Sourisplum a dit :

well I guess today's the twentieth and it doesn't look like I'll be getting any more entries SO

Okay so instructions for the judges who I believe are Thefourthone and Immagetcheez ARE to look at all the entries, and assign a number to them (you can use 1-5, 1-10, heck you can even use 1-1000 I don't care as long as you use the same system for all entries) and then post them in a list here. Immagetcheesed cannot judge her entry since she'll probably give herself a really low score.

so there

I'll add all the numbers up after they judge

Lmao

Sounds good! I'll get to it.

alright here's my dumb list

mousechris
2
1
4
unicorm
1
3
1
1
1
taleyes
6
8
5
rebornaddict
2
1
2
1
1
phedparty
2
7
bengalstar
1
1
sunnyweathr
8
9
vivihi
1
1
sirusthemice
8
6
cilekli
1
1
immagetcheezed
9
kattiej
1
2
livcorvish
1
susanlwu
5

this is actually using a one to ten scale and not a one to three scale as most of the scores suggest

and no I am not being biased against ones made in dressroom

most of them just suck

mousechris:
4
1
3

unicorm:
3
6
1
2
1

taleyes:
4
2
2

rebornaddict:
1
2
1
1
2

phedparty:
3
9

bengalstar:
2
4

sunnyweathr:
8
7

vivihi:
1
1

sirusthemice:
10
10

cilekli:
2
2

immagetcheez:
10

kattiej:
1
2

livcorvish:
2

susanlwu:
6

judged this on a one to ten scale

nnn so excited for the other scores.

Lol i did better than I thought lol
i want to see who wins

a dit :

Mousechris: one two three
Unicorm: one two three four five
Taleyes: one two three
Rebornaddict: one two three four five
Phedparty: one two
Bengalstar: one two
Sunnyweathr: one two
Vivihi: one two
Sirusthemice: one two
Cilekli: one two
Immagetcheez: one
Kattiej: one two
Livcorvish: one

EDITING THIS POST WITH CRITIQUES. THANK YOU FOR LETTING ME JUDGE PLUMU ♥

Mousechris: #1 - It's quite unique, but it lacks decoration. (3)
Mousechris: #2 - I see that it's quite Japanesey! I like it! (6)
Mousechris: #3 - Ah, your classic. I'll like it, but the items are a bit mainstream. The colours though? Wonderful! (4)

---

Unicorm: (I LOVE your stuff btw!) #1,2,3,45 - I love the colours, styles, furs, and themes. Totally a (13 overall!

---

Taleyes: #1,2,3 - Yes, I loved them all. A few points of for no originality (using Plumu's bases). Nice colours though! Although it seems harsh for me to take off points for originality, I'm kinda scoring for the things you mice think up on your own.... how well the colours go (see yours were nice, so you get a good score) and how well the designs flow. And how much you've thought of youself ^^ (5)

---

Rebornaddict: #1 - Cute! (1)
Rebornaddict: #2 - That's too cuuuuute aw (3)
Rebornaddict: #3 - That's nice, but I've seen it too much before ;_; (2)
Rebornaddict: #4 - Yup, this is pretty cool (2)
Rebornaddict: #5 - Icey, cool! Sorry, I don't really like how the colours are, they're just too.... messy.

- These are nice, but they're quite mainstream with the furs and items. I'm kind of looking for original colours and crazy ideas. Sorry :S (2)

---

Bengalstar: #1 - That's cute! Also a great halloween ghost costume. (4)
Bengalstar: #2 - THIS is beautiful. I love using the mask/feathers like that! I really like the moon and night theme. (9)

---

Sunnyweathr: #1 - Just pure beauty. Reminds me of something greek and mythical. I LOVE the vines on the tail. Like a goddess *-*! (8)

Sunnyweathr: #2 - Oh my gosh I just love this one! Turkish gypsy maus! The items are very original. (9)

---

Vivihi: #1 - Well, the colours are very vibrant! The items just don't go well together, and it doesn't sing in my opinion. (2)

Sunnyweathr: #2 EVEN MORE BEAUTIFUL! GEEEZ! Turkish dancing gypsy maus! ♥ (8)

wow are you really critiquing them all

ps do you really think it's fair to take points off for using a base? I mean check out all the people who used dressroom, the base is just to help people who don't have confidence in drawing mice to be able to draw original accessories on

pleasedonthurtme

also could you score individual designs and not a group of entries

Sourisplum a dit :

wow are you really critiquing them all

ps do you really think it's fair to take points off for using a base? I mean check out all the people who used dressroom, the base is just to help people who don't have confidence in drawing mice to be able to draw original accessories on

pleasedonthurtme

Sure! I'll put them back on. The bases just didn't have many items - and this is a design contest, and those w-

Point taken ♥

Sourisplum a dit :

also could you score individual designs and not a group of entries

'K doke!

i dont mind if i failed but i dont see my name in either of the scores
was i disqualified for doing something wrong or...?

Susanlwu a dit :

i dont mind if i failed but i dont see my name in either of the scores
was i disqualified for doing something wrong or...?

ack sorry I forgot to add your entry to the OP

um holly if you don't judge I'll go with just our two scorings

No it's alright I should be done soon afff sorry

If you don't mind for the people who've done more than one I'm goint to judge them over all ;u;

okay since it's apparently impossible to get holly to finish anything I'm just going with what me and fourth did

First place-Immagetcheezed
Second place-Sirusthemice
Third place-Phedparty

If you won please post your ref here to get your prize!

ps Sirus and Phed actually tied for second but since they both submitted two entries and sirus scored more than phed did on the other one sirus gets second

get it? probably not

if you see any problems please tell me

YAAYY GJ GUYS GJGJGJ!!! proud of you guys

o wowie second i always come second oh well atleast i made it somewhere eheh

either one of these two



second one is actually supposed to have a bowtie but ungh.

OH LOL AHHAHAHA

im crying but okay
i think it's weird though that people who used dressroom get higher points than people who actually drew

ah well
gj gj immagetcheezed, sirusthemice and phedparty

ahh
good job to the winners oUo