Rotation Officielle - P5

Rotation Officielle - P5 - Art

@7958511

@7946573
@7947082
@7948498
@7958400

Left as is:
@7952750 - Kiky#0542 - Not an art map
@7953190 - Streetraat#0000 - Those mice look cute, but don't really fit the overall aesthetic of the map, it looks a bit all over the place. I also wish there was more variety, not the same sprite 4 times.
@7953260 - Streetraat#0000 - The art doesn't look very appealing here, and the gameplay mainly consists of wj, which is boring and repetitive.
@7283143 - Streetraat#0000 - The art aspect of the map looks okay, but the collision properties are unclear on the right side. It would also be nice if the art interacted and related more with the gameplay.
@7954536 - Brtrem#0000 - Not an art map
@7784119 - Mivale#6763 - I love the theme and art, but the gameplay is quite boring sadly, and the collision properties are unclear and inconsistent (no indication on which side of the boxes/windows you can walk over).
@7957250 - Jab#8753 - Poor gameplay, no interaction with the art. Also, the cheese is hidden which is against the guidelines and rules, so I P22'd the map.
@7958168 - Jab#8753 - Artistic aspect is minimal, and the gameplay is boring as well.
@7958494 - B00_N#0000 - The art is poorly made, and the gameplay is tedious. boring.
@7958511 - B00_N#0000 - Same as above.
@7948498 - R_Y#8502 - I enjoyed the art here, but the gameplay is boring. Also, it is discouraged to have a hidden mousehole with no indication.
@7958400 - R_Y#8502 - Nice art, but the gameplay is not the best and the collision properties are still unclear despite the use of arrows.

P1'ed:
@7481479 - Streetraat#0000 - Map looks okay, but the gameplay is not too interesting.
@7646731 - Mivale#6763 - Lovely art, but the gameplay is a bit short and not very exciting.
@7956296 - Yukato#4683 - The art looks amazing! However, the gameplay is not too interesting.
@7731386 - Byroca#0000 - I feel like the color choices and the gameplay both could be better, but it's a decent map overall, ok for P1.
@7957602 - Hyk#6465 - Nice art, I love the theme, however gameplay is a bit boring.
@7957593 - Evizu#4068 - I love the art style, interesting and minimal. However, the gameplay is not interesting.
@7947082 - R_Y#8502 - I like the art and that the map is full of life, but the gameplay I feel is more chaotic than fun here.

Will be discussed:
@7946573 - R_Y#8502 - Great art, okayish gameplay. Nothing too extraordinary, but I would like to give it a chance.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#6504

@7946497
@7949519
@7958400 - Edited
@7959043

#6505

@7959818

#6506

@7960168

#6507

@7951804

#6508

Left as is:
@7946497 - R_Y#8502 -The art is decent, but not particularly engaging. The map's collisions make it hard to understand where to go, and the arrows don't do much to clarify the path. It’s difficult to tell which parts of the map are walkable and which are not. Given these issues, it wouldn’t be a suitable choice for the P5 rotation.
@7949519 - R_Y#8502 - The art is decent, but there’s room for improvement. Adding more detail, such as refining the characters' noses, could enhance it. The daylight background feels somewhat disconnected from the other art elements, creating a lack of cohesion. The map itself is ok, but it feels like something is missing to make it truly stand out.
@7959818 - Lafakinrata#8153 - The art is too simple for our current standards, especially considering we already have over a thousand maps in the art category. Regarding gameplay, the wind is too strong, making it very challenging to return with the cheese. The art feels more like just a background rather than a meaningful part of the map.
@7960168 - Lafakinrata#8153 - I’d say the same about the art as in the previous map—it feels more like just a background rather than the highlight of the map. The gameplay is somewhat repetitive and dull, and the circles with different colors seem a bit odd to me. Art maps should place more emphasis on detailed artistic elements to truly stand out.
@7951804 - Favelada#6672 - Não é um mapa arte. Por favor leia as regras de submissão de mapas da categoria P5 antes de enviar um novo mapa.

P1'ed:
@7958400 - R_Y#8502 - Art is ok, but there's nothing too interesting or outstanding in the details and gameplay.
@7959043 - R_Y#8502 - Fine for P1 for the same reasons above.

Will be discussed:
None

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

#6509

@7861557

#6510

@7961203

#6511

[Modéré par Rafinha, raison : This is not a submission, if you have any concerns or personal requests, contact the Mapcrew member in private.]

#6513

@7961947

#6514

@7946410
@7950774
@7958912
@7959371

#6515

@7777792

#6516

Left as is:
@7961203 - Erickindio#0000
@7961947 - Rioxmaps#3702 - Nice artwork! However, the gameplay is very poor once all you have to do is wall-jump all over the art. The next time, while creating a map, try to use all the map area to improve the gameplay, such as adding obstacles, paths or other art-ish elements.
@7958912 - R_Y#8502 - I see the potential on this map, but I'd like to see the back way (cheese to hole), next to the horse's tail, improved somehow, because it is difficult for most of the players. Fix it and submit again.

P1'ed:
@7946410 - R_Y#8502 - Although this map does not have the best gameplay I have ever seen, it is cute and fine for P1.
@7950774 - R_Y#8502 - It should've won the Grammy!
Anyway, the gameplay is very simple as well as the art. P1 seems good.
@7959371 - R_Y#8502 - The map is so original, I never saw something like that. On the other hand, the gameplay is linear and boring. P1 will do.

Will be discussed:
@7777792 - Mquk#0095 - Ma meilleure ennemie c'est toi!

Ignored:
@7861557 - Gaspar#3336 - Plagiarism. Blacklisted for a month.

Dernière modification le

#6517

@7946497
@7948498
@7958912 - Edited
@7962748

#6518

@5635289

#6519

[Modéré par Mapcrew]

#6520

Left as is:
None

P1'ed:
@7946497 - R_Y#8502 - The artwork is very great! However, the gameplay is not that attractive as all you have to do is walk and do wall jump over the art. In addition to this, you have used a lot of lines (joints) and it makes your map very heavy to load, consequently, it will take a little longer to load for the players that don't have good connections or machines and this is not good. P1 will do.
@7948498 - R_Y#8502 - Exactly the same comment as above.
@7962748 - R_Y#8502 - Simple art and gameplay, however, it is fun! Fits P1 fine.
@5635289 - Apollopolo#0000 - This map runs out of the "obvious" in the art category: do wall jump all over the art. And this is a great thing since the shaman is needed here to build like in a shaman map, which adds some challenge to the map and increases its gameplay value. But, despite being a well done art, it is not the greatest artwork, because of this, P1 will do.

Will be discussed:
@7958912 - R_Y#8502 - Better than the previous version. Nevertheless, it still has some lag issues. I will put it in discussion so I can have more opinions about it.

Ignored:
None

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue