Elacg a dit :

@1573445 unaligned

I don't think alignment really applies to P17.

Beachking a dit :

I don't think alignment really applies to P17.

^
I think Barrydarsow should consider the alignment at P17 reviews, because the alignment is ESSENCIAL in every P#

Unless gameplay is affected by poor alignment, it doesn't matter.

@2465212 p6
i don`t see how this would ever be a mech map

Why deperm? @4119570

Polypopu a dit :

@2465212 p6
i don`t see how this would ever be a mech map

When the joint update left P6 with only 50 or so working mech maps this was one of many that were added to fill the void.

Jyclone a dit :

Why deperm? @4119570

The map just wasn't fun.
Next time ask someone in-game or in IRC, that isn't what this thread is for.

@3971113

1 color ground is not needed
2 fake grounds
3 No reply value
4 pretty much build a bridge gameplay

Barrydarsow a dit :

When the joint update left P6 with only 50 or so working mech maps this was one of many that were added to fill the void.


The map just wasn't fun.
Next time ask someone in-game or in IRC, that isn't what this thread is for.

will @2465212 be removed / changed to a different rotation type when the void is filled? it really doesnt fit the category.

I've never seen any public complaints about it. Time will tell.

offscreen advantage @494706 upstairs to get the cheese

Both maps are p4.
It's not an exact copy but it's similar gameplay/positoning well kinda.
@4062696
@3820670

They look a like. The first one needs to be depermed.

@1090447 - P8

Near impossible for 2 shamans who happen to be on hard mode (even very skilled shamans). With the update, this is not feasable. If I remember correctly, maps should be some what possible for someone who has had a little experience at the game. This is definitely not the case. I have played this map while many great shamans are present and haven't seen very many do it. It's really just not fit for normal rotation. Truthfully, it was barely possible before the update.

Elacg a dit :

offscreen advantage @494706 upstairs to get the cheese

Fixed, thanks.

Beachking a dit :

Both maps are p4.
It's not an exact copy but it's similar gameplay/positoning well kinda.
@4062696
@3820670

They look a like. The first one needs to be depermed.

Many shaman maps look similar, they're fine.

Johnlantern a dit :

@1090447 - P8

...

This and a bunch of other P8s are being rediscussed at the moment.

excuse me barry in all do respect but why are you reviewing? Wouldn't it be against the rules knowing you're no longer any staff? It's nothing against you personaly, we all know you'd be qualified, it's more of the situation

Ravynn a dit :

He's still a mapcrew member, he only left the moderation and sentinel(?) team.

Aqvaswirle a dit :

Like Ravynn said, Barry is still a mapcrew member and it's his choice to not hide under "Mapcrew" account like all secretive mapcrews do.

That's fine and all, but then 1 shouldn't his name be blue and 2 they say he left the mapcrew in Topic-36452 so I'm a bit confused right now

Unless by that last part you mean any former mapcrew can still login with Mapcrew account, I'm confused about what you meant by that