Rotation Officielle - P4

#6472

Left as is:
@6839489 - Lymero - Interesting and well thought concept; but tests showed that if you place a b plank below the dynamic circle then the map turns impossible. Try to edit it in a way this won’t happen so easily.
@6829707 - Rekakurnr – Map is getting better little by little. Now try to fix the alienation, both sides should be symmetrical and place the grass in the middle at (x=400, y=50), so it can really be in the middle of the map. (You can ask another mapcrew member for help)
@6848085 - Elhectordm - Map is fine but I don't think it can add something interesting/funny to rotation. Also I have seen a lot of P1 maps which looks almost the same as this one.
@6850907 - Andrelionte – The use of clouds is interesting but the build itself results long and dull.
@5150569 - Tioyudis – You can use an “L” build to solve both sides and the clouds don’t have a relevant use for the shaman. I could say that simplicity is enjoyable but there a lot of P1 maps with almost the same design.
@6848496 - Chav1s - It isn't unclear that the horizontal anitcloud is glitched, try to add some arrows to make it obvious. Also I see that the concept is fine but I think is still not good enough for P4 since the build is just long and boring.
@6337559 - Viniciusdara – The concept is interesting but the gameplay is dull. Try to improve it since it feels like a generic map with an extra mechanism just to make it look better.
@6849629 - Sourisec7 - This is similar to the vanilla map with portals.
@6742000 - Fakkedorock - Map is too long, and waiting for the shaman to do the whole build is boring for the mice.
@6850158 - Mmhhxdxd - The build is nothing new which results slightly boring.
@6100497 - Lucasrslv - I see what you tried to do with water and the tramps. But mixing both concepts isn't a good idea since it results difficult for new players. I suggest you using only one concept of both: water or tramp. So it can be easier (also avoid cramped spaces too, path to cheese and mice results frustrating).
@6852116 - Pratton - This map needs a lot more of work. The build is too long for one shaman and mice will be bored after a long of waiting and the clouds are totally unnecessary since they result too closed and frustrating.
@6852494 - Tdft - Smart use of cobwebs but they might result annoying/frustrating for the shaman since they make everything too slow. Just imagine a new player losing his mind with the cobwebs and the mice getting mad because the shaman doesn’t know how to solve it.
@6852264 - Caraddon - Wrong category.
@6849627 - Queen1016 - Dynamic grounds don’t have a relevant use for the shaman and the design is nothing new.
@5449912 - +Mistersacri - Gameplay is unbalanced since it results more difficult to build in the middle of the map where the rainbow is. And the anticlouds aren't that clear for new players.
@6811246 - Eliaspdc - Too long for only one shaman.
@6850904 - Melasti - The left part of the map is fine but the right part with the cheese is so closed. I understand that you tried to make it challenging but it results more frustrating.
@4136271 - Sekui - The glithced grounds have the same use as an ice. So they don’t' really make a difference in the gameplay.
@6854526 - Vintagenacho - There is no variety on building and it makes me feel claustrophobic.
@6520381 - Obsyt - It feels like you ran out of ideas and played a few minutes with the editor. Map is curious but there is no variety on building.
@5796038 - Exoatz - Wrong category.
@6854987 - Bapereira - Gameplay is too short people will hardly enjoy it.
@1842394 - Rdzoze – Good concept, I think it has potential for P4. The only problem is that there Is no variety on building, during the tests shamans did the same bridge for cheese and then hole; I will not perm it so you can edit it in a way shaman choose different ways to solve it.
@3305165 - Framnm – The gameplay is unbalance since it is easier and shorter to build in the right part of the map, and the grounds at the bottom left are nothing but useless.
@6538828 - Tdpnice – Map can’t offer something funny/interesting to rotation. The grounds feels randomly placed and the mice spawn cause mass of deaths when they try to reach the wood where the shaman is.
@5712902 - Chessequel – You can solve this map with a simple bridge, which is nothing new for rotation.

P1'ed:
@6848763 - Jr4t - Good map but I don't see farther than P1.
@6845242 - Ptnarutopt - Neat idea. P1 will be fine.
@6848944 - Fuzzyfirsdog - I liked the use of that anticloud as an obstacle with the clouds supporting the buid. Good enough for P1.
@6697001 - Mquk - Good enough for P1
@6854433 - Ujkos - Interesting concept but I don't see farther than P1.
@6854382 - Mousezxcvbn – Cute and smart use of rings. I liked how the middle ground interacts with the whole map. P1 will be fine.
@6224228 - Picapauui – Once again, good idea but shamans keep avoiding the dynamic ground during tests. P1 will be fine.
@6850312 - Hakanproft - Cute map but I don't see farther than P1.

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
@6848310 - Leraionut111 - Blacklisted
@6849756 - Louis49 - Blacklisted
@6855257 - Leraionut111 - Blacklisted
@6855263 - Leraionut111 - Blacklisted

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue