Rotation Officielle - P4

#8073

Left as is:
@7098887 - Poteerfotter - The map is ok but it is very generic in my opinion. Having two cheeses is useless, so does the cloud is. The construction is fairly simple and lacks of interest.
@7105050 - Soldoju - Antigrav maps are too complicated for most of the players, this one is not particularly easy or interesting and the clouds are completly useless.
@6999619 - Tohpy - I feel we already have so many similar maps, it won't add anything to rotation.
@7108579 - Kwf - To be honest, I think the map is quite boring, there're too many grounds to be truly enjoyable.
@7091977 - Vitordiaspas - Not a shaman map.
@1121345 - Danielmago - Even though I like the design of the map, I feel like the building always be the same; a long bridge and a ramp. The top of the map won't be use so much in my opinion.
@7105114 - Tarciomaneri - Fine as P1.
@7105105 - Ldn - The concept is interesting but I think it needs some edits. The threadmill at the beginning is quite powerful, you should put a chocolate ground at the mice spawn to avoid mass death at the beginning. Plus I don't think the threadmill in the right side really improve the gameplay but whatever.
@6812469 - Antidepressant - Ok so, big amount of water and lava aren't liked in shaman's maps, many shamans struggle with those grounds. Here, the map only requires a long bridge and a ramp, and many mice will be killed by the lava so it is not very interesting.
@7104288 - Rooriluloooo - The grounds seem randomly placed and some are completly useless, so that is not very interesting for the shamans or the players. You should try to do something more organized.
@7103548 - Sirakaba - The map could be interesting, however some grounds seem too random. Moreover, the ice blocks make the map way too cramped, so it is not enjoyable for the shamans to build around.
@7105162 - Andrezitow - Unfortunalty, the map is not very interesting, basically it requires two ramps. This is not challenging or interesting and the construction will always be the same.
@7104406 - Expellus - Not a shaman map.
@4444501 - Sekui - J'aime bien le concept mais c'est beaucoup trop compliqué pour les joueurs, les chamans n'arriveront probablement pas à construire proprement.
@7105258 - Papelio - The map is definitly too cramped, and the path is generic.
@7105389 - Migrange - Les sols de la carte semble avoir été mis un peu au hasard, il n'y a pas de logique dans la carte. De plus, les gros nuages sont plus embêtants que challenging, Les sols de glace et le sol supérieur ont vraiment l'air d'avoir été mis là par hasard, et pour celui du haut, il n'a aucune utilité.
Pense à faire quelque chose de plus réfléchi.
@7105243 - Sladkoru - The first thought I have when I see this kind of map is "Why death tokens while you can put grounds?" There won't be any difference. But the major issue with this map is not the skulls; it's the cramped spaces. The shaman will struggle to do a stable construction with such tiny spaces.
@7105438 - Maxislow - I think those big clouds are spoiling the map, it makes the map cramped and the construction annoying. Many shamans will struggle with those clouds. Plus the map isn't very interesting.
@6749884 - Krato - I think the map has a weird design, it feels to build on it. The construction is quite boring to do, and I think the two cheeses are useless. It is also fairly generic, whatever the path you choose.
@7105822 - Bruno4ponto0 - It only requires a planck, so we can fairly say that it is not a shaman map.
@7105978 - Makudomakudo - Way too complicated for P4, even for P8 I think it is too complicated for most of the mice. I'll try it in public for P8 tho. It's complicated to build properly without going offscreen. I tested it in public as P8, it wasn't good.
@7106169 - Zasadesu - The map is really classic, it only requires few planks, and it is not interesting enough.
@7097860 - Anabooleta - The map is too simple and generic. The construction will always be the same. The map won't add anything to the rotation.
@7104990 - Cakepoprock - Not a shaman map.
@4049755 - Zombiewd - Meh the concept already has been used, and I think shamans will struggle with the cloud, they won't understand how to build around and they'll propably messed up the map.
@6926916 - Wersacho - I tested it in public since last time, shamans weren't good to handle this. I leave it as P1 for now, but I'll do more tests this week cause I'm still hesistant.
@7107577 - Yuugiooohhhh - The death tokens are useless and make the map cramped. Furthermore it is annoying for a shaman to build around that.
@3712555 - Neymazinhor - Already P4'ed.
@6772308 - Provincias - First the grounds are missaligned. Then the map is very generic, there's only one path and the building required is not really interesting.
@7108309 - Piniaadi - Not suitable for rotation.
@7026410 - Miirp - Even if simplicity is often enjoyable, this map is too simple. Some grounds seem to be random, and the construction required is not interesting to do.
@2136042 - Rikkeshang - The concept is ok, but I think it could be better executed. Here the map turns out to be boring, and quite unoriginal.
@6989557 - Tiojeje - The map is too cramped and generic to be enjoyable.
@5286423 - Eohx - Nowadays portal maps are too simple for rotation and this one isn't particularly interesting.
@7010014 - Clackprooo - The clouds are too big to be interesting. They make the map cramped and annoying.

P1'ed:
@7106674 - Verdolagas - Quite ok, but we already have a lot of similar maps in rotation, and the wind is kinda annoying.
@7100031 - Mquk - Le chemin est plutôt générique, mais la construction reste intéréssante à faire, y a pas mal de moyens pour contruire autour de ça. Le design est sympa et j'aime bien la petite touche décorative.
@6510198 - Ratufufu - The is an ok map, but I feel like it stays too generic and it is a bit too cramped too.
@7107451 - V_Ntage - If you have the restorative skill and use it on the two planks, the map can be soloable. However, Plus we already have few maps with the same concept in rotation. It stays a good map overall.
@6792763 - Apollopolo - I think it is quite easy for an antigrav map, but many players are too noob to handle antigrav maps, so I'm not sure about this one. I tested it in public, shamans couldn't handle it properly, so P1'ed.

P4'ed:
@6914910 - Pjfsamora - I don't think the block of wood truly improve the gameplay, but I like the design and how the shaman can build in many different ways.
@5449879 - +Mistersacri - Will be P8'ed instead I think.
@6686061 - Grimmaro - I like the design and how the shaman can build around, even if the top right part of the map feels weird.
@7105996 - Uhuge - I really liked it.
@6971563 - Gobbek - I like the simplicity of the map.
@7073459 - Tdpnice - Nice.
@7108903 - V_21 - This is a weird design and decoration but I actually liked it.
I think it's interesting because shamans will have to think before building, nice.
@1074556 - Garyarcanine - We probably already have similar maps in rotation, but I also like the simplicity of this one.

Ignored:
@7107535 - Fakkedorock - Posted more than 1 map (#8058)
@7107557 - Fakkedorock - Posted more than 1 map (#8058)
@7104776 - Norgnus - Posted more than 1 map (#8038, #8051)
@7100726 - Zackybear - Posted more than 1 map (#8045, #8061)
@7106793 - Norgnus - Posted more than 1 map (#8038, #8051)
@7107858 - Zackybear - Posted more than 1 map (#8045, #8061)

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue