Rotation Officielle - P8

#3082

The reviews are not completly finished yet, I'll finish them by the end of the week. However if you want a more detailed review (I kept them quite short), feel free to send me a PM on the forum.

Left as is:
@7279391 - Ahyenn - Too cramped, too many death tokens, and the layout is not particularly interesting.
@7243868 - Commandantso - On a déjà pas mal de cartes beaucoup plus intéréssants avec des caisses (d'ailleurs je me demande si on n'en a pas une pareil), du coup c'est pas très intéréssant et la construction est ultra générique.
@7299700 - Commandantso - Pareil ici, la symétrie ne rend pas la carte particulièrement intéréssante, c'est trop générique et certains passages sont un peu étroits... Enfin ca encourage pas vraiment la créativité quoi.
@1711714 - Tenoteno - The layout is pretty basic, so fine as P1'ed.
@7279272 - Tucancitto - The layout is also pretty classic here, and I'm kinda bothered byt the cloud. I totally get its point but I think most shamans will struggle to build correctly with it blocking the way (I thinking divine mode mostly) and the whole map is a bit tricky to build on.
@7321214 - Eyux - I don't know if the map's broken or if it supposed to work like that but fot now when I'm pushing the button the other blue ground is disapearing definitly so even when I'm not pushing the button anymore the blue ground doesn't come back. If it's normal the concept is not interesting.
@7291444 - Gamog - The grounds all seem pretty random. There're many things going on in here but I can't feel a real unity in the map. The cloud and the water are pretty useless.
@6415227 - V_Ntage - Meh the map is not really interesting, mostly bridges and ramp, the huge cloud makes thing easier but especially a lot more boring either.
@7288084 - V_Ntage - We already have tons of button-push maps and this one is not particularly outstanding, once again it's mostly brides and ramps.
@7236946 - Chocosuiss - Still the wrong cat. If you could read the basic guidelines before posting it would be great, thanks.
@7285302 - Desayuname - Not a shaman map.
@7285320 - Desayuname - Too many things that don't make sense, not aesthetic, it just seems so random.
@7295587 - Brenoouuw - The map is ok but to be honest it looks like some maps we arleady have so it won't bring anything new.
@7309779 - Brenoouuw - Same as above.
@4394928 - Zombiewd - The map looks ok but still looks like dozens of maps we already have in rotation. I mean honeslty it's a fine map but just won't bring anything.
@7289755 - Viaxeiro - Juste pas intéréssants. La carte peut être complétées avec 4 portails, le scroll ne sert a rien et les différents spawns non plus.
@7310244 - Uelintondd - The map is ok but once again the concept has been overused and here I feel like the shaman only has to teleport himself and it doesn't have much interest. The building could be fine but too linear in my opinion.
@6570684 - Bataatiinha - I a death tokens lover but I know most shamans will struggle and many mice will die stupidly which is frustrating for both mice and shamans.This is too cramped to be a success.
@7306727 - Trowwn - Random and definitly not aesthetic enough. We can barely see the clouds.
@7277699 - Sirakaba - The map actually looks interesting but the huge cloud in the middle kills everything. This is too annoying and makes the map too cramped.
@7277701 - Sirakaba - The map is too basic/linear and the ice blocks are pretty useless. It just doesn't encourage creativity.
@5005056 - Gobbek - I like it but it'll be a disaster in public with all those death tokens.
@5888885 - Tomaaasxddd -
@7309029 - Anthonyxc - Not suitable for cooperation. There's almost nothing to do here.
@7309058 - Anthonyxc - The clouds are too numerous, they're making the map cramped and annoying to build on.
@4034650 - Aznboiii - Too cramped and linear to be enjoyable.
@4041844 - Aznboiii - I kinda like it but it's too linear, it's quite cramped and I know we have a very similar map already permed.
@6895963 - Sekui - It worked pretty well in public but shamans struggle to build near the hole cause of the cloud. Besides it would be great if the speed could be x1.25. And maybe you should edit the flashy pink color. But the concept is really nice and I do think this map has potential to be permed.
@7024574 - Sekui - The concept is interesting but most players don't like wind and death tokens so the two together... Most will just struggle. And the color is a bit weird.
@7309697 - Mapadded - Those grounds are confusing because they look just like the ones which are non colliable with objects. So it'll be confusing to practiced players. And the map overall is too linear/generic.
@7311564 - Mapadded - My first thought was "It looks just like a soulmate map" but whatever... The layout is nice but it won't bring anything new either, it's too plain.
@7309811 - Pjfsamora - Some decoration elements seem to be a bit out of place but nevermind. The map looks just like many others and won't bring anyhing new either.
@7309821 - Pjfsamora - The "big clouds" concept is a bit overused now in my opinion especially since most mice still struggle harshly with it. The map is nice but still think it looks too common.
@7004822 - Trackswagy - It's too minimalist to be seen as interesting, the construction will be annoying to do and at the end it will mostly be bridges and ramps.
@7093595 - Trackswagy - No those clouds are making this map so annoying, especially the one next to the cheese. Too many players will struggle.
@6117863 - Jotatavo - Too minimalist, I'm pretty we already have a map which looks like this. Cooperation isn't even needed here.
@6009797 - Jotatavo - Feel like it's too generic and once again won't bring anything new/interesting.
@7050147 - V_21 - Pretty generic and will be a pain to build on considering the layout.
@7038637 - V_21 - I'm pretty sure a version of this map is already permed.
@7121270 - Yuugiooohhhh - No please no, no big clouds everywhere.
@7054637 - Yuugiooohhhh - I like it but the invisible rectangle on top is useless and weird. You could put it a wall if you want to avoid mice falling to the cheese, but for now it's just odd.
@7317808 - Jjrules - The different use of grounds seem pretty random, and the map is too linear to be interesting.
@6367739 - Framnm - The layout looks fine but each time it'll be a bridge and a ramp.
@7323240 - Mrorko - They're two shamans here so in 90% of the case at least one of them will teleporte and the concept doesn't work anymore. Plus the aesthetic of the map is really weird.
@7324194 - Fortfix - Not a shaman map, and there're way too much useless clouds.
@7328986 - Kbrasska - The layout seems nice but it's a bit too cramped to be enjoyable to build on.
@7071653 - Mrorko - In my opninion the map is too cramped and too linear to be interesting.
@5918333 - Curinfake - The map will most likely be messed up by the cooperation, and the this concept has already been used a lot.
@5980130 - Vlump - It just seems too plain, the cloud and the ice block seem random and overall the map is not really fun to build on.

@7262061 - Tucancitto - I truly liked the map and it played ok in public BUT almost all mice died because of the unsafe spawn area. Mice killed each others with consummables or just with bubbles exploding.
@6545017 - Uelintondd - I like the concept but I guess the execution isn't that good. I did (many) tests and none was convincing. During most of the tests shamans tried to complete the map with springs/baloons only.

P1'ed
@7291830 - Ahyenn - Not outstanding but quite ok for a map involvind death tokens.

P8'ed:
@7111177 - Eyux - I wasn't really sure about it but I tested it and I was really surprised by how well it went.
@6418571 - Framnm - Kinda weird but extremly fun when you understand how it works.
@5888855 - Gobbek - Really liked it.
@7300008 - Zombiewd - I'm not sure whether the water is adding something or not but the map is nice.
@1404911 - Tenoteno - Ok.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue