Thekeving: @6748853 - The design isn’t appropriate and the cage needs a lot more work since it feels very closed and the shaman can’t move properly inside it. Also there is no concept nor objective, it is just a bland antigravity map like any other.

Plubio: @6708917 - The mechanism makes the cloud grounds move weird where one stops and the other doesn’t. The mechanism concept also makes you feel bad because you fail whenever it breaks - even if you do a complete build that should solve the map. Additionally, the concept may rely on the skills of mice too much.

Uelintondd: @6758794 - It’s fine that the shaman is free to do different v swings, but the grounds seem randomly placed. That doesn’t make the map very enjoyable and the cramped path to hole is more frustrating than interesting since the shaman can hardly fix it if there is any mistake.

Wextoof: @6765367 - There is another map in rotation (@3615011) that shows the same concept in a better way.

Gekkeiju: @6775910 - This map is challenging and very interesting but the way it’s exactly designed can be confusing for players because of the red IF grounds. We encourage the mapmaker to resubmit this map once the design gets a positive overhaul.

Attomake: @6780800 - Solutions are hard to make in this map, making it way more frustrating than interesting.

Attomake: @6779350 - The concept is nothing we have seen before but in the end, it’s just a simple map trying to be difficult with forced challenges. This map could be better by zeroing in on a certain concept or by even enhancing the challenge itself in a way that doesn’t make it frustrating to build.

Attomake: @6770449 - This concept could be fun as an introduction to caged antigrav maps, but it doesn’t feel like the gameplay is balanced since very few solutions would be easier than everything else you could possibly do.

Anthonyjones: @6778127 - It is nice that this map introduces a concept where you need to make a build after your first one disappears, but the act of building on the map itself doesn’t feel very meaningful - it is too bland and it makes the progression on it feel too linear.

Anthonyjones: @6778435 - It feels like the randomly placed grounds everywhere make some parts of the map too cramped to build on. This concept could work with a massive improvement to the design, but right now this is hardly enjoyable.

Anthonyjones: @6793400 - This map feels too cramped to be enjoyable. It would also help if the design of the map supported no-b building more.

Jhowzera: @270791 - This map is too symmetrical to allow for much variation in building. However, this will be discussed again next review.

Tioyudis: @6794624 - This map’s concept is fine, but it doesn’t feel complete enough for spiritual. It could use improvements to make it more fun for players.

Arnees: @6396974 - This concept seems interesting, but it's too cramped to be suitable for rotation.

Anthonyjones: @6773514 - The mechanism isn't as clear as it could be, and the map isn't really impressive anyway.

Tioyudis: @6783995 - Some grounds in this map seem to have no purpose due to their placement in the design. It would also help if the map was less confusing judging by the use of rectangle grounds.

Tioyudis: @6785706 - The anticloud grounds are useless and the design of the map makes the gameplay unbalanced since it’s much easier to not build down in the beginning.

Fuzzyfirsdog: @6795956 - Mice can cornerjump to the hole which is against the rule of not allowing mice to solo parts of the map.

Arnees: @6796504 - The concept of this map could work, but unfortunately the right design was not found to satisfy the map's addition to rotation.

Arnees: @6798402 - Although both paths are balanced in terms of difficulty and speed, parts of the map could still use more work. For example, building for hole seems monosolution and the spacing used above the middle ground is not used

Hybinkunduz: @6044443 - The whole top right part of the map goes unused as there is no reason for the shaman to build there since it takes longer and the use of cloud grounds do not balance it out enough.

Hybinkunduz: @6058383 - Main challenge behind the map is building down towards cheese, which is something seen in many spiritual maps already. The difference in build solutions aren’t adequate enough for it to be considered for rotation.

Hybinkunduz: @6699973 - Map has hardmode slots which aren’t necessary since shamans can spawn b planks, so they only serve to incentivize the shaman into building the same way every time. Also the cloud grounds aren’t positioned in a way where they are a reasonable challenge for the shaman.

Kimsterjay: @6792868 - Portals used in this design makes for a meaningless concept.

Matheusferei: @6811616 - Not only this tries to make a concept that has already been done much better in another map, but the design here is way too flawed to be fixed - so consider a different approach. Also, there are unclear grounds present on this map, so be careful which grounds you make an anticloud.

Uhuge: @6700373 - The map is not properly balanced and it has some useless grounds on it. We recommend the mapmaker to make a larger update on the design and to improve the gameplay balancing in general. We look forward to a resubmission of this.

Uhuge: @5562153 - An interesting and unique concept of having sliding apples however the mice spawn is positioned poorly since mice can easily be knocked off the ledge. The gameplay is still enjoyable but since there is only a single anticloud ground on the map, it’s not enough to accept this map with its lack of obstacles. However, we encourage the mapmaker to resubmit an improved version of this since this concept has potential.

Uhuge: @6804450 - This map is frustrating to build on because the shaman cage is so closed - it doesn’t fit well with the no-b concept. The concept itself with the design isn’t bad, but just the shaman cage needs more work.

Dukeonkled: @6810730 - The concept intended on this map is enjoyable, but it is too unclear for anyone who shams this and they will just end up using a build that has been used many times in spiritual already. We’re not sure how to improve this map, but it has potential to do well in a future review.

Anthonyjones: @6379460 - This map’s concept is clear enough and it has potential to be an enjoyable thing to have in rotation, but it isn’t perfected. The design of the map doesn’t quite fit the concept, and a better use should be looked into for the dynamic grounds since some parts of the map go unused; but with an improvement to the design we’ll be happy to add this to the next review.

Anthonyjones: @6210745 - The stability concept with the skull tokens makes this a fun map, but the design could be much better. For one, it is too linear and this could end up being repetitive. If you had multiple options in building and had more space in the middle of the map, I think this would make for a good concept. For now it needs work, but we welcome an improvement of this in next review.

Anthonyjones: @6813022 - This map isn’t bad, but it’s not very exciting to sham on - it’s pretty much a caged build-a-thon. Also, there is no need for a timer that releases mice; just give them a normal spawn ground.

Bigzzz: @6202210 - The concept of the map could work out fine, but the shaman cage is incompatible with it since it’s small and it looks weird with the rest of the map. The design could use some work, so right now this isn’t ready for rotation.

Plubio: @6503534 - Having to fit your build through such a tight space makes for a frustrating experience than an enjoyable one even if the concept and design are interesting. There aren’t exactly many ways to solve this map anyway, so it can’t be accepted right now.

Marilulss: @6822220 - The map lacks a proper concept and seems to simply have an assortment of different features to make it unique however it only results in it being a frustrating map to play. The design has potential to appear better, but right now it looks weird.

Piionze: @6825437 - This map has already been edited completely to try and improve its previous design, but it has failed in that. Since the original map was in review first, we’ll be talking about that - its concept was pretty interesting to play on since you had different options in building, but the antigravity and configuration of the grounds also made it kinda frustrating to solve the map too.

Piionze: @6779355 - Unfortunately the concept of having the shaman use the grounds in the corner to form a build is unlikely to happen and the map will just turn out to be a repetitive balloon-anvil ship map for most people.

Piionze: @6680211 - It can be frustrating for the shaman since he has to form a dynamic solution or a v swing while making sure to form a passage through the narrow gap near the hole. The map isn’t bad but it’s not quite exciting enough to be added anyway.

Piionze: @6418197 - Although it’s an enjoyable wind map, there is a huge lacking in the amount of solutions possible due to the layout of the map. If it were possible to make distinctly different builds but while keeping the same fun concept, then this would be great. Though, a sizeable improvement to the map is needed for that.

Attomake: @6789948 - There is hardly any room for the shaman to spawn objects from just a single apple. Either the design of the map needs to be compensated for the small spawn range, or there should be more added options in how and where you can spawn.

Attomake: @6832655 - Concept is too similar to @3761224 and the right side wall should be redesigned to allow the shaman to force the cloud across with planks.

Attomake: @6834507 - Concept of the map is clear and fairly unique however the design of the map doesn’t encourage the shaman to solve it in many different ways.

Arnees: @6837470 - There are many different solutions to the map which is nice however there are too many parts to the map that it becomes overbearing for shamans to try to solve within two minutes.

Arnees: @6817258 - A good attempt at trying to utilize the entire map by forming separate parts the shaman must complete. However, it feels like there is less innovation potential in the right portion of the map when compared to the left.

Sourisgogo: @6845686 - Hardly any room for the shaman to build since they’re almost offscreen, and this results in an unfair advantage to those that can see offscreen as they’ll be able to work with more space. The map doesn’t present anything beyond the common cage concept.

Jhowzera: @6790753 - A large majority of the map is effectively completed by spawning angled b planks and spamming boxes instead of forming connected builds. This is not necessarily a bad map, but it’s not fun to sham on either.

Anthonyjones: @6832397 - The symmetrical design only results in the shaman having to repeat the build again and ends up being quite the build-a-thon.