Rotation Officielle - P5

Rotation Officielle - P5 - Art

Left as is:
@7896423 by Kana#2630 - The art is cute, but not up to our current P5 standards. I think you should try improving the gameplay because for now it's mostly wall-jumping and running around.
@7897628 by Lucas11#5331 - Honestly same as above, the art is cute but because the gameplay is mainly wall-jumping and jumping around the map, the replay value is very low. Also, the art doesn't really meet current P5 standards, mostly because it's just a piece of art places in the middle of the map a bit randomly.
@7898131 by King#7644 - The art is too minimalist to make to it P5. I'd suggest improving the art and making something a bit more detailed, and then trying to think of a more challenging gameplay.
@7897625 by Kolibamboli#0000 - Same as above, the art is too simple and the gameplay not challenging enough to be interesting and have a replay value.
@7899205 by Banana#6055 - The art is very cute, but the gameplay is a bit confusing because the collision isn't clear enough. I'd recommend improving the collision and just the overall layout to make it clearer to players as to where they should go.
@7900304 by Mwuo2004#0000 - The art is okay, but the collision could be a bit better on the top part. Besides, the gameplay is really too poor, there's too much wall-jump and not much else to do around the map. I'd suggest trying to improve the gameplay and find some challenges that would be funnier to players.
@7418698 by John#9081 - The art is fun, but the collision is too sloppy and could be better. The gameplay might be fun once, but I think it really lacks replay value and isn't very enjoyable on the long run. Besides, the art is a bit minimal and not up to our current P5 standards.
@7416743 by John#9081 - I do think the art is better here, but the gameplay isn't. It looks like it can't be completed without the shaman help, but the construction isn't interesting to build and overall it really isn't enjoyable for the players nor the shaman.
@7900480 by Afonico#0000 - We usually advise against hiding the cheese or the hole, as well as needing to go off-screen. Furthermore, the art just isn't good enough. It's cute but not detailed or particularly interesting and won't be enough for P5.
@7900598 by Afonico#0000 - The art is cute, but once again a bit light compared to what we're expecting for P5. Besides, the players' spawning point is too cramped and will be awfully annoying for the shaman. The map relies too much on the shaman but isn't challenging, so everyone will get bored pretty quickly.
@6140514 by Hea#0000 - The art is not the best because it's quite simple and doesn't really serve the gameplay. It could have made it to P1 but just think the scrolling is unnecessary, you could have fit the map in a classic 400x800 frame. Besides the tramp on the top part of the map seems a bit useless. Overall the map has poor replay value.
@7904560 by Timothy#8918 - Map is cute but gameplay is lacking, it's kind of annoying how you just have to wall-jump and run to the cheese. It has poor replay value and nothing really stands out to make it P1 or P5.
@7905246 by Bonan#6495 - Art is fine but same as above, the gameplay being only-jumping is boring. We're searching for maps with a more elaborate gameplay that won't be annoying very quickly.
@7903882 by Nj_1#0000 - Same as above for the gameplay. And I'd say the art is also lacking a bit, it's nice but just... Not enough for an art map. We're expecting a significant piece of art what will blend well with the map and the gameplay in P5.

@7897536 by Dragonbzx#0000 - I really liked the art style and simplicity and I tested the map a couple of times, but it didn't work very well. Most players didn't understand where the collision was on the lower part and were dying, so I'd suggest putting collision everywhere on this particular part. The path could also be a bit clearer, players didn't understand where to go to grab the cheese. But I think that with couple edits, this map has potential.
@7795555 by M23#4702 - I like it, but it seems a bit laggy, I tested it twice and both times at the very beginning the prison cage was up and mice could already leave And then.... Just shamans not understanding what to do with the house... I don't have much suggestion for this part , but maybe having a visual clue that the hole is up there could help some understand what they need to do.

P1'ed:
@7899111 by Wiannix#7716 - Simple but cute. I think it'll be a bit annoying to build on it as a shaman, but it doesn't hurt to have this in P1.
@7900087 by Deadpoolgve#0000 - The art is great and well executed, however the map doesn't have anything really special, and the gameplay feels very blend to me since it's mostly wall-jumping. I'll add that the scrolling feel a bit unnecessary here, so I think P1 is enough.
@7900224 by Mwuo2004#0000 - Nothing extraordinary about this and gameplay is really lacking but won't hurt to have this in P1.
@7815068 by Bautipro#5357 - The map is simple but nice. However, the path is not very clear despite the apples and the arrows and many were confused. It's also possible to shortcut the map by wall-jumping on the waterfall directly but I don't mind it much. P1 will be just fine.

Will be discussed:
@7903410 by Deadpoolgve#0000 - Really confused by the art but I like it :') I think the gameplay might be a bit tricky and involve too much waiting but I don't mind it much.
@7786000 by Jasseh#0000 - Not a fan of dodue if there's only one cheese but it's a quick edit at most. Not the biggest fan of the map in general but the art is nice and the gameplay well executed.

Ignored:

Dernière modification le

#6362

Mapcrew a dit :
WIP

Left as is:
@7896423 by Kana#2630 - The art is cute but not up to our current P5 standard. I think you should try improving the gameplay because for now it's mostly wall-jumping and running around.
@7897628 by Lucas11#5331 - Honestly same at above, the art is cute but because the gameplay is mainly wall-jumping and jumping around the map, the replay value is very low. Also the art doesn't really meet current P5 standard mostly because it's just a piece of art places in the middle of map a bit randomly.
@7898131 by King#7644 - The art is too minimalist to make to it P5. I'd suggest improving the art and making something a bit more detailed and then trying to think of a more challenging gameplay.
@7897625 by Kolibamboli#0000 - Same as above, the art is too simple and the gameplay not challenging enough to be interesting and have a replay value.
@7899205 by Banana#6055 - The art is very cute but the gameplay is a bit confusing because the collision isn't clear enough. I'd suggest improving the collision and just the overall layout to make it clearer to players as to where they should go.

P1'ed:
@7899111 by Wiannix#7716 - Simple but cute. I think it'll be a bit annoying to build on it as a shaman but it doesn't hurt to have this in P1.

Will be discussed:
@7897536 by Dragonbzx#0000 - The gameplay is very straightforward but I really like the simplicity of the map so I'll give it a shot!
@7795555 by M23#4702 - Will test it, I hope it'll be easy enough to understand for shamans.

Ignored:

Good job

#6363

@7904541
@7904348

#6364

@7907037

#6365

@7907932

#6366

@7908257

#6367

@7908604

#6368

@7909414

#6369

@303115

#6370

@7912428

#6371

@7815068 edited

#6372

@7915247 fiz esse mapa sem precisar usar viprin drawing editor, por ser mais difícil de fazer manualmente acho que poderia ser um p5

#6373

Left as is:
@7907932 - Zewsos#0000 - I feel like adding a background to the map would make it more appealing visually. Right now, the character (especially the hood) blends in too much with the grey, and the overall look feels a bit bland.
@7908604 - Arthur107#1925 - Art is kinda sus... The gameplay of the map is only walljumping, which is boring.
@7909414 - Mrijalover#6179 - The art looks nice, but it would be great if the mice could interact with it, walk on it.
@7815068 - Bautipro#5357 - The art is nice, but I have some suggestions to make the gameplay more enjoyable: first is the bird, the current speed is too slow, making it faster would make the gameplay more dynamic. Second, the apples on the tree are too close together, making it awkward to jump up. I think it would be okay to have less apples, farther away from each other.

P1'ed:
@7904541 - Deadpoolgve#0000 - The gameplay is a bit boring and linear, but the art is cute.
@7907037 - Indexinel#5948 - The art is really good, the red overlay gives some nice extra atmosphere, but the gameplay aspect is lacking.
@303115 - Gokuzinho#0000 - The waiting in the beginning of the map is boring, but otherwise it's cute.
@7912428 - Ballantines#1391 - Good idea, but the gameplay is not too exciting.
@7915247 - Redfelipexxx#0000 - Cool aesthetics, but the gameplay is a bit boring and repetitive due to the symmetry.

Will be discussed:
@7904348 - Deadpoolgve#0000
@7908257 - Wrfg#0000

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#6374

@7873243
@7836048 - Edited

Dernière modification le

#6375

@7815068 edited

#6376

@7916912
@7916958

Dernière modification le

#6377

@7675819

#6378

@7917328

#6379

@7917956
@7918031

Dernière modification le

#6380

@7915768 cute flower

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue