Rotation Officielle - P7

Rotation Officielle - P7 - Sans Chamane

Left as is:
@7971797 - Zeus#6550 - This map is, overall, linear, with some walljumping, repetitive, and boring. There's nothing here that is actually outstanding, despite the galaxy grounds use - which add little to no gameplay value to the map.
@7971798 - Zeus#6550 - The fact that the map consists of randomness is already a red flag, because it makes it luck-based, which is not so cool. In addition to this, the players can't see what's coming from the bottom, leading to more randomness and also making the map have a boring waiting gameplay.
@7971799 - Zeus#6550 - This map has the same issues as another map of yours that got recently denied: the players have to wait a lot, both when they get teleported and while the galaxies are coming to them. This one is also a bit hard for the players.
@7971949 - Rioxmaps#3702 - What's the point of this map?
@7972362 - Rioxmaps#3702 - This map requires little to no abilities to be completed, and it lacks gameplay a lot: it is mirrored on both sides, as a result, it becomes repetitive, in addition, it has a lot of wall jump in it, which is annoying.
@6367239 - Okpatinhos#0000 - Por favor, não fique enviando o mesmo mapa várias vezes. Bastou um olhar rápido pelo fórum para notar que você tem feito isso muitas vezes com o passar dos anos desde 2015. Você já teve o seu feedback.
@6986493 - Okpatinhos#0000 - Basicamente o mesmo que eu falei anteriormente. Faço das palavras do último feedback dado as minhas.
@7966039 - Dinahmiite#0000 - If the players missed the point of getting the cheese, they can't do it anymore. Other than that, the map is overall generic and has nothing new here.
@7971433 - Dinahmiite#0000 - There are similar racing maps already in rotation. Please, try to be as original as possible while making maps.
@5335738 - Brenow#4577 - This map would add nothing new to the rotation. Besides that, it plays very automatically due to the gravity, the corners, the trampolines and lava, and the ice, which makes the gameplay value low as it can be completed very quickly.
@7972197 - Danzo#6972 - There are maps with the same idea and use of grounds as yours. It has no potential of becoming a highperm map. And, if we were to make it P1, the shaman would lose many saves due to the players dying a lot here, which is not good. That said, staying as is.
@7778778 - Omgjrn#0000 - Do not submit the same map for multiple categories. You got your feedback already.
@7770280 - Bautipro#5357 - It is way too repetitive, and the players will learn the sequence very quickly as they play in this map. If it were random, it would play much better! On a side note, the colors you used here are a nightmare!!!

P1'ed:
@7971793 - Zeus#6550 - Although this map plays fine and it is fun, the gameplay is poor and a bit linear. P1 will do.
@6727359 - Brenow#4577 - As in the previous map of yours, it has nothing interesting here in terms of innovation. But it looks well made and some players can use the shortcut to get some advantage. P1 seems fine.

Will be discussed:
@7961913 - Jasseh#0000 - Simple but fun. I think it might work as P12.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#11022

@6728331

#11023

@7974341
@7974337

#11024

@5963328

#11025

@7396627
@7408920

#11026

@7974546
@7974629
@7974255

Dernière modification le

#11027

@2856960

#11028

Left as is:
@7974341 - Ashiya#2137 - For this map, I felt like I played in a try of a racing map made up to 13 years ago. It has a lot of information, lots of grounds, the map is misaligned, the gameplay is poor, repetitive, and it also feels cramped.
@7974337 - Ashiya#2137 - This map is much better than the other one. However, you're confusing the categories. You should've submitted it for Racing (P17) instead of No-Shaman (P7). But still, it doesn't fit the current standards we're looking for racing nowadays.
@5963328 - Einle#0000 - There are a lot of problems here. First of all, you've made the same mistake as your colleague above, you're confusing P17 with P7. Secondly, the gameplay is poor, repetitive, and would add nothing new for any rotation. Thirdly, it is misaligned, and an offscreen gameplay can be done on the top part of it, avoiding the map's path and consequently, its purpose.
@7974546 - Akiong#3458 - This map is way too deadly, it doesn't fit any rotation category.
@7974629 - Akiong#3458 - Maps like that are often frustrating because you'll take a long time to complete them and will do the very same thing repetitively until you do it (if you do it). It lacks gameplay diversity a lot here.
@7974255 - Akiong#3458 - This map is way too deadly, it doesn't fit any rotation category.
@2856960 - Katwyn#1614 - Você enviou o mesmo mapa para P9. Não fique enviando o mesmo mapa para múltiplas categorias. O comentário de lá é o mesmo aqui.

P1'ed:
@6728331 - Jasseh#0000 - This map works fine, and has a layout that we're not used to, especially for the shaman items rotating other than using a spinning ground. Nevertheless, that's all the map brings us. To sum up, works fine, looks good, but there's nothing that justifies it to become a high perm. P1 will do!
@7408920 - Mquk#0095 - The map plays fine, the circular galaxy ground was a nice use here. But it is way too simple for the high perm rotation. P1 seems fine here.

Will be discussed:
@7396627 - Mquk#0095 - Simple map, but very cool! I am only concerned about trolls in this map, once it can be completed very quickly, and they will just stay there until the time ends. Let's see what the others think about it.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#11029

@7974652
@7913942
@7974656

Dernière modification le

#11030

@7899512

#11031

@7974929

#11032

@7975210
@7975213

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue