Rotation Officielle - P5

#6021

Left as is:
@7692266 - Sazd#0148 - This map is just too laggy in general, it takes 4 seconds at least to load in the room and that's a warning sign because while some players with better PCs will spawn earlier, others will suffer to complete it. The collision on the plant/tree isn't very accurate as well. Other than that, I must say it's a shame to deny this map because the art is really pretty and the gameplay although not awesome is not too bad. If you can work on it a bit in order to remove some joints to make the map less catastrophic for the players to play on it, I would surely put it up for discussion.
@7781417 - Sazd#0148 - Art looks very fancy, however, the joints below the glasses caused a lot of mice to get confused thinking that part was collidable. That said, they ended up jumping there to their death. Either make it clear those stuff (clouds, perhaps? I'm not too sure) don't have collision or just remove them from the map. Just like your other map this one has some starlag as well, but it's bearable here.
@7766989 - Wed#0000 - No need for this map to have such a long vertical scroll, once it just makes you walljump exhaustively which is boring. Wind is also not valuable here. As for the art, it's good overall, but a spider web in Spider-Man's left hand seems to be missing.
@7779713 - Kkkkkkkarry#7381 - I really appreciate the art of this map and it's noticeable the hard work you put into it, indeed awesome and appealing to the eyes. Unfortunately, it's way too cluttered for mice and the tests I did proved me that. It's also very time-consuming and if it happens to players to fail at some part of the map in the way back to hole, they tend to just give up. Maybe increasing friction for every ground and moving the mice/cheese/hole spawns somewhere else to make it easier to get completed could help. There's still some lag going on, but if you can make it overall more playable I'd forgive it.
@7779762 - Mimx20#1809 - Both the art and gameplay are lacking on this map.
@1610412 - Ifo#4275 - Well made art, it's very pretty. I don't care if mice have to rely on the shamans to complete it but then they just need to spawn a plank or very few objects to get it ready for mice to solo, so it's not interesting. From what I can see, it's all composed of map editor grounds only, maybe that's why it should be a little difficult to add gameplay to the map.
@1651278 - Ifo#4275 - Same as above. Shamans have to work a bit more on this map though, but it's not fun.
@7780731 - Solderify#0000 - While the art itself isn't that bad, there's too much walljumping needed to complete this map, which is boring.
@7217801 - Gilcatmey#0000 - The art was well drawn but then there's not much gameplay to this map, it's fine as it is.
@7781964 - Altibindokuz#0000 - I don't think this map has enough artistic sense for the objects not to have colouring. The collision is kind of awkward in places as well and the pencil is going off-screen.
@7731750 - Sonic#2456 - This map takes a lot of time, walljumping and patience to get completed. Art's awkward and so is the collision on it. I dislike how mice have to rely on the shaman after walljumping for so long. Furthermore, you should try to make a better contrast between the background and the art itself.
@7748041 - Stovedove#0000 - For an art map, this leaves a lot to be desired as it doen't have anything eye-catching. Not very interesting when it comes to gameplay as well.
@7665039 - Jasseh#0000 - Unfortunately, this map doesn't have much art value even though I find the gameplay acceptable. The mech of the thing on the bottom broke for some mice while worked out fine for others.
@7144721 - Yuugiooohhhh#0000 - Map has an extremely huge start lag, that alone is enough for me to deny it. The gameplay's is also really random.
@7138023 - Yuugiooohhhh#0000 - Pretty much same as above.
@7768538 - Recessionist#0000 - The art is there, but I can't say the same when it comes to gameplay as it has nothing to do with the art itself.

P1'ed:
@7781351 - Marllonsilva#0000 - While the art does have some value, mice barely interact with it after getting up and going to the sides. The mech itself doesn't seem to be very stable either.
@7777473 - Godmcb#6577 - Cute but that's it, not really awesome and gameplay is just walljumping over art.
@7743423 - B0wl#7075 - The art is nice but doesn't really catch up attention. Gameplay isn't too bad, however it's mostly about waiting in the water everytime which may be boring for some.
@7780940 - Kinhusxd#0095 - It's a map we would surely perm in late 2010. If you had worked harder on the boats, perhaps I'd consider this one once the gameplay is acceptable enough for an oldschool styled map.
@7719722 - Juliandcc#0000 - Okayish art, gameplay feels off and random though.

Will be discussed:
@7769912 - Marllonsilva#0000 - I really enjoyed the simplicity of the art and how it's connected to the background overall, it's fun to play on it. I'm fine with giving it a shot.
@7774493 - Godmcb#6577 - Good art, acceptable gameplay, I think it is perfectly fine for Halloween which is coming.
@7779489 - B0wl#7075 - Cute art, no lag issues, good and straightforward gameplay. Definitely worth giving it a shot.
@3385089 - Erickindio#0000 - Fine art in its simplicity and it offers different gameplay every single time as well, which is a plus. I thought the mech would be unstable in public but to my surprise it played out nicely. There's a small wood ground right under the chat bar though. I believe it was placed by accident and you should remove it. Furthermore, I think it could use some decorations because it feels a bit empty but that's not a big deal.
@7724378 - Juliandcc#0000 - The only issue I have with this map is the start lag. Mice also seemed to struggle with the wood ground on the middle a bit, but that could be solved if you move it some pixels down. Other than that, the art is funny and it's good gameplay-wise.

Ignored:
None

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue