Rotation Officielle - P5

#101

Left as is<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
@4709422 Uskil Collision on Jane's ponytail could be improved, gameplay in
general is fun and improved from the last time I saw the map,
but start lag is still a big issue.
@4961360 Sherrwagn Cute map, but collision and ground properties are confusing
@5038667 Sherrwagn Lovely map, although the collision at the right hand side of Olaf
could be improved, getting up from the right hand side seems a
little awkward to me and with the flowers (if that's what they
are) being bouncier that could be solved, and the bottom of Olaf
just cuts off abruptly.
@4951087 Jyclone The art is spot on but gameplay is really lacking. In my opinion
making art bouncy for no reason is worse than simple
wj-over-the-art since it's unexpecred which makes for poor
gameplay, especially since one of the four hats for some reason
isn't bouncy. The ground at the right of the map by the side of
Kyle is odd since I expected to fall to the same level as the
characters are standing, rather than just walking along the
backdrop. Work on the gameplay mainly.
@5074756 Mousechris This art isn't terribly detailed and lack of gameplay certainly
doesn't make up for it.
@5084639 Biripin Walljump-over-the-art gameplay and the grounds are confusing
with their properties.
@5097498 Biripin Confusing collision and gameplay is poor, not to mention there's
not enough art for an art map.
@5085873 Xxshedownxx Art isn't terribly detailed nor is the gameplay interesting.
@2583438 Peppio This is a great idea, but the art is pretty simple and gameplay
isn't terribly interesting.
@5082184 Squirtlspkmn Collision could be improved, art could be rounder, map could do
with decorations, but the gameplay is just wj-over-the-art, so it
isn't very interesting.
@5086610 Cimentooo I assume this is meant to be a character from Cyanide &
Happiness, it captures the style perfectly. Unfortunately
gameplay is pretty lacking.
@5083848 Cimentooo Art is pretty undetailed and gameplay is lacking a lot.
@5083656 Jagunu Invisible hole, unaligned grounds, very vibrant background with
a very simple pattern rather than detailed or interactive art.
@5089019 Yoyoomar Homer looking at the cheese would make this art make a lot
more sense, but it's very sketchy and could be improved to look
rounder and smoother, the map itself is plain and could be
aligned better, gameplay has no interaction with the art.
@5089194 Lisathecute This is great and the map has an awful lot of potential as a
concept, but there are a few problems. Firstly mice are forced to
walljump at the spawn, what about the mice that can't do this
since the shaman has no building room to help them? The sun (I
assume it'ss a sun) doesn't really fit in with the rest of the map,
nor should have collision. The lower parts of the arrow have no
collision which is confusing, and the cheese is floating.
@4485076 Slayermaster I fail to see the art in this. Big grounds like this are just laggy
and mice seem as if they're floating. Could be aligned better.
@5089751 Vegetablee Art has no interaction with gameplay and most of the map is
blank, this much of the map being white with small cutouts
doesn't look too good either.
@5089738 Leogon Art isn't detailed and has no effect on gameplay, basically a free
cheese map.
@5089782 Geovanezikka Cute map, but collision is awkward, gameplay just consists of
walljumping over the art, and the different frictions on the art is
confusing.
@5089986 Sebitacapoda A very nice and clean map, but art has no effect on gameplay,
and the gameplay itself is poor.
@5090062 Nargss Map seems far from complete, although the lineart is adorable.
@5087789 Xariio Art is cute but has no effect on the gameplay which makes it
very lacking.
@4917907 Xariio Cute again, but the amount of shaman interaction in this map is
just enough to make it tedious to play, it seems it's not needed
at all with a little editing. Art could interact with the gameplay
by lifting mice up or something similar, too.
@5088566 Typhoonhika Lightning bolts could be more detailed, gameplay is pretty poor
and I feel like it could be imrpoved.
@4968709 Wollacy Getting out of the spawn is a pain, gameplay doesn't interact
with the art, and shamaning gameplay isn't very inviting.
@5092167 Jagunu Art isn't very detailed, gameplay is very basic.
@5092522 Nubcolorado Walljump-over-the-art map, not interesting gameplay. The body
is offscreen.
@3114781 Mrkurt Art is simplistic although as detailed as it needs to be so that's
fine, gameplay can be fun but is pretty poor.
@5094089 Vegetablee Map is far too vibrant, gameplay is confusing, and collision is
poor.
@5094868 Joseventus This map is beautiful, I love it! The bench seems to be floating,
different silhouettes having collision and not having it is
confusing, gameplay is pretty poor. Work on these things
(mainly interesting gameplay) and this'll definitely be up for
discussion.
@5057568 Skymauss Lineart doesn't seem finished, gameplay is random, map is very
unaligned.
@5059603 Skymauss This map is just inviting crashes, gameplay is extremely poor,
it's almost impossible to get the cheese.
@5095123 Lemurjede Walljump-over-the-art gameplay, not very interesting.
@5096179 Karodemata Offscreen hole and cheese.
@5078058 Sebashabbo Not an art map, hidden cheese and hole, unaligned,
unnecessary start.
@5100956 Newnicemice Collision is awkward, gameplay isn't terribly fun or interesting.
@4662540 Newnicemice Unown art is rather simple which you can't avoid, but the
gameplay isn't interesting enough to make up for it.
@5101598 Slayermaster THE EYES! IT'S SO CUTE! Unfortunately the gameplay on this is
really poor and leads to a lot of deaths, I'd like to see that fixed
and more interesting gameplay involved.
@4653804 Mathiiixz Gameplay is rather poor.
@4491667 Douglaswilam Art is rather simple and gameplay doesn't make up for it.
@5102677 Tasted Art fits in well, but the chocolate grounds being ice is a little
annoying and confusing, and the map is so simple to beat it's
almost free cheese.
@1748760 Enoismanoo Not an art map.
@5104931 Theform Not an art map, nor aligned. Invisible hole.
@5107109 Mehlkaa Gameplay is pretty simple and boring, art isn't terribly detailed.
@5106228 Tearwing Spawn is too low, cheese and hole are too close to eachother,
art isn't very detailed, gameplay is lacking.
@5109837 Kohyingjie Art isn't very detailed, gameplay is poor. Let your art speak for
itself, with a landmark as well known as Tower Bridge people
should recognise it instantly if it's good enough, without text on
the map.
@5066427 Slonamyszka Scrolling seems unnecessary and there's a lot of whitespace on
the map. Gameplay is poor and art isn't very detailed.
@5106673 Slonamyszka Creepy cat, unfortunately the art isn't detailed enough.
Gameplay is poor, grounds are unaligned, having decorations
have collision but the wood ground not is more than confusing,
and there's an offscreen shortcut.
@5112327 Snowysun Gameplay is lacking, art is unaligned, mice jump to the lamp
and die since it has no collision.
@5113420 Rafatimaoaff Some grounds have fixed rotation and others don't, it's awfully
confusing. Gameplay is pretty lacking and the blocks' art isn't
very detailed, nor do they stack together properly.
@5113954 Ilanoudecp Reminds me very much of [url=@1243782]Musketrat's old
P5[/url], the gameplay isn't terribly interesting either.
@5114301 Korzzuz When the flying mouse goes around a second time it's not in
sync with the tubes.
</textformat>

P1'ed<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
@4598787 Uskil The art is wonderful but gameplay is pretty poor, collision is a
little off in places and part of the branch having no collision is
confusing. Soloing the map seems too difficult for anyone to
enjoy, and build for the shaman is extremely simple and boring.
@5083694 Peppio Art is cute but gameplay is lacking and most of the map is
blank. You can't even see the top of the hat, and bottom of the
mouse is just white.
@5091812 Geovanezikka Art and gameplay are separate, the art is good but lack of
gameplay puts me off.
@4503063 Rasmaru Seems like a nice logo copy, but gameplay is just walljumping
over the art, I'm sure this won't make sense for many people,
and in general is pretty undetailed.
@5051827 Acefakeeeh Those googly eyes are creepy, they're staring at me! Gameplay
seems to fit but isn't really interesting, and the art is fairly
undetailed.
@5099057 Diabet This map is beautiful despite how simple it is. i'm not too fond of
the simple hole and think it could be improved, gameplay is just
walljumping over the tree, but the map looks nice.
@4555383 Tasted Simple and gameplay is lacking, but I'm a fan of the retro
ground art style.
@4288624 Shalander Art is nice, but gameplay is mainly just consisting of waiting
once you get on the ballon. The other bubbles moving around
don't make much sense nor look very realistic floating around in
sync.
</textformat>

Will be discussed<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
None
</textformat>

Ignored:<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
@5094861 Freseroctm Blacklisted
@5096870 Freseroctm Blacklisted
@5097099 Freseroctm Blacklisted
@5097349 Freseroctm Blacklisted
@5089402 Nlff Posted more than 2 maps (separate posts)
@5114343 Nlff Posted more than 2 maps (separate posts)
@5096868 Nlff Posted more than 2 maps (separate posts)
</textformat>

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue