Rotation Officielle - P9

#5532

Left as is:
@4740022 - +hotboy#0000 - I see that you have addressed the problems of mass death, but the map is still quite frustrating and difficult to understand for the shaman, in public tests there's only ever 1-3 mice which end up completing, even if the shaman understands the map. I'm not sure exactly how you could avoid that and ensure more completions, but one of the main problems does seem to be that the mechanism is too easily stopped by the mice, which means the shaman needs to keep cannoning it much too frequently.
@7906170 - +hotboy#0000 - Interesting concept but I feel it's much too difficult for the shaman to understand and the summon range and items available are way too restricted to ensure that the shaman is able to successfully complete the map.
@7799993 - Jasseh#0000 - Not really a good execution of soulmate, the first 2 obstacles are basically identical then the cheese portion is much too complicated for the mice to understand. Also very easy for mice to be trapped or not be able to complete the map if soulmate is afk or dies.
@7900555 - Jasseh#0000 - Like the previous map, not a great execution of soulmate - the start is much too difficult and complex for most mice, resulting in mass death or just being stuck. The hole portion is also quite unclear.
@7904771 - Deadpoolgve#0000 - Gameplay is not really that interesting, just turn around with cheese or fall, dodge the acid and wait for the hole trampoline to open up.
@5456368 - Tricksteer#5888 - I personally enjoyed figuring this map out but it's much too difficult for the rotation, and the shaman doesn't really have much room to help without messing up the intended gameplay.
@7907733 - I_Ba#0000 - Fine as P0, please look at the recently permed maps to get an idea of what we look for in this category
@7902964 - Xaxadoooooo#0000 - Cool mechanism but the gameplay just ends up being running back and forth
@4862615 - Pgmsule#0000 - Definitely something quite different to what we usually see in rotation but it's still way too easy for the mice just to fall almost directly to the bottom, there's not much challenge to the map and just ends up being quite luck based.
@7909118 - Bonan#6495 - Fine as P0, please look at the recently permed maps to get an idea of what we look for in this category
@7901036 - Xaxadoooooo#0000 - Similar maps exist in rotation already, which have done this concept better. Also generally I find that dynamic trampolines are really annoying to play on because of the inconsistent momentum you get from them.
@7876952 - Zeus#6550 - Not sure if this map really fits as a P9 if anything at all, the lava combined with the gravity and overall design of the map makes it quite chaotic and difficult to control your mouse.
@7912291 - Zeus#6550 - Not really any interesting gameplay here, just bounce using the first tramp to cheese then bounce/run back. Also, the second trampoline is positioned very awkwardly meaning it can only really be used to go up to cheese, the grass block mostly prevents it from being used to go back to hole.
@6025928 - Namelessh#0000 - I'm not sure if this fits in P9, nevertheless the gameplay is quite confused and there's not really a clear path. It's also not good that there's no clear way to get back to hole without using the tokens once you have cheese.
@7347540 - Namelessh#0000 - Again not really any interesting gameplay here, it would be just the same if you had just started with the boxes pre placed on the bottom, and then it's just a matter of riding them over the acid to cheese and hole
@7910746 - Ballantines#1391 - Not really any interesting gameplay, just run - wait - run - wait.
@7900593 - Fakedoaero#0000 - An unique take on an existing vanilla map but doesn't really offer much gameplay wise, most the ice just slides off to the hole side and doesn't really make any difference to how the map plays
@7898760 - Fakedoaero#0000 - I don't see any changes from when this was submitted to P7, same feedback applies - it's too easy to get all cheese and the boxes don't really make any difference to the gameplay
@7911385 - Aqvaswirle#0095 - This map is just particularly unpleasant to build and play on due to the high gravity and doesn't really meet the standards for maps these days. Have a look at the recently permed maps to get an idea of what we look for.
@7911676 - Aqvaswirle#0095 - This concept has pretty much been done to death at this point, and it's not really a fit for rotation these days. Also why the random wind?
@7904497 - Antoni0#8587 - These kinds of maps are cool in concept but usually end up being too confusing for the shaman, in public tests it often took much too long to figure out, or the shaman would just mort. Maybe you could add some indicators as to what to do, but I'm not really sure if that would help.
@7908546 - Antoni0#8587 - Same as above
@7912039 - Mari_Ah#6279 - Not really up to rotation standards, please take a look at the recently permed maps to get an idea of what we are looking for.
@4989338 - Seishi112#3839 - Same as above. Also should have been submitted to P5 instead as it's an art map.
@7912343 - Elisahrahibesi#7092 - Same as above

P1'ed:
None

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
None

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue