Rotation Officielle - P7

Rotation Officielle - P7 - Sans Chamane

Left as is:
@7606254 - Ventrumx#4278 - Mirrored maps are usually boring back and forth and this map is one of those cases, the gameplay is quite short and the cobwebs don't change much it.
@7606558 - Deadlag#0095 - Boring wall jump gameplay.
@7606779 - Xdxboxjaja#0000 - Gameplay is pretty bland, it's only based on run through the map and wall jump. In other words, it's boring back and forth.
@7403601 - Cyclone#3550 - I actually like unpredictable maps, but this concept is already overused and wouldn't bring anything new to the rotation.
@7607323 - Lunaflare#6206 - The map layout and the map itself are both unappealing, the gameplay is bland.
@4814426 - Pgmsule#0000 - Fine as P1.
@5943778 - Shalander#0000 - Good map, but we have similar maps already in rotation.
@5637019 - Viniciusdara#4015 - The map is somewhat different of the others submitted maps, but it doesn't mean the map is good. I found the gameplay a bit boring and a bit hard some parts.

P1'ed:
@7606718 - Renax#3834 - To be honest, the mechanism doesn't impress me and seems a bit inconsistent. But it's p1 worthy.

Will be discussed:
@5492101 - Alnitak#7205 - The gameplay is a bit boring, but I liked the layout. Let's see what others think of it.
@7485554 - Awesync#8255 - Cool

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#9282

@6871856

#9283

@4858550

#9284

@7420498 - edited

#9285

@7608459

#9286

@7601541

#9287

@7272089

#9288

@5209981

#9289

@6452509

#9290

@7262698
@7268948

Dernière modification le

#9291

[Modéré par Etyla, raison : Double post]

#9292

@6522609

#9293

@7608903

#9294

@7609229

#9295

@7154932

#9296

@7578140
@7565782

#9297

@7609460

#9298

Left as is:
@6871856 - Fram#4747 - I found this map to be rather entertaining and fun. I liked the shortcuts and the multiple ways to complete a given obstacle however, you have to understand that P7 is not merely an easier P17 category for normal rotation. I would argue that we have plenty of racing-themed maps in the P7 rotation and would implore you to possibly submit this for P17.
@4858550 - Viniciusdara#4015 - I found this to be an interesting take on a not-so-original concept that isn't necessarily bad, but too difficult and to be honest, quite boring in general given the reptitiveness of the concept. The boosters here are way too strong and that is understandable given that mice need to slow down enough to get up to the cheese however, the problem here is that the boosters are just too strong that even mice who are somewhat good even have a difficult time and it comes down to almost luck-based but not quite, though that doesn't change the fact that this map is tedious and frustrating to do. Unfortunately, even with providing me with some edits, I don't see this map as enough to warrant a discussion but if you were to make the boosters slightly less powerful, I would not mind a P1 if you were to contact me.
@7608459 - Ventrumx#4278 - The concept of using a maze isn't something we usually add to discussion often given the nature of how tedious it becomes but you added water in your version of the map and to be honest with you, I just don't see how the water improves the map as a whole compared to a version without water. There isn't really anything I can say here that will improve this map because on a fundemental level, this map just wouldn't make it to discussion without actually changing the map as a whole, even if there isn't any major flaws preventing it from getting into discussion.
@7601541 - Faizoz#6668 - I like how you gave mice a few different routes to take to get to the cheese and back, even providing multiple cheese and holes but the problem here is that most mice will end up taking the bottom route and then using the trampoline to get into the hole because that's the easiest and fastest route and to be quite frank, it isn't as hard as you think it is for mice to complete. The map as a whole is also quite boring because there isn't really anything that fun or entertaining to be had here due to the amount of walljumping you have to do here; I would encourage you to add different modes of transport in your next map because it makes a big difference in how you can have fun moving around the map. I don't think editing this map will warrant me to give this a chance at discussion so I would recommend starting fresh on a new map.
@5209981 - Alnitak#7205 - I can tell that this map was originally intended by P17 and because of that, this map is just too difficult and to be quite honest, not that interesting as a whole for P7. I have to warn you that P7 is not a replacement category for P17 as both categories are very different so I would implore you to not submit maps from P17 to P7 unless you think the map is good for P7.
@6522609 - Zoldseg#0000 - The map as a whole isn't that interesting because it basically consists of mice running around the map and walljumping which again, isn't that fun. I don't find the wind to be that necessary here and it doesn't feel like you actually made a map for wind but you made a map and then added wind to make it a little more difficult.
@7608903 - Xdxboxjaja#0000 - The map isn't that fun and it's a little too hard for noobs because they're required to do a TA which by the way, is pretty thick and most noobs cannot do that and since there is no shaman, they have no other way to get into the hole. I also don't like how boring this map is because its basically nothing but a really long walljump and then trampolines. I would recommend starting over with a new map and try to make something fun and unique because this map doesn't have either.
@7154932 - Im_Sama#8017 - I have a warning before we get into the bulk of your review, try not to hide your grounds below the chat UI because it is something we reject as it is against the rules, try to raise them up to be visible next time. There isn't really much here in this map other than a walljump and then maybe a cornerjump but what I am trying to say is that the obstacles here are pretty low in quality and as a whole, not that entertaining to do. I would encourage you to do more with your maps in the future.
@7609460 - Erenadoo#9526 - Nothing too interesting here, the lava booster is quite common and it doesn't really do much here that a simple trampoline couldn't have done. Most of this map consists of walljumping or running around the map which isn't that fun. The TA chocolate next to the spawn is a little unnecessary because the TA doesn't give you that much of a shortcut compared to just going up the ice ramp next to it.

P1'ed:
@7420498 - Commandantso#0000 - The map works as intended but this concept has been used so many times. I don't see this map unique enough to warrant a discussion.
@7272089 - Eparcs#0000 - We rarely add maps to discussion that are based on going back and forth but I found the concept to be different and enjoyable enough for P1.
@7609229 - Radioactium#0000 - Not enough for a discussion but I haven't seen a concept like this before even if its a little simple.

Will be discussed:
@6452509 - Grimmaro#0095 - Not a big fan of the ice but it seems to play okay in public and it's kinda fun, will see what others think

Ignored:
@7578140 - +ele#0000 - Posted more than 1 map (#9296)
@7565782 - +ele#0000 - Posted more than 1 map (#9296)
@7262698 - Bravo_45#6976 - Posted more than 1 map (#9290, #9291)
@7268948 - Bravo_45#6976 - Posted more than 1 map (#9290, #9291)

Dernière modification le

#9299

@7610602

#9300

@3662917

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue