljump. Besides, I don't feel it as an art map, it looks more like a tribe house map.
@7224814 - John#9081 - The map is very linear and it is not interesting to our rotation. The only obstacle is a boring wall jump in both right and left sides, this kind of gameplay is annoying. Also, the map doesn't provide a good art and it is not visually appealing.
@7576925 - Abel#5631 - Please don't submit the same map in 2 different categories.
@7566769 - The_Remab#6644 - Despite the gameplay is enjoyable and the art is appealing, the initial lag is an issue. Due to this, it will be left as is.

P1'ed:
@7568774 - Keyx#0000 - Despite the art is visually appealing, the gameplay doesn't offer much potential to be a highperm. P1 will be.
@7523479 - Zioumy#0000 - The map layout provide a linear gameplay. However, it looks cute and makes us remember our childhood somehow.

Will be discussed:
@7420839 - Anto#6095 - Good map with an interesting gameplay. I'll see what the others think about it.
@7420840 - Anto#6095 - Same as above: the art is very interesting and it offers a good gameplay which makes the map enjoyable.

Ignored:
None

#5503

@7578232
@7578480

#5504

@7578692
@7580054

#5505

@7473290

#5506

@7580226

#5507

@7563450

@7563135

#5508

@7429519 ehhhhhhhhh

#5509

@6796513

(co-operated with Describe, huge thanks for it btw)

#5510

@7580122

#5511

Left as is:
@7578232 - Gaster#0512 - The artwork is very nicely done however the placement of it and collision of it within the map is poor, meaning you have to use the portals to save the mice, which is just quite poor design.
@7578480 - Gaster#0512 - The artwork is decent, but the gameplay is seriously lacking. Mice can simply jump across the map, completing it within seconds. The gameplay is generally very linear and bad.
@7578692 - Heba#4782 - The map has been made with little to no effort at all. The art isn't that impressive and the gameplay is just basic walljump.
@7580054 - Heba#4782 - Classic artworks using grounds are quite nice but this map is not very interesting, it's far too simple because all you do is walljump over the artwork. The parts of the map aside from the artwork such as the chocolate ground, trampoline and decoration seem to be lazily added in as an afterthought.
@7473290 - Drzwi0003#0000 - The art isn't that good, and the gameplay relies on the shaman too much.
@7580226 - Eitchwarz#5190 - The art here is very basic and uninteresting, and the gameplay is very simple and boring. It's not the quality of map we're looking for in P5.
@7563450 - Blinkero#0000 - The art is really good, but the gameplay is bad. It's not very fun and the map's collision is really unclear.
@7563135 - Blinkero#0000 - The collision is very inconsistent, for example, the top of the creature in the pit has collision but the black bits around it which are the same color don't. Also, the wall on the far right is difficult to see. This combined makes the route quite unclear and not enjoyable to play.
@6796513 - Ventrumx#4278 - The aesthetic of the map isn't bad, but the collision around the artwork is very poor and confusing. Also, the artwork appears to have the lineart underneath the coloring which makes it look messy.
@7580122 - Serek535#0000 - The artwork is far too basic here and the gameplay is lacking, there has been very little effort put into the map as a general.

P1'ed:
@7429519 - Anto#6095 - The art is very nice, but how it's scattered around the map makes it uninteresting to play. P1 is fine.

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#5512

@7580746

#5513

@6796513 (updated)

#5514

@7505090

#5515

@7581079

#5517

@7581670

#5518

@7582960

#5519

@7581636
@7583126

#5520

Left as is:
@7580746 - Lunaflare#6206 - The art isn't visually appealing. Also, the grounds behind the art (joints) aren't well placed and it is going to affect directly the gameplay somehow. But don't give up! Keep improving your skills on it.
@6796513 - Ventrumx#4278 - The art is cute, but there is too much information in this map (joints). In other words, it may cause some initial lag or lag while you are playing this map, and that's an issue.
@7582960 - Mapping#1413 - The map design/art is very simple and it provides a boring gameplay.
@7581636 - Gaster#0512 - In spite of this map is visually appealing, the gameplay is very poor. It basicly consists in a boring back and forth map. Next time, try to put more effort and improve the gameplay.

P1'ed:
@7505090 - Zioumy#0000 - Despite the gameplay isn't one of the best I've ever seen, the art is visually appealing and it harmonizes with the map scenario. Next time, try to use the unused space to improve the gameplay by adding obstacles and different paths to follow.
@7581079 - Ventrumx#4278 - Despite both the art and the gameplay are very simple, it is enjoyable somehow, deserves to be protected.
@7583126 - Gaster#0512 - This time, the both the art and the gameplay can be appreciated. However, there is some unused space in this map, limiting the diversity of options to build, the map will become repetitive.

Will be discussed:
@7581670 - Ikasaruzu#0000 - This map is very kind, the gameplay is enjoyable and fun. I'll see what the others think about it.

Ignored:
None

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue