Rotation Officielle - P4

#9286

Left as is:
@7270568 - Tenoteno - This map doesn't really offer anything new that we haven't seen already. The cheese simply needs a small bridge and a ramp, and the hole is not that exciting either. Try to make your map fun to shaman on; gives us the "wow" for P4
@7270581 - Claysen - The top left area of the map is kind of useless, the only reason it is there is for symetry and for the shaman to spawn; 9 out of 10 times, the shaman will build out of it and go to the middle platform, and build to the cheese from there. The rest of the map is not very unique nor is it fun to play on.
@7244793 - Yuugiooohhhh - The design choice is interesting, but the gameplay is lacking. To break it down to the bare basics, all the shaman has to do is build over the middle obstacle and build down to the cheese. There is no other route besides to the left of the hole, which doesn't even really serve as a route since most won't use it.
@7266257 - Papelio - The map is pretty boring to build on. There is only really one real route to take, and that is through the cloud and then a ramp over the ice since no shaman will want to build straight through the cloud and risk it. Try to bring more routes to your map otherwise I suggest you start over with a new one.
@7270694 - Fitwick - Boring map; just a few planks and then you're done
@7218362 - Tennistete - Fine as P1
@4321568 - Donmickey - Boring map to build on. The cheese is in a spot where the only thing required is a simple ramp -- then a ramp up to the upper section, then another ramp up to the hole.... then lastly a ramp to the player spawn, I think you understand what I mean
@7275617 - Tucancitto - First off, I don't like how isolated the shaman spawn is -- he has to literally traval all the way over to the player spawn just to even start building, which wastes a few precious seconds. The rest of the map is nothing but a build-a-thon; it takes too long to finish building taking the bottom route.
@7212273 - Bendittt - I am a different reviewer so I am going to tell you that I don't like this map, simply because with clouds like this, you have a force path, making shamans have to build through the clouds, and it's reallly difficult to do that especially for new shamans
@6170479 - Kingdave - As of now, the routes are a little unbalanced, I don't think a lot of people will try and take the right route since it's safer to just go to the left, especially since the mice spawn over there so it makes sense to the shaman to just go back. Try to make the right side more appealing.
@7270905 - Ahyenn - Too hard for a single shaman, try to make this map work for two. Also, try to make it obvious that you can nail things to the clouds as some might just work around them completely without even knowing you can.
@7271092 - Areluissohxx - The clouds are just annoying, especially since the shaman will have to build through both of them; the cloud on the right will lead to off screen building, which is bad since it's well, off screen!
@7271315 - Clautheripper - The dynamic grounds are really annoying, especially since most noob shamans will cannon them, causing the dynamic grounds to mess up and possibly glitch in most cases.
@7264061 - Nikomap - The design gives the shaman a good amount of options to build from, however it just takes too long to finish building with one shaman. Try to either shorten the gameplay up a little or make it work with two shamans.
@7268887 - Simazoooo - Building through clouds are very annoying, and your map is very annoying with the amount you have. Also, the clouds don't really add much towards the gameplay.
@7272434 - Streetraat - The thing is, P4 must require the shaman, otherwise there is no point in it being a P4 map, no? Soloable maps can be submitted through P9 (misc) instead
@7269585 - Andrezitow - Boring map, just a ramp up to each platforms.
@7272589 - Finerlobster - Bridge solution, try to make your maps more fun to shaman on.
@7176188 - Theking2003 - Your map seems more random than anything + all is needed are two ramps on either side of the ice.
@7273278 - Roksiula - Not a shaman map
@7273364 - Propeoplezs - This style of map doesn't work for P4 since mice can do most of the work with minimal shaman effort unless players get stuck at the bottom
@7273431 - Gamog - Shamans aren't really going to take the effort to build a really long bridge below, so that means most shamans will just build a ramp up on top of the ice and then down to the cheese, and then a ramp up to the hole. All of that will make the map tedious and boring since shamans will take the same route every time.
@7269596 - Klarry69 - The map is not really exciting, it is just another portal map that doesn't have that "wow" we're looking for in P4. All is really required is a ramp from the cheese and that's it, players can just jump into the hole.
@7273534 - Mckeydown - While the map is cool, It doesn't really fit the play style for P4, you should try another category
@1504334 - Bobsponjinha - The layout is okay, but it encourages shamans to build the same thing over and over again, and doesn't give shamans the opportunity to be creative. A long ramp is required up to the top right platform, and then a support below -- then a ramp up to the hole.
@7200222 - Mquk - The map turned out to be too hard in public, try to make it easier.
@3847602 - Namelessh -
@7274426 - Maxislow - The right side of the map is too crampped to build down from, causing off screen building. I also don't like what you did with the two ice collums, they just look ridiculous.
@7269974 - Reppam - While I like the idea behind the treadmills, they're just not used in a good enough way that greatly impacts the game play. I could also climb the treadmills by holding the up arrow so that just defeats the purpose.
@7274715 - Ruanndo - Too hard for rotation. The wind is annoying and without the proper support needed, most shamans will fail.
@7264799 - Zasadesu - The wind is not needed to start this off. Another problem is that there is only one route to the cheese, which limits what the shaman can do and what they can build. Lastly, the route below the cloud is way too narrow.
@7274851 - Sirakaba - This is just way too hard for public rotation; shamans will get overwhelmed.
@6162254 - Bubamg - The route on this map is limited since there is only one for the shaman to take; the route is nothing new or spectacular, neither is the map layout.
@7274823 - Merodikku - Just a veryyyyyyyyyyyy long ramp
@7125709 - Dumantepe - This is cool! Sadly, not a P4 map.
@7274645 - Xtuitex - Not a P4 map
@5771502 - Kbrasska - The shaman will take the same route everytime to get to the mice and to the hole, making this map very tedious. The shaman will build under the cheese, then build a ramp up to the hole, and then finally a ramp from the mice spawn.
@7276158 - Vomleci - The route where the mice spawn is located is just wayyyyy too tight, the shaman won't be able to build anything in there. The rest of the map is pretty bland and not very fun + it's borderline build-a-thon.

P1'ed:
@6391066 - V_Ntage - The problem was that most shamans took the exact same route on the right because it's the easiest. Still nice to shaman on though, P1
@7270826 - Commandantso - Too hard for rotation but fine as P1
@6223289 - Kenanskd - The triangle doesn't change the game play too much, but it's cool
@7245200 - Virtini - There was just way too much going on that it made the map more overwhelming that it actually was

P4'ed:
@7104243 - Framnm -
@6656539 - Grimmaro - P8'd
@7235982 - Ikasaruzu - Nothing too special but it worked

Ignored:
@5522938 - Noppew - Posted more than 1 map (#9254)
@5523008 - Noppew - Posted more than 1 map (#9254)
@5523023 - Noppew - Posted more than 1 map (#9254)

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue