Rotation Officielle - P5

Rotation Officielle - P5 - Art

#6061

@7794566 (p9 edited)

#6063

@7800027
@7800028

Dernière modification le

#6064

@7809035

#6065

@7809303

#6066

@7750020

#6067

@7811226

#6068

@7811324

#6069

@7811854

#6070

@7812088

#6071

@7812094

#6072

@7792776
@7801920

#6073

@7789250

#6074

Left as is:
@7809035 - King_seniru#5890 - I have a hard time undertsanding everything, like I get the concept of each color representing a ground but the big LUA logo seems really out of place here. Besides it's kinda hidding the meaning of one color = one ground and it makes the map so confusing.
@7750020 - Prolat#0575 - I really like the art and I think the map as a great potential but for now the gameplay could need some improvement. The gameplay is boring and the path is pretty confusing too, I'd suggest you to work on the cheese area a bit more, and as someone suggested during the review maybe put water behind the green light. The map would be really great with less WJ and a clearer path.
@7811226 - Hackdesamba#0000 - The concept is interesting but the execution is lacking. It's very disturbing / not aesthetically pleasing to have some grounds in foreground and some others in background. The art could really need some improvement too and the gameplay needs to be re worked. We need to understand more clearly how to complete it, for now it's quite a mess.
@7811324 - Mousechris#0000 - The art is great I'll give you that but there's pretty much no gameplay, it's really confusing we don't really know where to go and the path is just too linear.
@7812088 - Karaka#0647 - This is well done for sure but the gameplay isn't good at all, it's too linear and is pretty boring. I suggest you improve the gameplay and maybe the art too a bit, although it's well done it's not impressive.
@7812094 - Mousechris#0000 - The art is fine but the gameplay could be improved. I don't love the fact we're only playing on half the map and the gameplay is a bit too short to be interesting.
@7801920 - Altibindokuz#2192 - I like the art very much, but I think the gameplay is a bit too boring for now, I think it'd be much better if it wasn't so linear / so full of wall-jump. I'll let this map P0 because I really think it has potential for being P5 with a bit of improvement.
@7789250 - M23#4702 - Huge lag start, and although the art is nice, the gameplay isn't very good, it's kinda annoying to get stuck on the sand and helping for the shaman to help.

P1'ed:
@7800027 - Newen#6196 - The art is nice but the gameplay is quite short and uninteresting. Besides it's a real pain to complete without a shaman, but even as the shaman the map isn't that interesting, all it takes is an anvil and a spring
@7809303 - Hackdesamba#0000 - I like the oldschool art but the gameplay is quite boring. The shaman only has to build a long ramp and that's pretty much all. I don't hate P5 maps where the shaman has to build, but I wish the building was a bit more interesting.
@7792776 - Altibindokuz#2192 - The art is fine although I guess I don't have the reference, but I think the gameplay is a bit too simple / too linear for the map to worth a higher perm. Also there's a bit of a lag start.

Will be discussed:
@7800028 - Newen#6196 - I really like the art and the colors but as said I also think the gameplay is a bit too short to be interesting and it might lack replay value.
@7811854 - Ceagy#7796 - P5'ed for Xmas season and will probably be P1 after that because the gameplay is just "meh". It's a really nice art.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#6075

@7813562
Wipsy Woods

#6076

@7808228

#6077

@7814163

#6078

@7797770

#6079

@7814219

#6080

@7062647
@7051912

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue