Rotation Officielle - P5

Rotation Officielle - P5 - Art

#6401

@7926950 - Inspired by Mondrian's paintings
@7926954 - Inspired by the Bauhaus logo

#6402

@7926360

#6403

@7927527

#6404

@7926738

#6405

@7926956

#6406

@7927595

#6407

@7927669

#6408

Left as is:
@7924533 - Zaturapro#8143 - It is very confusing to understand where the ground's collision will start/end. In addition, the collision on the cookie isn't even on the actual cookie. The map itself is too simplistic with its art. The gameplay itself is very plain because it's all based around wj and running.
@7924564 - Zaturapro#8143 - Same as above, the gameplay is too plain and the art is too simple.
@7924653 - Zaturapro#8143 - The art and gameplay are too simplistic for the standards we expect for the modern rotation.
@6627962 - Leiks#0000 - Same as above.
@7925525 - Zaturapro#8143 - The map offers very limited gameplay and the art is basic.
@7926950 - Look991#0000 - The route is very unclear and the gameplay consists solely on walljumping around the map.
@7926954 - Look991#0000 - The map has an invisible floor and gameplay is based solely on walljumping.
@7926360 - Mammon#0430 - The map doesn't contain anything that could be really classified as art, the spinning fan in the middle doesn't really fit for our expectation of art for the rotation. The map also contains invisible walls. The gameplay is running around from one side of the map to the other, which is very plain.
@7927527 - Teodoracool#0000 - Not sure why the map has two different cheeses when one would have been just fine. In addition, I'm unsure what the crocodille legs in the water are supposed to do, since they do not help you reach the hole. Overall, the map does not have much interesting gameplay.
@7926956 - Look991#0000 - The art isn't very impressive, and the gameplay is quite lacking. It is kinda unclear where the hole is, despite the arrow, I'm not sure whether most of the players would understand it. On top of that, the collision is rather confusing. The map also has an invisible floor.
@7927595 - Look991#0000 - The map lacks any gameplay, other than walljumping. The white background is very bright, which makes the map seem very high contrast and could be jarring for players. The art is not very impressive and the map contains an invisible floor.
@7927669 - Fliqpy#6862 - The map has very plain gameplay, just walljumping, with maybe succeeding in a corner jump. The art isn't impressive and the random decorations scattered around the map don't make it better.
@7926738 - Daanieeln#0000 - Art is nice, gameplay is not all that interesting, just repeating the same route twice, once for hole and once for cheese. There is also a hidden floor in the bottom of the map. If you would like to make the floor more clear or remove it, this map could be good enough for P1.

P1'ed:
@7675819 - Lucas11#5331 - Map is overall nice, good enough for P1.

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
None

#6409

@7927692
@7930779

Dernière modification le

#6410

@7909414
Fixed - players can move around in the art

#6411

@7929343
@7929384

Dernière modification le

#6412

@7929573

#6413

@7929676

#6414

@7930127

#6415

@7930019
@7930022

Dernière modification le

#6416

Toilet - @7930592
Mondrian - @7930593
Bauhaus - @7930594
Homer - @7930595

#6417

@7929741

#6418

@7930834
@7930837

Dernière modification le

#6419

Left as is:
@7909414 by Mrijalover#6179 - Although I can see edits have been made, the art and the gameplay remain too poor. The art is not very clean and can be a bit messy on some part. The gameplay is totally unrelated to the art, it's just a cheese and a hole put on total opposite directions; but it is not nearly enough to make the map interesting or enjoyable for both players and the shaman. As is it, I don't have any specific edit to suggest, I'd just say it would take serious reworking on the art and the overall layout of the map to makes it eligible for a higher perm.
@7929676 by Blondie#3432 - The art is cute, but not very detailed or impressive. On top of that, the gameplay only consists in wall-jumping over the art, which is boring with no replay value. I'd suggest working a bit on the art and then trying to elaborate a more complex gameplay around that art.
@7930022 by Jasseh#0000 - The art is cute and all, but the gameplay is a bit tedious. I tested the map in public and the vast majority of players couldn't get pass the mill. The shaman really struggled to help and to build properly around the art. I think finding a way to make the map soloable and more accessible to players would be better.
@7930592 by Look991#0000 - The art is not detailed and definitely not up to our current P5 standards. The gameplay is also frustrating, with mice being stuck in a cramped space full of water just below the cheese. It's a nightmare for the shaman and is not fun at all. You also submitted a very similar map last time and it was already refused, it will not be accepted if nothing changes.
@7930593 by Look991#0000 - Basically the same as @7926950, refer to previous review.
@7926954 by Look991#0000 - Refer to previous review.
@7930595 by Look991#0000 - Refer to previous review.
@7930834 by Shen#3315 - I don't know if the map is finished but there's not much going on in terms of both art and gameplay.
@7930837 by Shen#3315 - There are more elements here, but the art is not very good, the collision with grounds not super clear and overall the gameplay is lacking. It basically requires a lot of wall-jumping and that's it.

P1'ed:
@7927692 by Bautipro#5357 - The art and the colors are nice, but the gameplay remains poor. It is linear and involved a lot of wall-jumping / jumping on platforms over and over again. Because of this lack of gameplay, I don't think this map could get a higher perm.
@7929343 by Xaxadoooooo#0000 - I don't have much to say about the art, it's nice and cute. However on the gameplay I'd say it's pretty short and un-challenging, it's ok to play on it a couple of times, but there's not much replay value. I'd also say the scrolling feels very unnecessary here, the whole map could have probably fit on standard size. It can also be deadly for some players which can be frustrating, but I think the map is fine as P1.
@7929573 by Lakapaxxd#0000 - The art is not up to the standard of what we're expecting to P5 and the gameplay is not the most elaborate, however I can see efforts have been made for both art and gameplay and I don't feel like there's anything that could be changed to make the map better without changing everything, so P1 will do.
@7930127 by Sin#9948 - This is weird ugly, but I guess it's ok for P1.
@7929741 by Qadori#0000 - The art and the gameplay are both ok but I don't see much replay value, it remains pretty simple.

Will be discussed:
@7930779 by Bautipro#5357 - It can be frustrating to fall when trying to grab the cheese, but overall it's very clear effort was put into the gameplay and it is pretty different from what we see these days. I reckon most can recognize the art and enjoy it too. Many some minor edits could improve the map, but we'll see how it goes in discussion.
@7929384 by Xaxadoooooo#0000 - Nice detailed art, can be a bit laggy but ok for me. Gameplay's ok to.
@7930019 by Jasseh#0000 - I really enjoy the use of typical grounds in the art, it looks different and great at the same time. The path can be a bit confusing and some places are cramped but it should be fine.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#6420

@7932041

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue