Rotation Officielle - P4

#180

Left as is:
@5172846 - Thegoldmice - Generic and build-a-thon
@5032210 - Augustinas - I think many people will take a while to understand that the ice grounds don't collide with objects, despite the plank. Aside from that I feel like this concept is overused and this doesn't introduce anything new which would justify discussing it.
@5100234 - Adikey - Generic building with a cloud ground in the middle which makes the building annoying/awkward too
@5149471 - Quesoyquesos - Almost no bulding required
@4587748 - Helosx - No
@5101434 - Viniciusdara - Generic building, water doesn't add much but makes building at cheese and hole awkward and cramped
@4596040 - Nickpriosy - Not a shaman map
@5168702 - Wesesw - One long build-a-thon with a cloud ground placed randomly with its only purpose being a filler concept. I would suggest avoiding putting cloud grounds like that unless the concept centres/focuses on them. Otherwise they tend to be annoying and making building awkward
@5156373 - Bravefriends - Generic
@5154221 - Hyouraan - Nothing new/innovative or fun about this
@5096881 - Eliaspdc - Wind and death tokens makes this really awkward and annoying to build on but without them it's a plain generic shaman map.
@5114598 - Siilverpack - Interesting idea in theory but in practice this turns into box/plank spam; really repetitive and unenjoyable
@5172999 - Antcristi - Not a shaman map
@5033641 - Gobbek - Easily soloable/minimal to no building, not much of a shaman map at all
@5177869 - Scantec - Similar to that other Tzette P4 but with lava, which is different but makes this annoying to sham on and it's very easy for mice to hit the lava and then destroy a sham's build
@5184491 - Geovanezikka - Generic
@5172766 - Nprata - Way too hard for public - most people fail to grasp the negative gravity concept, and even those that do fail to sham on it correctly. I would suggest avoiding the use of it in most shaman maps
@4561449 - Fluffypuffeh - One long tedious build-a-thon with wind added on to make it more interesting but just makes it annoying. However, I do like the right side of the map where you have to build to up and to catch the mice after they jump and get cheese
@5170645 - Lastcookiez - Generic
@5118935 - Gunalp - Generic/cramped building
@5179094 - Kralat - Random and not a proper shaman map
@5177986 - Luckerfalse - Unoriginal
@5019549 - Wicax - Generic and the cloud ground just makes this awkward to build on
@5180334 - Soname - Generic
@5180404 - Tinittee - I feel like the dynamic wood ground doesn't fit in with the rest of the map and that most shams will struggle in moving in it or will just avoid it completely by teleporting through theice. Either way, the build still remains generic or monosolution, as well as long and tedious
@5178692 - Mrkurt - Once you've removed the dynamic ice blocks there's almost nothing to the map and definitely nothing original or fun. Also, the left one feels mostly pointless since it's so easy to remove and a large portion of the map is empty and unused. However, I generally find maps where you have to move ice like this quite enjoyable so I would suggest executing this concept in another way to make it more original and the ice more related to the gameplay.
@5181396 - Faakedomitow - Feels like the opposite of Muffun's map but far more awkward to build on. A lot of shams will be confused by the circle grounds and will just try and build through it t but then mess up their build. I just don'tsee this working out well in public and despite having the circle grounds and using a different concept, the build remains the same
@5181559 - Xsfh - Generic
@5181509 - Pulpit - Random grounds everywhere, nothing at all consistent and build remains generic but awkward to due to the cloud ground
@5179292 - Hotspotower - Extremely cramped at the bottom, nothing original and once you spawn a single plank mice can you wj up so minimal building too
@5182086 - Joseventus - Generic shaman map with high gravity add to try and make it different but in practice makes this annoying to build on and quite a few shams will struggle with it
@4992768 - Mmmmaikon - Generic portal spam map
@5129219 - Scoobddum - Not a shaman map
@5167154 - Vilns - Not a shaman map
@5175737 - Artistimulen - Not a proper shaman map/minimal building required
@4727636 - Sebsssssssss - Random gameplay that doesn't go well together - most shams won't realise there is cheese athte boxes so they'll try and build under the plank but fail because it's so cramped. Also, the cloud ground towards the hole doesn't havemuch use besides making this more awkward to sham on. Overall this feels very random and doesn't work well together
@4644331 - Papelio - Not a proper shaman map
@5097403 - Lightningzto - Minimal building, quite easily soloable so shams role here is extremely limited and even unnecessary
@5184086 - Regeletran - Not a shaman map
@5147628 - Fkrthebest - Extremely awkward and hard to build on, no one will be able to complete this. I would suggest avoiding antigravity unless it's a very simple use of it
@5175986 - Groltz - Generic
@5095422 - Icheesebr - Not a shaman map
@5140695 - Enginfener - Mostly generic shaman mapwith a cloud ground added on to add more of a challenge but just makes this more annoying to sham on.
@5184728 - Jeanblay - Generic
@4021986 - Raincrowme - Unoriginal and a bit cramped
@5135009 - Guyfawkers - Awkward, cramped and annoying to sham on. Once you've built to cheese there's almost nothing left to do
@3523840 - Pageedoown - Not a shaman map
@5183136 - Amabei - Not a shaman map and mass death
@5191132 - Caaioceesar - Unoriginal + build-a-thon
@5182858 - Potmap - Planks don't add much to the gameplay and the map is still generic
@4951268 - Hiisaan - Minimal building, poor alignment and not very innovative
@5161404 - Waidio - I don't see many shams figuring out what to do and messing up the map. I find the sides to be very cramped so it's difficult to save the mice and then remove the ice. Also, a lot of the map is very cramped which makes building awkward and this type of concept has become very overused. Overall not the worst map I've seen but not the best one either.
@5188080 - Gabrielcsq - Generic
@5148047 - Sutaux - Generic
@5188393 - Pjlqueijoo - Generic
@4132847 - Elhectordm - Generic, tedious and monosolution
@5147521 - Sekui - This is just annoying, confusing and easy to mess up. No one will understand this
@5133032 - Djschelle - Generic
@5188446 - Sarkazm - Decent map but there isn't enough to distinguish this from othe rmaps. There are lot maps like this which require the same building and this one just isn't different enough. Also, I feel like the leftmost part won't be used and that it would be better if sham spawns above cheese, not with mice.
@4181484 - Cemoscuk - Different idea but not very well executed and there are fake grounds everywhere. I would suggest reusing this concept in a different map in a different way. Right now it seems like most shams will just spam boxes to get the mice to cheese
@5130436 - Txma - Not a shaman map
@5191207 - Reganjsg - A lot of the map is useless, cloud grounds just makes this awkward to sham on and get in the way of building. No one would enjoy shamming this

P1'ed:
@5165203 - Tuliomumic - I don't think the water adds much to the map considering how it isn't very wide and easy to build through. Also, this isn't very innovative or original and the build remains a bridge + ramp no matter the path you choose, just a steeper ramp or longer bridge. Fine for P1 but I don't think there's enough to distinguish this from plenty of other maps out there.

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
@5173520 - Extremoko - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5101167 - Extremoko - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5173865 - Extremoko - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5180348 - Extremoko - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5174457 - Kenanskd - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5173609 - Kenanskd - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5126574 - Jorginhonune - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5166685 - Jorginhonune - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5137815 - Ochey - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5138035 - Ochey - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5135833 - Dprocik - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@504714 - Dprocik - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5102610 - Commupro - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5094883 - Commupro - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@1730545 - Ratassobr - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5189517 - Ratassobr - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@2991689 - Lucasdoavai - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@2988998 - Lucasdoavai - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@5239956 - Vivanananana - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)
@4942685 - Vivanananana - Posted more than 1 maps (same post)

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue