Rotation Officielle - P3

#7844

Reviews
Maps being discussed

CHECKPOINT!

Maps that are now permed:
Tennis#8153 - @7694874

Reviews:
Bielpratasqn#0000 - @6465366

This is another map which there are several aspects that I dislike. The start is ok in my opinion, kinda challenging to pass, and fun to figure out at first sight, but the entire right top, over the start, is a no for me. All of the obstacles there are underwhelming and uninteresting, and with such space it is possible to come up with better ideas.The left side is good, but still needs improvements. If the cheese obstacle difficulty stays the same, a checkpoint before it would be a good idea. Also, the spring token is almost invisible there, so you should make it appear more on the screen. All of the skulls on this side are useless as well. and the obstacle with the 45º trampoline is a bit annoying cause a lot of times instead of going in the direction of the chocolate, mice hits the wood. End is good. Plus, that skulls in the middle makes no sense at all. It gives people the possibility of glitching trough it, and the solution for it is simpler than what you made there. Just make the ice wider and there will be no hole at all. P22.
Not a bad map but it lacks gameplay-wise. Firstly, the obstacles above the start are just dull and as mentioned above, the space could have been used in a better way. Second thing that is worthwhile to mention is the cheese chain. It seems okay, although i don't find the obstacle as fun as other obstacles. Also, as mentioned above, all skulls from left side + skull at the middle are useless so I suggest deleting them. To sum up, first and two last obstacles are the best and I think that you should definitely keep them and exchange other obstacles, although you might also keep the cheese obstacle since it's harmless. P22.
I agree with what has been stated above regarding the top right part of the map above the spawn, the obstacles starting from the first skulls part until right before the cheese part could have been better, I'd like to see something more interesting done there. Remove the unnecessary skulls and make the bottom spring token at the cheese part more visible, it took me a bit to notice that it is there on my first tries. P22
The map as a whole is problematic for several reasons. The first obstacle is fine and generally easy to complete after the first few attempts. The second and third obstacles where there are speed coins is where the map starts to become problematic. The player has to be very precise to complete each obstacle, especially at the part where they have to hit the corner of the ice ground to slide up into the water. This part can be tiresome for players if they keep missing the corner. The water ground turnaround is an okay obstacle but can add to the tiresome factor is the player falls, they have to complete the previous obstacles again. The chocolate ground at the cheese area is not needed as the player won’t be able to grab it when falling to grab the cheese. The same could be said for the skull coin in the middle of the vertical ice ground. The spring coin at the bottom is barely visible for the player and might not realise they have to go to the speed coin first. Agreed that the skull coins are not necessary for the obstacles after as they don’t add any difficulty to the map as the obstacles themselves are quite simple and easy to complete. The ending of the map is a bit of an issue for me. The player can easily fail this part of the map which means that they would have to re-do the map again. This is fairly time consuming for a 5 minute map in rotation. For this to be improved, there needs to be some amendments made. For example, the obstacles after the speed and spring coins could be made a lot harder so the skull coins add another layer of difficulty to the map. Another improvement that needs to be made is the ice ground in the top corner of the map. This obstacle needs to be a little bit more forgiving for players to progress through the map. If the right edits are made to the map, I would suggest adding a checkpoint into the map. This could either be just before the cheese or just after. In public tests, quite a lot of players were able to complete the first obstacle after two minutes of understanding on what to do. There were still quite a few that were unable to complete said obstacle, however. Players then struggled to complete the speed coin section of the map and only one made it to the ice ground corner slide section. The said player then missed the corner and had to re-do the map. For the time being, edits need to be made so I will go with a P22.

Stovedove#0000 - @7694690

I see some potential in this map, but quite a few edits would be necessary for it to have chances of perming. First of all, the chocolate on the starting obstacle which has very high friction is very annoying, making most of the players to give up on it right there. That could be a normal chocolate, and you could try to find other ways to make that part difficult. Also, the cheese obstacle is way too cramped, and the invisible wall is not a good thing in my honest opinion. The obstacle itself, though, is fine, so if it is possible to edit it so it has a bit more space to it, while also removing the fake wall, it would be way better. The hole part is way too easy compared to the other obstacles, so adding a bit more difficulty there would be nice as well. Another negative aspect are the number of skulls on the map. Even though glitches are not allowed, trying to minimize the places where they could possibly happen would really improve the maps gameplay. Some of the skulls could be replaced by treadmills with really strong power, so that the mice would be throwed ofscreen and die is probably the best way, and could probably be used on the top skulls on both the left and the right side and maybe the bottom skulls. The water on the skulls are harder to replace, so if the others end up being replaced, keeping those skulls as they are is fine. Gameplay-wise on the water part, it is pretty fun and challenging. Some minor regarding the design could also be better, such as the ground colour (that blue is not very appealing), and the waters overlapping, but thats less important than the other things mencioned above. For now, P22.
I didn't find this map to be anything outstanding but I did feel like it had some potential. It feels like the spring under the trampoline at the top of the map was placed there only to make the obstacle look more interesting, but really it would be the same thing if you remove the spring and higher the restitution of the trampoline which is really boring either way, I would like to see a more interesting way to transition into the water obstacle. The last obstacle is way too easy and dull, I suggest changing it to something completely different for the ending as well. P22.
The majority of the map relies on the player being time specific and precise in their movements and only tests these specific skills. The first obstacle in fairly easy in my opinion and only takes a few tries to perfect it. The chocolate turnaround is simple and holds no degree of difficulty. The sticky ground on the far right isn’t that challenging as the player is able to perfect the timing of when they need to jump. The spring up to the chocolate ground at the top is quite difficult. The player needs to be specific in terms of time where they want to jump and hit the ground. This obstacle doesn’t require super preciseness as the player is able to grab onto different parts of the chocolate ground which allows some flexibility. The chocolate turnaround is similar to the first but with the cheese, again this obstacle isn’t that difficult to complete. The end of the map is far too easy to be a bootcamp map in my opinion. The skull coins hold no difficulty as the player can easily avoid them on both the side and at the top. This section of the map is easy to get through and does not test any major player skills. The last obstacle with the sticky ground and ice ground is simple as well. The skull coins are not needed under the sticky ground because if the player doesn’t reach the whole, they no longer have the speed boost to complete the map. The gameplay is okay, and they made use of all the available space and there is some creativity in the obstacles, however the maps obstacles are too easy. Edits would be needed on a few of the obstacles to make them harder for it to be considered into bootcamp rotation. During testing in a public room, players were unable to complete the first obstacle and only three players managed to complete it. All of the players then later died at the ice slide and the sticky grounds obstacle. I believe after some practice, players would be able to complete this map fairly easily. P22.
The map is very fun to play on however it is clear that the map is too easy. Additionally, the spam of death tokens makes the map look quite messy. There's a good flow to the map with the water + spring combination however edits are needed in all parts of the map. P22 for now.

Pratton#0000 - @7000033

Not a bad map, the concept is pretty nice and it's execution is fun UNTIL you reach top part of the map which is uninteresting and repeating cheese part is pretty frustrating. P22 for now, but I'm looking forward to seeing edits applied to the top part.
I really like the concept, but it's been horribly executed. The start obstacle feels rather lucky than skillbased. Sometimes you hit the ice, but it feels like chocolate.The obstacle on top with the water is way too simple compared to the first and last obstacle. I'd like to see a whole different map. P22.
Wow this concept is really unique, I really like it! Although I'd love to see the last few parts (after the choco TA) to be edited a little. P3 material right here.
I really like the concept but I don't like the map, the only obstacle that I liked is the top left one but the rest isn't really enjoyable (especially the chocolate turnaround part). This definitely has potential for P3, but with better obstacles.
The map is generally okay overall. There’s a fair amount of gameplay as most of the map space is used but each obstacle is fairly big which limits the amount of skills can be tested. The first obstacle is tiresome and glitchy and can throw the player to the other side of the obstacle. The player has to keep retrying to complete the obstacle as it’s very easy to jump too late and touch the chocolate ground at the bottom or jump too early and hit the chocolate ground after. The second obstacle requires the same speed and precision from the first obstacle to get the player to the second half of the map. These two obstacles take up half of the map the map and don’t test the players on any other skill other than precision. The same sticky ground is then repeated to teleport the player to the top of the map. The chocolate ground turnaround is easy and holds no difficulty in completing this obstacle. The third teleporting sticky ground may be confusing for the player as they could assume that they have to jump to the other side rather than carefully moving down the chocolate ground and walking across the said sticky ground. The slanted trampoline jump isn’t a difficult obstacle overall as it’s very forgiving and allows the player to repeat it until they manage to get the cheese. The last obstacle of getting backing to the hole is okay as it is possible for players to die to the skull coins below if they do not sprint far enough. This could be irritating to the player if they die as they have to restart the whole map again. In public tests, players were confused by the first obstacle on the map as a handful of players were on the trampoline ground on the far right believing they had to bounce their way to the top half of the map. The majority of players were killed by the skull coins at the start of the map as they bounced too high off the trampoline ground and only one mouse made it to the second half of the map. The player wasn’t able to complete the other obstacles as they died to third sticky ground teleporting them into the skull coins below. Some edits need to be made to the bottom half of the map which test the players other skills. I would also like to see some harder obstacles implemented into the map. I found the map creative, but I didn’t enjoy the gameplay. I would P22 for the time being.
The map is enjoyable however it could definitely be made more interesting and slight more difficult since it does get pretty easy to farm after a while, I would like to see some edits in the top part of the map mainly since the obstacles could be made into something better. Edits.

Drotik#8972 - @7688823

Even though it is a bit repetitive, I find the map to be really enjoyable. It played very well when tested and mice figured out the pathway pretty quickly. Weak P13.
It is indeed repetitive and I found the obstacles themselves to be bland, just wasn't a fan of this map. P22.
Pretty much dislike this map due to repetitiveness and boredness of it's obstacles. P22.
As said above it's the same over and over again. Once you get the hang of it it'll probably become a farm map. P22.
The overall map is far too easy to be put into bootcamp rotation. The same skill of corner slides is repeated in the middle section of the map and the overall map doesn’t test many of the players skills. The trampoline ground at the top is easy for the player to gain speed to bounce off the other trampoline and collect the cheese. The hardest section of the map is from the cheese past the two water grounds to the chocolate ground, as the player can hit their head on the chocolate ground above and lose their momentum and therefore die. The trampoline on the left to the hole through the four water grounds is fairly easy to complete with ease. In public tests, the majority of players were unable to complete the first obstacle, and a few thought they had to corner jump on the ice section at the bottom. A few players managed to make it to the middle section of the map but later failed believing that they had to use the speed boost to get to the other section on the left. Players were confused as to what the water grounds were for at the top in the middle. There are obstacles in the map which have been seen before but could have been used differently. In terms of gameplay, the map is fairly small and doesn’t use as much space as it possibly could. There needs to be several obstacles which are harder for the player to complete for this map to be put into bootcamp rotation. It’s also unclear for players to know where they have to go once, they reach the water grounds as it looks like there are several routes to completing the middle section of the map. Because the map lacks difficulty, and the reasons stated above, I’ll go with a P22.

Submitted maps that are being discussed:
Alarobzein#0000 - @7718163
Drotik#8972 - @7667199

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue