Rotation Officielle - P17

Rotation Officielle - P17 - Racing

#14101

@7107529

Dernière modification le

#14102

@7968080

#14103

@7971812

Dernière modification le

#14104

@7607750

#14105

Left as is:
@7971425 - Tadzio#2404 - The way you can complete the map by using twice the lava is fun but overall the map is not good enough for racing and a little generic.
@7912890 - John#9081 - We have seen many maps like this one before so it is not something we are looking for, the gameplay is quite generic and there is nothing that stand out from some other maps we have already in the rotation.
@7376303 - Brenow#4577 - The only interesting part of the map is the shortcut on the end in my opinion, everything else feels boring and bland.
@7877396 - Wiannix#7716 - Overall the map doesn't really fit with the racing category, I can see some obstacles that you could keep for a racing map, for example the cheese part with the column on the right, but right now it is a giantic chain with no shortcuts (except on the end if you consider that a shortcut) and there is no ways to comeback once you missed a small thing.
@7971803 - Z0mb4#1472 - Too low to reach a perm, the map is really short and empty and the gameplay is very basic. The whole right part of the map is useless because you can just complete it by reaching the fake chocolate (do not add fake grounds in your maps!).
@7960976 - Danielmago#5918 - Not a very good use of the galaxy grounds in my opinion, not sure if it was intented but you can avoid using twice the pink galaxies by just reaching the ice on the top. The shortcuts are a little boring and it is overall not interesting enough for racing.
@7971826 - Kikii#4681 - The obstacles are too narrow and you can't really control yourself, all you gotta do is jump at the perfect timing but apart from that it is just an automatic maze.
@7971279 - Rioxmaps#3702 - I like the shortcut on the end to go under the water and the ice with a cornerjump but everything else is not very well made and it feels frustrating to play. You can reach the cheese from the middle but you die to the acid, going to the right part is annoying because of that close gap between the ice and the earth. I think it is hard to use that concept with only 1 water, at least right now it doesn't look ready for racing to me because there is too many things that are wrong.
@7971440 - Dinahmiite#0000 - Even though I can see you did efforts to make this map, the gameplay doesn't really stand out from the maps we have in the rotation, it is still quite simple and generic.
@7970814 - Dinahmiite#0000 - Only walljumps and a few cornerjumps, again too generic and basic.
@7107529 - Sharking#2914 - It looks like you improved it since last time you sent me the map but the obstacles are still too narrow and basic. The first shortcut with the upcj is fun, could be improved a little but it works, that's what i would keep but the rest will not be good enough.
@7971812 - Urook#1131 - Je pense que le gameplay est un peu trop lent et répétitf pour du racing, même si il y a plusieurs manières de finir la map, je doute que ca puisse correspondre à ce style de jeu.
@7607750 - Olwys#3385 - Not a bad map but it's far from the most original gameplay I have seen and it's just a boring walk/wj to reach the second hole if you missed the upcj.
@7968080 - Zeus#6550 - J'aime bien certains shortcuts dans ta map et j'ai voulu voir ce que ca donnait en salon mais je pense qu'il y a encore des choses qui doivent être modifiés et la carte n'est pas prête pour être perm à l'heure actuelle. Le premier shortcut en utilisant le trampoline pour atteindre le chocolat juste au dessus me semble trop facile et ruine un peu le reste de la carte car dès que les gens comprennent qu'ils peuvent faire ça, personne n'utilise la partie gauche, donc ca manque un peu d'équilibre entre les chemins (trop facile et/ou trop court). Des gens sont aussi tombés avec le fromage en bas a droite et ils n'ont pas pu sortir, c'est donc aussi quelque chose qu'il faut modifié. Il y a du potentiel mais essaye d'équilibrer un peu mieux les chemins au début.

P1'ed:
@7969976 - Bautipro#5357 - The concept of the map isn't bad but it feels overused and repetitive after playing it a few times. It is basically the same obstacle all over the map but with different places and angles. I'm gonna put it P1 because it isn't a bad map but I couldn't see this p17.
@5094003 - Brenow#4577 - I can see the shortcuts and the way we can skip the bottom part to walljump the chocolate and reach the hole but I think the map is too boring for racing.
@7971947 - Rioxmaps#3702 - Layout is really cool but the gameplay is too simple so i'm gonna go for P1.

Will be discussed:
@7970012 - Danielmago#5918 - Very cool shortcuts (maybe too much on the first lava though), I'm not sure if it is challenging enough for racing because some parts feels a bit automatic but i'm going to give it a chance.
@7778787 - Omgjrn#0000 - The way you placed the galaxy grounds is really fun and enjoyable but I feel like the map around the galaxies could have been better than the way it is right now. Putting it in discussion to see what the team think about it.

