Rotation Officielle - P4

#7303

Left as is:
@6000012 - Gobbek - The concept and objective of this map is rather interesting, however the use of the portals and overall gameplay of this map is simplistic, unexciting. The use of the anti-cloud is rather monotonous, perhaps if you could make it more of a challenge to inspire the Shamans to try new and interesting builds.
@6814493 - +Ppp - While there is two evident path-ways to use regarding the completion of this map, it's easy to see that majority of the Shamans will avoid using the cloud as it's merely a obstacle in their way.
@6996605 - Leiks - While this map does give the Shaman plenty of room and space to build, it's overall quite dull, even giving the atmosphere of a buildathon, it can easily be completed by a massive bridge or 'V' build, as well, making it unexciting to build for.
@7007030 - Clackprooo - Unforuntately, this map is considered too difficult for newer P4 Shamans, as it hardly gives them any room or space to build (in normal mode, since totems can vary between Shamans) and the grounds overall are just awkward and tricky to build on.
@7007900 - Okpatinhos - This map as a whole is extremely simplistic/generic, it doesn't insight the Shamans to try any new or interesting build nor does it challenge them any. It's worth noting that it's appreciated that you made two clear paths for the Shaman to use, however it's very genuine.
@2128293 - Jaonm - This map is unfortunately too difficult for P4 Shamans. It's also rather frustrating to no end to attempt to use the portals successfully to get the cheese and into the hole, it almost always only pushes the mice out of the way. Please fix this problem, perhaps by making mice able to stand inside the center of the circular grounds. Once you do so, feel free to submit this map again!
@7008279 - Shamapas - Perhaps if you moved the Shaman spawn to the ground the right of the vertical ice, it would help them be able to cover more ground and more efficiently complete the map, time-wise. There is also (unfortunately) not many solutions that the Shaman can go by making it rather dull and unexciting to build for.
@1147794 - Jotatavo - Your edits are apreeciated! However, the map, while it does have new found support for the Shamans to use in the center of the map, does still morerather give the buildathon type of atmosphere, making it repetitive and monotonous.
@7008251 - Maxislow - This map is rather genuine and pleasing to the eye; however, on the downside it doesn't offer many variables for the Shaman to go by, regarding them completing the map, and using the clouds as obstacles are typically frowned upon; as they limit the Shamans space and creativity, in this sense they are fine as it isn't too overwhelming and actually challenges the Shaman. Nonetheless, when it comes to building towards the cheese, it becomes rather tight or, 'cramped' to build towards. It's advised that you raise the platform that the mice spawn on, perhaps.
@7007311 - Censere - Unfortunately, during testing majority of the mice ran towards the cheese, which as a result drowned/killed many. Also, if a Shaman were to have a certain skill, they could easily just remove one of the planks of the box, taking away the entire idea and concept of this map. Unfortunately, looking over the limited variations of solutions and risk, it won't fit into P4.
@3782002 - Darklantern - This map does prove to have a new and interesting concept/idea behind it, which is really appreciated, however it has proved to be too difficult and or confusing for newer P4 Shamans to understand the idea behind anti-clouds.
@2876466 - Neymazinhor - Majority of the Shamans have avoided the trampolines and have opted to merely go under them, making a bridge. The map all in all is rather simplistic; tedious, even in its current state of offering plenty of solutions (shown by the crevices).
@6378173 - Tioyudis - While it is a unique idea/concept behind this map, it is morerather simplistic and unexciting to build for, as it doesn't challenge the Shamans, primarily due to having so much room and space to build inside. All in all, it is very monotonous, unfortunately.
@7008369 - Marllonsilva - Cobwebs are frowned upon in maps submitted for P4 as they only result in vexation from the Shamans, unfortunately. However, I see that it does challenge them to be creative in their builds. One edit I'd recommend is to remove the cobwebs around the cheese, at least to make it more tolerable.
@7008762 - Amaciadoo - The excessive use of cobwebs are frowned upon, which can be explained above. Also, in this case, a lot of mice has gotten stuck in these cobwebs, making it a rather ... sticky situation ... which in the end results in irritation from the Shaman as they would have to patiently wait or attempt to free the mice.
@7008758 - Bequerr - Same as above.
@7000017 - +Lindas - While there is crevices to the grounds, giving the illusion of having multiple solutions, it has little to no effect to the gameplay of it all, this map merely encourages Shamans to use the lower path (as it's the simplest) to build a bridge, in the end it will become tedious and repetitive.
@7009450 - Antonioepf - The design of this map is rather charming, however it has proven to be too difficult/vexing for P4 Shamans due to the excessive use of diagonal grounds and the clouds being a obstacle.
@2995200 - Reppam - Same as above.
@6995133 - Stalii - Your edits are appreciated! Nonetheless, it's easy to see that majority of the Shamans whom must build for this map will not really even bother with the lowest cloud as they could build above the highest one (which is the easiest solution possible) nonetheless, it's a interesting concept and does slightly challenge the Shamans. A few edits I'd advise would be to; remove the lowest/southern most cloud and set the ground where the Shaman spawns to be in the middle right, so it is seemingly inbetween the two remaining clouds, so that the Shamans are more so inspired to use the crevice.
@886573 - Bowlt - While it does have a unique format and the setting of having multiple solutions due to having the crevices, it's simply too generic/unexciting to be anything more than P1.
@7009818 - Papelio - This map is overly simplistic and rather monotonous to build for, while it does give the illusion of having multiple solutions via the crevices, many of the Shamans will only create/build the same thing; a bridge. Which in the end can be repetitive and not add anything new or exciting to the gameplay.
@6963729 - Mythofcheez - While it does have a interesting concept and idea behind it, it's unfortunately too simplistic/easy going for P4 Shamans, as it only requires a few cannons and maybe even a balloon. This doesn't challenge the Shaman in any way.
@7010211 - Uskil - The excessive use of the cloud as a obstacle is really vexing for Shamans, as it limits their space and creativity to build, and is especially a nuisance for newer Shamans. A edit I'd advise you to add would be to make the cloud able to have objects attached to it (once the edit is applied, please make it evident by having a already attached object to the cloud)
@7003155 - Lassapq - While it's a pleasing and straightforward, this map isn't really exciting or interesting to build for, and it hardly challenges the Shaman, either. While it does give a vast area of space to build, majority of it won't be used.
@3214829 - Shalander - This map doesn't really challenge nor insight the Shaman to try any new or thought-provoking builds due to the excess use of portals being the only key factor of this map, in regards to this, a Shaman in Divine mode would have no problem what-so-ever, either.

P1'ed:
@7008055 - Viptoto - While this map is rather appealing, it only offers one or two solutions regarding the completion of the map, making it rather monotonous. However; it does have somewhat of a charming simplicity to it. P1 will do.
@6506049 - Bataatiinha - While it does supply many solutions/paths that the Shaman can use, it doesn't necessarily challenge them to try new or interesting builds, making it rather simple or incomplex, nonetheless, it's a well designed map and is worth to remain P1.
@6996696 - Fulist - This map does have a delightful simplicity to it, and the use of clouds (while typically looked down upon) have proved to be little to no trouble for the Shamans, as it only truly challenges them to tweak their builds a bit to get into the atmosphere this map sets. Unfortunately, it only does give two obvious sets of variations/paths for the Shamans to use, which can be repetitive. All in all, this map is pleasing and worth P1.

Will be discussed:
@6780352 - Framnm - Already in discussion.

Ignored:
@6991081 - Bruno4ponto0 - Posted more than 1 map (#7287, #7288)
@6994886 - Bruno4ponto0 - Posted more than 1 map (#7287, #7288)

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue