Numlk#8907: @7693066 - This map is fairly enjoyable and is not at all frustrating, but the concept it offers is not new and the gameplay seems pretty repetitive.

Numlk#8907: @7694443 - The map is enjoyable and is quite unique/challenging. However, solutions where you attach a big plank to the dynamic ice are too overpowered. We recommend editing the map to counterbalance this.

Numlk#8907: @7696856 - The concept on this map is decent, but it’s outperformed by an existing map in rotation: @6168632. Furthermore, this map’s lava ground aesthetic is not very pleasing to the eye and should be switched out.

Elmattjuan#0000: @7718785 - The concept on this map is fine, but it has a fatal flaw in its design. Since the layout is symmetrical, that leaves the left side of the map with gameplay that is very bland and uninspired, especially compared to the right side.

Urook#1131: @7720749 - Even with a vertical scrolling environment, this map doesn’t offer any new content for #spiritual since it’s just about creating large v swings. There may be room for innovation but the map’s gameplay isn’t really that unique.

Urook#1131: @7726301 - The gameplay on this map is enjoyable, but its concept hardly offers anything new. We have enough of swing-building and basic build-stabilization maps in rotation already.

Kimiko#7954: @7726704 - In addition to having gameplay that is rather boring and unoriginal, this map is actually impossible to solve within the allotted time.

Commandantso#0000: @7707354 - This map’s gameplay is too generic to entertain, and its design does not feel like one that you would see in #spiritual.

Bhvana#0543: @7724933 - The gameplay for this map is balanced and enjoyable, but the concept is already repeated in rotation several times. This map has nothing new to offer us.

Bhvana#0543: @7734091 - Portals on this map do not contribute to fulfilling a unique concept. Too generic.

Dukeonkled#0000: @6284206 - This map has a good aesthetic, but it limits the types of potential solutions. Since this map mostly forces the shaman to create monorail-type solutions, it would make the gameplay become repetitive and uninteresting after a while.

Bhvana#0543: @7730414 - The spinning b plank on this map is not strong enough to pose a threat, thus undermining the concept. Because of this, and due to the fact that the space under the b plank is large enough, mice can easily walk underneath the spinning plank. Even ignoring these points, this concept hardly has anything new or original to offer spiritual.

Viniciusdara#0000: @5665390 - The trampolines on this map actually make it annoying for the mice and shaman, as you have to constantly redirect your movements since you can’t stop bouncing. Also, the gameplay isn’t balanced since there is only one best path to take when building to the objectives. Besides that, the building process on this map is a bit generic but nothing bad.

Bhvana#0543: @7421594 - This map’s design is too similar to the designs of some existing maps in rotation, such as: vanilla map 90, @185570, @225254, etc.

Misterpepper#0000: @2862161 - The no-b mechanism on this map is currently broken. This should get fixed prior to submission.

Bhvana#0543: @7747844 - Although this map can be useful as a learning environment for new players learning water mechanics, the concept has nothing new to offer and is seen as rather bland. Furthermore, an existing map in rotation already executes this gameplay in a better way: @481056.

Dukeonkled#0000: @7763456 - The gameplay for this map consists of long bridge building, which isn’t really interesting to build. Building on a scrolling map can also be annoying for shamans.

Bhvana#0543: @7763288 - This map hardly has a good concept for portals, but that aspect is forgivable. The real reason this map is pre-rejected for next review is because the map design is unaligned, ugly, contains fake grounds, and has useless connected planks at the top of the map since B is allowed anyway. Overall, this map will only lead to a lot of player confusion. To the mapmaker: please improve this map to the best of your ability before re-submitting it.

Bhvana#0543: @7774966 - The layout for this map is rather messy as it contains useless cloud grounds - which can also lead to a lot of player confusion. The grounds have no proper alignment, giving the map design a poor structure. If you are going to create a no-b map with a no anchor cloud, ensure that the mechanism works first before you submit the map.

Yinjackson#0000: @7769829 - The concept for this map is interesting and rather unique, but the design does not allow for enough solution variety. Removing the b planks would vastly improve solution variety for this map. We encourage Yinjackson to resubmit this map with that change.

Lilith#0123: @7738086 - This map actually can be challenging and entertaining when it comes to building up/down with cheese in water. However, the water is a bit excessive and it wouldn’t hurt to either lower the water level or reduce the map length. One other possible suggestion is to remove the symmetry on the map and create a new, more interesting challenge to replace what was erased. We encourage the mapmaker to resubmit this map with any enhancements - especially those that increase solution diversity.

Dukeonkled#0000: @7775032 - The concept for this map is interesting, but the design limits solutions too much since you have to mostly rely on balloon ship builds.

Sunlight#0123: @4231189 - The aesthetic for this map looks decent and the design features multipath gameplay, but the concept is generic and does not have anything new to offer #spiritual.