Rotation Officielle - P17

#14083

Left as is:
@7967174 - Relaxbir2#3456 - There is too many features used in a same map so the players are kinda lost about what to do, the lava feels a bit random. Need also big improvements on the design.
@7968724 - Relaxbir2#3456 - This one is also a bit messy, the way you used the ice buff seems quite useless and uninteresting because you could just replace the chocolates by ice. The beginning seems cool but everything after is messy, has a bad flow and does not work well. Again the map is kinda ugly and doesn't fit with racing standarts.
@7962536 - Dinahmiite#0000 - Fun map, it has potential and we hope to see antoher version in the next review. It lack a bit of obstacles and the ending is boring. You could add an obstacle on the top left part of the map and do some changes on the top right to improve the end. The shortcut with the 45° trampoline could also be improved because it is very precise and longer than the other way.
@7969021 - Tadzio#2404 - Boring and basic gameplay, the honey is almost useless.
@7969083 - Bwoim#0000 - Very very similar to a map already in the rotation.
@7969086 - Bwoim#0000 - Very very similar to a map already in the rotation.
@7969147 - Zeus#6550 - The beginning and the cheese is fun but all of the right part is boring and the bottom feel useless. We suggest you to change everything after the cheese/after the second galaxy.
@7969587 - Zeus#6550 - Cool concept, the bottom left obstacle is really fun but the transition between the beginning and the left is quite bad and slow. We would like to see edits on the right part to improve that, once you've done it, you can contact us and we will put it in discussion if we think it' ready
@2141556 - Katwyn#1614 - The concept is interesting and the very fast way by using all the portals is fun but it looks like everything has been made only for that way. The normal way is quite boring, messy and frustrating. Could definetely see something perm with invisible tps like this but need improvements on the design and on what has been mentioned before.
@7969355 - Danzo#6972 - Basic gameplay and the map is empty, the only thing I appreciated is the way to go back to the hole from the cheese but besides that it is quite generic.
@7748453 - Tdpnice#0000 - Some good shortcuts but overall quite messy. It is very precise and almost luck based to do the shortcut at the beginning, the bottom right is very boring and can be skipped if you're lucky enough on the start.
@7944415 - Katwyn#1614 - Despite the edits, this map is still looking similar to another one that has been recently added to the rotation. Please, try to be as original as possible while making a map. Also even if we don't consider the context behind this map, the main shortcut is fun but very unstable because the speed if often stopped by the galaxy grounds. The other way, if you fail to do the shortcut, is very boring.
@7969885 - Bisbilhoteir#1596 - Offscreen obstacles, half ot the map is empty and most of the obstacles are very basic and uninteresting things for racing.
@7969941 - Brian#8804 - There is only one way to complete the map and most of the obstacles are automatic once you understood how to play it.
@7969962 - R_y#8502 - The low restitution of the trampolines just make the map boring and too slow. It is quite hard to go to the hole from the cheese without using again the portals. Overall the map is a little boring.
@7969963 - R_y#8502 - Repetitive and similar to other maps from the rotation, also low value of the galaxy grounds because it could just be trampolines instead.
@7329998 - Mquk#0020 -
@7288884 - Mquk#0020 -
@7966066 - Bautipro#5357 - A little too simple and the map feel incomplete, you could remove the top half and it wouldnt change anything because everybody tries to reach the hole in the bottom, the map feel a little too cheap for P17.
@7970007 - Bautipro#5357 - The gap near the hole is very cramped and annoying to pass through when you are returning. Besides the shortcut with the corner of the trampoline, the map feels a bit too automatic once you understand the way to complete it.
@7953323 - Antoni0#8587 - The main concept of the map doesn't really match with this category.
@7970815 - Jordan8#2489 - Very basic gameplay, the cheeses are almost offscreen and hidden and the map is very empty.
@7971057 - Xendpoint#0000 - This map seems too complicated and confusing for racing. The ice buff seemed useless to us (or is it just to help going through the cobweb?) but maybe it has another purpose and it would mean it's again too confusing. Most of the obstacles aren't natural to play and feels more like bootcamp vibe (but slighlty easier) than racing vibe.
@7376303 - Brenow#4577 - The gap between the two wood grounds in the top left is too short so the players can't go there, not sure if this was intended but if it was, having to go back to the top left after getting the cheese is kinda frustrating and not very fun.
@7960789 - Rioxmaps#3702 - Too similar to another map from yourself (@7526673), it wouldn't bring anything new to add that one too.

P1'ed:
@7961021 - Dinahmiite#0000 - Not a bad map but basic and a little generic.
@7950182 - Danielmago#5918 - Plays well but fit more P1 than P17. Also the acid is quite useless and very easy to avoid.
@7969667 - Danzo#6972 - Okay gameplay and the flow is cool but too simple for P17
@7962073 - Rioxmaps#3702 - Not an uninteresting concept but once you understand that you must go high from the spawn, the map becomes a little too boring for high perm.

Will be discussed:
@7969056 - Tdpnice#0000
@7970167 - Danielmago#5918
@7406473 - Brenoouuw#0000

Ignored:
@7968810 - Jim#3189 -Posted more than 2 maps (#14058, #14072)
@7970369 - Jim#3189 -Posted more than 2 maps (#14058, #14072)
@7970059 - Jim#3189 -Posted more than 2 maps (#14058, #14072)

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue