@5754447

@5846654 Edited

@5556160

@5882598

@5874518

@5052741

@5888445

@5890082

Note: This is not my review, I'm just posting it for a VMC member. Please don't message me about your p8 maps.

Left as is:
@3260428 - Garybro - Generic symmetrical concept. Water and clouds are annoying, but without them, the map would be even more boring.
@2328768 - Garybro - Generic and boring monosolution. Its layout is awful and doesn't leave enough space for the shamans to cooperate.
@5839905 - Meganetoo - Plain and uninteresting map, doesn't follow P8 standards. Two shamans aren't needed here.
@5833621 - Meganetoo - Same as above.
@5868067 - Rdzoze - Interesting usage of the concept, though it lacks of sense of cooperation as the wind forces both shamans to build towards only one direction. There aren't many solutions either.
@5869978 - Joseventus - You just have to build a long bridge on a side of the map until you reach the cheese. There's not sense of cooperation and the scroll is annoying.
@5872219 - Joseventus - Overused concept. It's confusing and the rotating circles don't add much uniqueness to the map.
@2160076 - Mrkurt - Interesting concept, but it's currently too confusing and easy to mess up. Replace the ice grounds by another ground to show they don't have collision with objects.
@5870624 - Exoatz - Bad map overall.
@5868089 - Exoatz - Weird design and doesn't have the enough difficulty for P8.
@5859614 - Unparagoned - Generic buildathon. Nothing really different from what's already in rotation.
@5861081 - Unparagoned - If one shaman dies, there's no possibility for the other one to help the mice on the other side of the map at all. The scroll and the clouds are annoying too.
@5875728 - Ltuv - Two cheese are not necessary and the layout looks kind of messy. Nice challenge, but it wouldn't flow well out in public.
@5872250 - Diremaus - Generic. The left shortcut will most likely never be used and the water is pointless.
@5754447 - Chuilan - Not bad, but it's unaligned. Scroll is unecessary as you could have perfectly made this map in an 800px lenght screen. Fix this and it may be okay for discussion.
@5846654 - Soulperf - What if both shamans go to the same side of the map? Or if one dies? They won't be able to help the mice on the other side unless they have skills, however, you must take this into consideration. The overall map is not fun either.
@5556160 - Framnm - This concept is not new and it has not been implemented in an outstanding way here. It's kind of complicated and the cloud is annoying. Also, watch out where you set the spawns.
@5882598 - Looils - Pretty generic and boring.
@5874518 - Eshkation - Same as two maps above. Shamans won't be able to help the mice on the other side of the map. Mice on the right can reach the cheese without building as it's just invisible water. Bad map overall.
@5052741 - Brwil - Nothing new and the clouds are annoying.


P1'ed:
None


Will be discussed:
@5888445 - Thugsta - Even though there are many similar maps already in rotation, the layout here is fine. Up for discussion.


Ignored:
@4487126 - Jhonsondx - Posted more than 2 maps (same post)
@4198913 - Jhonsondx - Posted more than 2 maps (same post)
@4186227 - Jhonsondx - Posted more than 2 maps (same post)

@5881015

@5896202

@5835882
@5056575

@4487126 '-'

@5556160

@2741094
@2522921

@5897884
@5897817

@5867482

@5899945

@5522270