Rotation Officielle - P8

#1204

Left as is:
@4886481 - Joseventus - Nice map, but the cloud grounds being so uneven distances from the wood looks messy. Tidy up some of the alignments.
@3321599 - Joseventus - Interesting map, I like that it's open for interesting builds, but I dont see this as future rotation because the right side looks cramped and disorganised.
@6337717 - Bleoons - Nice and open map, but it seems similar to another P8 map already in rotation in regards to building straight up to cheese, then to the hole.
@2001846 - Triboxxl - Similar concepts already in use in p4 and p8. Nice that it isnt cramped but cheese being in cloud doesnt give this map enough difficulty for dual shamans.
@5935170 - Reppam - Map is a little cramped for building, and I feel the map could be completed by a single shaman well within the time frame.
@5606643 - Reppam - I like that everything is well aligned and nice to build on for the shamans. However it's a little cramped in some spots for building.
@6309540 - Marceleyly - Similar to other maps in rotation, doesnt really feel exciting to build on. However it is nice and open for building which is always a plus.
@5637035 - Viniciusdara - Nice map, interesting paths, the cloud grounds a little too thick, especially due to leaving so little room for shaman to build for cheese. Fix that and I will put up for discussion.
@6329868 - Viniciusdara - Building upwards on the left side is a pain because small area to build in without going offscreen, Also the solo path isnt the best for P8. Otherwise map is pretty enjoyable and interesting.
@6348881 - Gusfromcc - The single path is a bit of a let down with this map. Seems quite similar to your other submission which I prefered.
@6369999 - +Mistersacri - Cheese part with the clouds is way too cramped to build for.
@3826286 - Framnm - Similar sort of concepts to maps already in rotation that are far less cramped. However it was a nice effort.
@6339153 - Framnm - I feel the wood ground on the left side was next to pointless, would be better if it was removed and map shifted towards left. Giving more room to build in between the grounds.
@6355412 - Lipeproziim - The cloud grounds give a very cramped feel to the map. While I love the mech involved between switching between cheese and hole, the rest of the map lacks interesting features for the shamans to pass.
@1623334 - Wangan - Too long for me to P1, not as interesting obstacle wise as your other submission, but I really like the water part. Would like to see that put into a more interesting map.
@6354400 - Uelintondd - Map is nicely aligned however it is quite cramped for building in.
@6355802 - Lipeproziim - Interesting concept but I feel it could be executed better, perhaps not having the ice moving so fast.
@3478526 - Brenoouuw - Single path and cramped spaces are not the best for P8. The grounds were nicely aligned however.
@6358075 - Joeprooxxdd - Space under the ice is far too small/cramped for P8, otherwise the map is quite nice.
@6361369 - Trtgala - While I like the openess and possibility for builds on this map, it is far too similar to other P8s in rotation.
@6361797 - Jinglebrasil - I do like the two paths and moving ice idea behind the map, I feel most shamans will always build the same way because of where the ice starts off and not realise it can be moved.
@6367890 - Brenouw - While the grounds are nicely aligned, all the clouds make the map too easy to complete and look messy.
@3971751 - Srmal - While the map looks interesting, most of the grounds dont server a purpose. Leaving it to be just one gigantic build for the shamans to complete within the time.
@6373434 - Srmal - Love the concept but in my opinion could have been executed better. I feel it's far too much of a build-a-thon for the shamans to complete it in time, especially with the hole located where it is.
@6375686 - Esqueleticuu - Grounds are poorly aligned, Map looks way too messy.
@6375905 - Mrorko - Similar to other maps in rotation already. However, map is well constructed and looks nice.
@4198604 - Mazeq - Grounds are well aligned and map looks good, however, it is single path with quite a few areas being too cramped for construction by the shamans.
@4293980 - Mazeq - Grounds appear quite haphazard. While it is a nice attempt the map is far too single build path to be enjoyable by dual shamans.
@6359073 - Szamankakox - Similar concept to other maps in rotation. Just a box spam for the shamans to complete the map.
@6366562 - Enmasi - I dont think you quite understand what P8 category is, your map does not require a shaman, let alone two, to complete the map.

P1'ed:
@6343425 - Gusfromcc - Looks quite similar to another P8 in rotation, Cloud grounds with gap makes the map somewhat easy and the water is a nice touch of difficulty to counter that.
@2660560 - Modifys - Nice map, interesting ways to build, however I feel far too simple for P8, might suit P4 more.
@6031455 - Modifys - The map looked lovely and grounds were aligned perfectly. However, can easily be completed by a single sham, also single path solution.
@6362712 - Souradiativo - Map is nicely aligned and looks good however, map is single path solution that can easily be completed by one shaman.

Will be discussed:
@6345421 - Renaxan - Interesting new concept, enjoyed it, pretty open for building and looks pretty.
@1929779 - Triboxxl - Nice map, open spaces, ice gives it that difficulty for shamans not on normal mode.
@6152377 - Uhuge - Like this map concept, interesting enough to be discussed.
@3305130 - Aksale - Like the different build path choices and map looks really nice and well put together.
@5553609 - +Goondad - The circle cloud looks more interesting than it is. But something about this map makes me enjoy building on it.
@920732 - Wangan - Nice map with a few paths for shamans to build.
@6376186 - Zhouajie - The concept, the execution and the design of the map are all amazing.
@4184975 - Vvarriorw - Really interesting concept, makes the shamans build quickly, but still allows slow ones to complete the map by stopping at the end. I do worry that first cheese and hole will not be utilised often though.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue