@7519076 - The mobility might make a duo of unexperienced shams struggle here, however I think 2 shams timing their cannons well should make this map feel unbalanced.

@7518627 - The gameplay is not balanced as the map is very much in favour of the players. It will be difficult for the shaman to remove all the players from the map. Additionally, the two curved obstacles on either side are not much of an obstacle as players can easily avoid them. In it’s current state the map will not work in P24.

@7755557 - The map is quite unbalanced when there are two shamans that are well-coordinated. Additionally, it is quite similar to other P24 maps.

@3780736 - It seems to be too easy for 2 well-coordinated shamans, regardless of whether they use the trampoline grounds. Furthermore, we advise not to make the mice spawn on ice grounds as it can be an instant struggle, as the mice should be able to stay balanced while being shot at by cannons from two shamans.

@3878078 - This map requires edits before it can be considered for P24. The shaman cage is too small and can be constricted for two shams, as there would not be enough room to spawn cannons inside the cage. The middle ground in the cage also makes it difficult for the shamans to climb back up. Less experienced players will have difficulty wall-jumping in such a constrained space. The left side is also too tight of a squeeze, and shamans cannot fall down from that side at all. In addition, the centre ice ground at the bottom require constant movement for mice to stay on the platform, which is something advised against. Furthermore, the proximity of the square blocks to the shaman cage allow players that are knocked back to climb back up. The anti-cloud blocks also make it easy for mice to be shot up. This will make it difficulty for shamans to kill mice due to the players' mobility. The square blocks are also a bit too small for players to adequately survive on. The colour of the grounds is also a bit misleading. The light blue and pink can be assumed to indicate ice grounds, due to their light colours. However, once players figure out that the coloured grounds are wood, they will generalize the assumption to the bottom centre ground with the white border, which is a genuine ice ground. This map would not work for P24 in its current state.

@3905863 - This map also requires edits before it can be considered for P24.Shamans spawn only on the top blue corner of the map, which is unsuitable for balanced gameplay. It is also too close to the perimeter of the screen, allowing for offscreen spawning to the side. In addition, the top solid grounds of the shaman spawns are too close to the navigation bar, allowing shamans to spawn up offscreen. The miniscule despawning ground that mice spawn on is too small to survive on. Shamans are also barely able to reach that ground with cannons; mice can jump over the cannons. The triangle ground on the bottom of the map is ice, despite it appearing to have normal friction. The ground lends high mobility to the map as mice will be easily shot up. Although there is a channel that mice can be shot through and die to the height maximum, that channel is narrow and players are able to move to rebound off the upper solid grounds. It is also difficult to kill players on the opposing side's anti-cloud grounds. Mice are easily able to dodge the cannons as they fall through the ground. It will still be tedious if the shamans move to the solid ground of their spawn. Overall, although this map has an interesting layout, its execution prevents it from working in P24.

@7738388 - We suggest that you add a ground above the information bar to stop shamans from moving from their spawn points so they can camp the side of the chocolate grounds and spawn off-screen cannons which other players not be able to see and therefore would have to react quickly.

@7738474 - This map's layout is generic and a bit bland, and thus would lead to repetitive gameplay. The sticky grounds are a unique touch, but they only lend to high mobility for the players, increasing the difficulty for the shamans. There are several areas of the map that are hard to access by the shaman, such as the bottommost platforms, which would require shamans to drop down to the middle level to effectively kill mice. The grounds of the shaman spawn are long as well, which would be tedious for shamans to clear mice off of. This map requires edits before it can be considered for P24, as the gameplay is too skewed towards the mice.

@7745869 - The anti-cloud ground below the shaman spawn allows players to camp this area and makes it hard for the shaman’s to remove these players from the map. Additionally, the middle ground on the left does not need to be anti-cloud as the shaman’s still have easy access to the bottom ground. The anti-ground makes it harder for the shamans to remove the players from this ground as the cannons pass through it rather than rolling on a normal ground. Furthermore, once the diagonal ground has despawned, the players do not have much mobility on the map which makes it hard for them to move around on the map. In it’s current state the map would not work well in the P24 rotation.

@7758472 - Although this map looks quite nice and has no major flaws, the layout of the grounds is too generic. Most shamans will not notice and use the angled undergrounds, which is one of the unique aspects of the map. In addition, shamans have easy access to the mouse spawn due to the spawn range, which make it difficult for players to survive the incoming cannons. The gameplay will also not be very interesting as shamans will most likely target single platforms. Due to the layout of the grounds, the cannons will not affect other platforms much, so mice would only have to wait until the shamans target their ground. This map requires edits before it can work in P24.

@7758950 - Although the layout of this map is rather unique, it would be tedious for the shamans to kill the players. Most of the grounds are 'isolated' from each other, i.e. that the cannoning players off a certain platform has no effect on the rest of the map. This makes it arduous for the shamans to kill mice, as they have to tackle each platform individually, which takes more time. In addition, the left ramp is hard to aim at, so players can camp on it. The rightmost half-arch column can also be used to camp, as shamans cannot reach that platform. Overall, this map requires edits before it can be considered for P24.

@6999321 - The concept of the map is creative, however the spawn points for both the shaman are broken and result in them both being instantly killed. Additionally, as there’s only one shaman on the map at the time, this can be quite boring for the shaman that has to wait as they’re unable to do anything until the other has passed through their cycle. Furthermore, the concept takes up quite a chunk of the map space which then limits the room for grounds and the players. The shaman’s should also have the choice of being able to stand still and spawn grounds as the constant moving cycle can hinder the shaman’s specific spawn. In it’s current state, a lot of edits would need to be made for this to be considered for P24.

@7759557 - The map breaks several rules, such as the map can be completed which is not allowed in Survivor. Please keep the rules in mind while making maps for P24.