Rotation Officielle - P18

Rotation Officielle - P18 - Défilante

#1581

@4553960

#1582

@4559158

#1583

[Modéré par Katburger, raison : Spam]

#1584

@4569168

#1585

[Modéré par Vulli]

#1586

After nearly 2 months without a review, I've gone through this thread and reviewing all maps up until this point.

Left as is<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
@3653382 Mousegodmind For the most part, the two paths seem to not give enough of an
advantage to make a player want to take a certain one.
@3999417 Fluffyshine Map can be uninteresting and too easy for the most part, the
paths can be broken up by parts like
this, where it's
almost too difficult to get across, forcing everyone the same
way.
@2050937 Arthurgol The cheese doesn't need to be covering the hole, there's only
one path for the majority of the map, and the dynamic earth can
be too hard to get past.
@3634186 Kittyasd Most of the map's gameplay is uninteresting, and the tougher
path isn't rewarding enough for most players to want to go that
way.
@3849609 Kittyasd A nice map and interesting concept, but the springs launching
you in different directions can confuse players and leave them
stuck.
@4198057 Felipedtx There are some fake grounds, some tokens and grounds are
misaligned or not aligned consistently, and some parts such as
the far right are wasted.
@3618330 Minstens Map's design is odd and inconsistent, no collision on the lava is
confusing, very little difficulty and the paths don't vary much.
@3661996 Bowlt Only one path and getting some of the +1 tokens isn't that
rewarding.
@4381162 Mrkurt Inconsistent design and collision.
@4381647 Gulimon Mice can get offscreen easily, alignment is poor in places,
gameplay is more tedious than fun at points.
@4391440 Lehelms Hard to tell what some tokens are
at points, leading to
a lot of death. In general the gameplay is interesting and paths
vary, making it very interesting.
@4392312 Mtorrent Poor alignment, a lot of the paths don't differ that much.
@3926164 Malaroos Some of the gameplay is fun and interesting, but most of it is
generic and the only varying paths are a short bit in the middle,
which don't have varying difficulty.
@3742939 Chailonrs The minimalist styling should be left for minimalist mode. The
paths can be interesting to play but aren't particularly difficult or
differing.
@4385033 Cndalr The paths don't have anything to entice players to go in a
particular direction, generic gameplay.
@4406080 Tokesdavid Not a defilante map.
@4419594 Fofonams The majority of the map is just one path.
@4204093 Fofonams Just one path.
@4425456 Enzoo Majority of the map is unused, and most is one path with bad
alignment, the split paths aren't of varying difficulty.
@4452186 Jsilv The split paths aren't interesting or long, and gameplay is
overall generic.
@4482997 Cndalr Several decorations are unaligned, The paths and gameplay
don't vary that much, and aren't rewarding enough.
@4483758 Vanovandro A lot of unaligned tokens and some even hidden/offscreen,
mostly linear gameplay with generic gameplay.
@4493176 Xxveirocksxx Linear gameplay, lava causes shortcuts, hidden trampoline.
@4503828 Xcarlosxxxxd Single path with generic gameplay.
@4498102 Sekui If this is intended to be a soulmate map, it ruins the gameplay a
lot, especially with the extremely fast speed the map scrolls at.
Gameplay is generic apart from the speed. Hidden hole.
@4509584 Noblekid Collision is odd, the first 2 holes are useless, there are some
alignment issues, gameplay is mainly linear, backgrounds don't
look too great as decorations as they are.
@4514386 Noblekid While the different paths can be interesting, the majority of the
map seems like randomly placed grounds and tokens, leading
for inconsistent and not fluid gameplay.
@4511870 Hombregirl Unaligned and token spam.
@4516544 Hombregirl Unaligned and token spam.
@4525097 Rullexxx Hidden hole, backgrounds don't fit in, unaligned at places,
Ca="" would make it more playable on fullscreen, mainly a
single path and short gameplay.
@4040910 Tdft This is a nice map but the ending is a little disappointing, the
instant death when the skeleton appears is nothing but tedious
and annoying, the fire floating with a cut off graphic, and the
pile of cheese are all things which slightly cheapen the map.
@4542621 Xxveirocksxx Bad alignment, token spam, offscreen cheese, hidden death
token, one path. This map breaks a lot of P1 and P18 guidelines.
@4193196 Daniielxdpro One path, almost too fast, inconsistently aligned and placed
tokens.
@4553960 Douglaswilam Poorly aligned grounds and tokens, top hole is useless (mice
would just fall to the lower one), token spam.
@4559158 Hasannj Poorly aligned tokens and decorations, single path through most
of the map, generic gameplay.
@4569168 Sebanobpro Poorly aligned, token spam, so many speed tokens are useless
without free scroll or faster scroll speed.
</textformat>

Will be discussed<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
@3854826 Felipedtx Challenging and the alternate paths are rewarding.
@4338517 Guidellk The majority of the map only has one path, but the places to get
the extra tokens make it a lot more interesting.
@3917824 Tdft
</textformat>

Ignored:<textformat tabstops='[80,180]'>
</textformat>

#1587

Shamousey a dit :

@4391440 Lehelms Hard to tell what some tokens are
at points, leading to
a lot of death. In general the gameplay is interesting and paths
vary, making it very interesting.

@4391440 Edited ^^

#1588

@4548058

#1589

[Modéré par Bolinboy]

#1590

@4040910 - Edited
@4688500 .

#1591

@4548058

#1592

@4588333
@3605625 .

#1593

@4525645

#1594

@4589918 ~ ♪

#1595

@3133081

#1596

@4215617 @4215263

#1597

@4612473

Srry if there too much points XD

It was my first defilante map ive ever made :p

#1598

[Modéré par Takumisyn, raison : Spam]

#1599

@4618541

#1600

@4642596

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue