@5633026

@5633440

thank you

@3769168

Firstly, this review is a little different than usual. We don't usually give feedback as it takes way too long so you usually just get a list of the accepted maps. However I decided to give it a go giving feedback on each map and although it took a long time (about 3 hours) it was worth it because there are some good concepts and idea's in some of the rejected maps that could easily be recycled into improved and new maps. So please if in your review i've mentioned that it had good concepts, don't be discouraged, and really work to make it work in another map. Secondly, this is a batch review, I've been a lot more lenient with what I've put up for discussion that I usually would be if I was reviewing another category. You'll notice that even some of the will be discussed maps have some suggested edits. This probably means that even if the map is received well by the rest of map crew, you'll probably be contacted to make those edits. So you might as well do it now. Also on a couple of maps I just couldn't do it at all so I've passed them along to the other map crew who are better at bootcamp than I am :^)

Left as is:
@5463152 - Debilenio - Not terrible but a lot of the map is standard ta, cj obstacles and the 10px grounds aren't very appealing. The cheese cj bit is well made and flows nicely but apart from that the map is pretty standard. Also the start is skippable if you have enough lag.
@4991249 - Plussh - Bad alignment and nothing really new. Also hidden roofs are kinda frowned upon
@5610689 - Kikirikirito - Very bland
@2517620 - Framnm - Some nice concepts but the execution is pretty bad. The map is awkward. The double use of grounds on the ending and cheese section are good. Also why does the ice have restitution, it's weird.
@31969 - Zooeynka - Not a map
@5606471 - Clumsydogger - The start is kinda fun if nothing special. The peg's on the right is an overused concept and boring. Rest of the map is pretty much just ta's. Also double cheese wood ta is just no
@4453105 - Minijuruba - I like the map overall but the lava section is way too inconsistent. Maybe change the top right section and resubmit
@5613124 - Brianthegood - Bad alignment and concept don't work very well. Also massively shortcuttable
@5614427 - Yoshiguyfull - I feel bad because it seems like you put a lot of effort in but the map isn't very good. Aside from the bad alignment, the only semi challenging part is the start and after that it's pretty much a racing map.
@5615372 - Ratomkdois - Massively offscreen....
@5616422 - Zzmacth - Start is extremely tedious and aftre that it's just genric ta's and cj's
@5599545 - Adaxone - Every obstacle is just extremely fiddly, precise and unfun
@4896051 - Brwil - I'll post that it's been edited on the thread
@5616587 - Sasoriaka - Ice is almost impossible to see. Aside from that the concepts are ok but nothing really new or special. Also you should export your bootcamp maps as p22 so they don't come up in public rooms
@5619143 - Arcifves - Extremely similar to @168204 by hopeasaur. Also badly aligned and generic.
@5619970 - Xenossixmile - No backrground in bootcamp please. Aside from that the map is pretty standard.
@5620492 - Arecio - Map is badly aligned and pretty much racing
@5622393 - Mousechris - The tramp at the start is hardly even a tramp and after the start the concepts are very standard.
@5555465 - Korzzuz - The concepts are good but the map is very precise and fiddly and doesn't flow very nicely. Also that start would be so clustered in an actual bc room
@5624879 - Reganjsg - Fun map up until just after the cheese cj. Looks like you ran out of ideas and just ended it with a boring ta section. Change the ending to something more interesting and resubmit
@5622646 - Apprise - Fun map up until the wooden wj and the right. After that it goes downhill a bit. Maybe change the top section and resubmit
@5539673 - Fafee - Decent concepts but overall the map is just way too precise even with the checkpoints
@5626126 - Rufflesdqjo - Looks terrible but some nice concepts and fun gameplay. The start is very nice and the lava bit is nice but a little too luck based. The ending could use some spicing up. Overall some good ideas just needs some edits to make it a little mroe consistant and better looking
@5621830 - Comeatmebroz - Map is really cramped and having to do that wj everyy time you fail the start gets so tedious. Perhaps could have potential but as is it's just annoying
@5629276 - Raoubombino - Not bootcamp
@5602763 - Strondaqt - Not terrible but same concept repeated over and over gets a bit boring
@5615620 - Neyrton - First obstacle is good but you can skip the entire rest of the map by just grabbing cheese and jumping back up
@5633440 - Coeai - We don't accept defilante in bootcamp maps
@3769168 - Pikkaczuu - Not very fun and pretty plain


Will be discussed:
@5608861 - Dprocik - Nothing new here but well designed and challenging map. Not a huge fan of those tiny chocolate ta's
@3706413 - Lebeauturque - First bit is way too hard/precise. The cj after is hard but not too bad when you know to hit the ice. I like the up cj section. The left and top section flows nicely but it's pretty much auto, not really any skill involved in it.
@5616777 - Xorcist - You need to extend the offscreen blocking ground higher because it's possible to jump over it still. Also i don't know what the top tramp is for as you can reach the cheese using the bottom section. Overall a fun map though
@5616978 - Danielmago - Personally found the start really annoying but after that it's a pretty solid map
@5377679 - Fluffypuffeh - Nice concept but I dislike the ending
@5615241 - Introsc - Fun map up until the cheese section. Seems a bit hard and unforgiving to not have a checkpoint at the cheese though
@5619383 - Curiousityy - The start is absolutely horrible and seems entirely luck based if you get a grip on the ice gap. Aside from that the map was quite fun and flowed nicely.
@5600000 - Gobbek - Being discussed because i'm too noob and complete it, so need others opinions
@5506702 - Widmill - Was in room when reviewed
@5488903 - Fastyle - Fun map overall, although start can be semi shortcutted
@4820532 - Brunoav - Decent concepts although the double cj but is pretty annoying.
@5598943 - Eili - I'm too noob, need others to test
@5633026 - Uhuge - Has some potential


Ignored:

@5105647 - Drawist - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5491385 - Drawist - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5627712 - Comteatedes - Posted more than 1 maps (separate posts)
@5631093 - Comteatedes - Posted more than 1 maps (separate posts)

@5632692

@5505990

@5632692

@5633873

i to pójdzie na bootcamp?

@5633276

@5617220

@4140331

@5635933

@4453105 - Edited

@5634321

@5636478

@5636655

@5636698

I reported the map (page 46), but mapcrew nothing about it wrote.

@5635110