Ignored:
@7944422 - Katwyn#1614 - Blacklisted until nov 8, 2025.
@7944420 - Katwyn#1614 - Blacklisted until nov 8, 2025.

#14106

@7968080 - Edited
@7969147 - Edited (from the previous review)

Dernière modification le

#14107

@7966039
@7961016

#14108

@7959663

#14109

@7944420
@7944422

Dernière modification le

#14110

@7972692

Dernière modification le

#14111

@7778778

#14112

@5520848
@7300667

Dernière modification le

#14113

@7970369
@7970059

#14114

@7968713

#14115

@7771777
@7885884

#14116

@7973337

#14117

@7969979

#14118

deleted

#14119

Left as is:
Zeus#6550 - @7969147 - Je rencontre toujours les mêmes problèmes malgré les edits: tout ce qui est après le fromage n'est pas très intéressant et c'est même un peu confus de savoir ou passer car il y a trop de chemins (dont un qui est très très basique ou tu peux juste marcher vers la droite). Il arrive également souvent que ma vitesse soit arreté lorsque j'utilise le tout premier galaxy après le trampoline (et donc je tombe dans le vide).
Dinahmiite#0000 - @7966039 - The obstacle right before the cheese with the water/lava/trampoline is pretty fun and works well but appart from that I don't see anything very interesting that could make it to racing.
Dinahmiite#0000 - @7961016 - Same as the previous map, I like one of the obstacle which is the lava part to reach the cheese, it's decent but the rest is pretty basic and very linear.
Danielmago#5918 - @7959663 - You can just take the cheese from the spawn which make all the middle part of the map useless, it's a shortcut but it's way too easy to make it. I feel like there is some good ideas on the left but everything before is a bit messy and confusing.
Blackcrebet#0000 - @7972692 - Too generic and very punitive if you miss that cornerjump near the cheese. Also some transitions in the map are either boring (first wj for example) or a little too complicated (transition from right to left in the middle).
Brenow#4577 - @5520848 - Most of the map is generic and boring, also it feels very natural to try reaching the hole right after getting the cheese so most of the people will just try it and die because there is nothing to save them after missing the hole.
Brenow#4577 - @7300667 - There is already another version of this map in the rotation.
Jim#3189 - @7970369 - Even if you're using a new ground, it's actually just a single basic cornerjump and the galaxy could have been just lavas with 9999 restitution to teleport you from the bottom to the top so the galaxy grounds doesn't bring anything there.
Jim#3189 - @7970059 - The top left is useless because it's longer to use that water+trampoline than just going directly to the right. The cheese part is decent and could work even if i wish it would be a bit more dynamic because the wood just stop your speed and you still need to wj after. The comeback from the cheese feels very weird, you almost never have enough speed to use the big 45° ice on the bottom left so you have to walljump on the galaxy which just break the dynamism of the map again and is quite annoying to do.
Danielmago#5918 - @7968713 - The first chain with the shortcut by slowing down to reach the chocolate is cool and I think you could keep that but that second part in the middle feels very unintuitive: You get speed from the water so you think you have to keep going left but actually no you have to go right and you get very suprised by that. The top part is decent but nothing amazing and would fit more P1. I'd like to see another version with the same start but something different after.
Jasseh#0000 - @7885884 - I get what you wanted to do but there is too much walks from right to left and left to right which makes it long for a poor gameplay. The shortcuts are a bit generic (on the top) or a bit luck-based (upcj on the chocolate with the lava at the spawn).
Ryder#3319 - @7973337 - Decent gameplay but too generic, also I don't like the fact that we don't see there is a ground under the cheese because when you play it for the first time you don't know that you can use that trampoline in the bottom mid.
Bautipro#5357 - @7969979 - Doesn't really fit with racing in my opinion and would fit more the normal rooms but I also think there is many maps like that one already in the rotation so it's not very original.

P1'ed:
Zeus#6550 - @7968080 - J'aimais bien certains shortcuts mais au final les chemins ne sont pas du tout équilibrés (et donc certains deviennent quasiment inutile) et je ne vois pas comment tu pourrais corriger ça donc je vais la mettre P1 car je ne vois pas trop d'edit possible pour l'améliorer suffisament.
Omgjrn#0000 - @7778778 - There is some fun ways to complete the map but it's overall too messy because there is so many ways, when you play the map for the first time you really don't know what lava you should use and where you should go so I don't see this being more than P1.

Will be discussed:
Jasseh#0000 - @7771777 - Very cool shortcuts

Ignored:
@7944420 - Katwyn#1614 - Blacklisted until nov 8, 2025.
@7944422 - Katwyn#1614 - Blacklisted until nov 8, 2025.

#14120

@7944420
@7944422

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue