Rotation Officielle - P4

#7493

Left as is:
@6967605 - Wersacho - While the concept itself is executed in a friendly simplistic way, the map isn't really fun to build; the solutions and the way that shamans will have to move the dynamic circle are kind of tedious and somehow repetitive. Moreover, the circle offers of an obstacle that newer shamans can't really deal with, as well.
@1298059 - Prodizyan - This map is extremely similar from maps that were been submitted over the last years, the concept involving portals is kind of overused, which means that it wouldn't really offer much for the rotation. Moreover, having to use portals for multiple times is kind of annoying for the shaman, while building is required in the cheese spot, only.
@6865751 - Zaptoliti - The use of clouds is kind of annoying and somehow useless, concept isn't exciting and doesn't bring anything fun for the shaman. Water might be a painful ground because too many mice are supposed to die while trying to grab the cheese. The large building for hole isn't appreciated.
@6818813 - Maherv1 - The map barely needs a shaman to build on since most of this consists on wall jumping, only. Try reading the category rules and take a look into the shaman maps rotation so you can understand what does look a P4 map.
@7030236 - Aguerorko - Shamans need to build off the screen, the excess of waters usually make it tedious and painful for the shaman to build on, as well. The map is extremely boring and not shaman category style, even while it does need a shaman.
@7030385 - Allthetrees - The concept is rather too simplistic and tedious, mostly because the defilante skull tokens just act like a massive death obstacle that kills most of the mice which try to avoid. Overall it's extremely frustrating to shaman on, even while there is some simplicity here.
@7028732 - Mrorko - Interesting concept, but not enough space to build properly, plus the skulls are actually an annoying obstacle for the shaman. Moreover it's not clear that clouds are attachable with those objects. Kind of concept that is actually implemented in a way that confuses newer shamans.
@7000604 - Victorgabino - Firstly, the plank is nothing but an unnecessary obstacle. Due to the simplicity of this map and the fact that it's a too common concept, it doesn't inspire the shaman for creativity solutions, which is rather monotonous and not exciting.
@6228886 - Uhuge - This map is extremely simplistic and rather tedious to build on, while there is nothing interesting or exciting to take it in consideration. The ugly design is disappointing.
@7029969 - Tohpy - Extremely boring and rather tedious to build on, the vertical solutions are too monotonous and not really fun for the shaman, even while the simplicity is appreciated.
@7031271 - Ayentrax - Same as above.
@7031303 - Bladirox - This is not a shaman map. Please, read the category rules before posting a map on this thread, hope you understand it.
@7010015 - Clackprooo - The clouds and the cramped space in the bottom usually just make the map not exciting to build on and easy to screw everything up. Too similar from an already existent shaman map and a few other P1s.
@6985504 - Jotatavo - Solutions are rather monotonous and repetitive, which isn't good to shaman on. This map just that was randomly created, while the bottom is completely ignored by all the shamans and the clouds is nothing but a unnecessary and tedious obstacle.
@7031668 - Polskakurwa2 - This map barely needs the help of a shaman, which makes it not suitable for this category. Read the rules before posting a map on this thread, for the next time.
@7020685 - Kyclet - This map is too complicated for a single shaman and really cramped and monotonous for cooperation. The three possible paths are quite unbalanced and everyone is going to avoid the skulls, only, since they are placed in a very unsafe way that kills almost all mice if the shaman is trying to go hole from the high.
@7032128 - Filenewmap - Rather simplistic and tedious since there are too many useless grounds and the weird design is visually ugly. The space hasn't been well utilized since there are some obstacles like the cloud in the bottom that makes everything less fun to build on, lacking on variety of solutions and creativity.
@7029732 - Sajtor - Not a really fan of maps like this, there are too many grounds that limits the possibilities of solution and creativity. The map is way too monotonous and gameplay is extremely tedious, even while it is accessible for newer shamans.
@7032628 - Pastelao150 - Dealing with dynamic grounds with b nail is noting but tedious, while some newer shamans aren't experienced enough to pass through it properly. There is way too much of vertical building for a single shaman, which can be monotonous and somehow dull.
@7032870 - Jowholer - Annoying use of clouds and unbalanced paths - getting the upper cheese is way easier to reach on, making the bottom one always ignored by the shamans, which isn't fun for a map with double cheese.
@6997402 - Bruno4ponto0 - Solved with portal using only, that is disappointing and not fun for the shaman.
@7032954 - Markywa - This is not a shaman map, read the category rules before posting a map on this thread.
@6812469 - King_Louie - Lava grounds are usually the worst thing to add in shaman maps since they easily ruin it's building. This map is overall too massy death and painful to try to build on, which makes it not suitable for the category.
@7033066 - Mabste - While the concept itself is interesting, this map just doesn't play well because newer shamans are unable to understand how to use portals properly and it requires a bit more of experience to place portals in the way you've implemented it. Some might fail, while others are just going to die. Couldn't understand the trampoline grounds, either.
@4057982 - Neymazinhor - Even while the concept can be interesting, it's still confusing and not exciting to shaman on. Newer shamans are going to have troubles about understanding what to do with the choco grounds.
@6643104 - Kimsterjay - Too much of building for a single shaman, try submitting it for P8. The use of cloud isn't really interesting, while it's just harmless otherwise.
@7026283 - Poteerfotter - This map is extremely similar from maps that were been submitted over the last years; extremely simplisctic and rather tedious to build on, while there is nothing interesting or exciting to take it in consideration. The cloud ground usage isn't really appreciated either.
@5652030 - Flllasshhhh - Already P1, and p1 will do since it's not good enough for high perm. Having to handle with cheese and water and portals might be painful for newer shamans, while most of them will just die and kill other mice because of the lack of supports.

P1'ed:
@2913746 - Sekui - Even while the concept is interesting, I imagine that newer shamans will have troubles about properly since the map itself requires kinda much of vertical building and the non collision with shaman object is usually a feature that will just make them frustrated. P1 is fine otherwise.
@6790819 - Pjfsamora - The map is shaman friendly, even while the concept doesn't bring anything interesting for the rotation. However, due the boxes around the map, it usually lacks in build variety + creativity, which might be tedious for the shaman. The whole right bottom is ignored because of that, for example. P1 will do.
@7031805 - Paulmarques - Nothing against this map, this is just not good enough to be considered high perm. Cool for newer shamans, even while there is basically only a solution.
@7032181 - Mythofcheez - Even while the map is kinda hard for newer shaman in terms of solutions, the concept of portals is executed in a friendly way. P1
@6721819 - Mquk - The simplicity is alright, I just feel like the cheese should be moved down a bit more to make both paths balanced and accessible. P1
@2230090 - Nukualofa - P1 will do. Nothing against this map, but I feel like it won't offer anything really fun for the rotation.

Will be discussed:
@592501 - Rikkeshang - Concept is overused but the map overall is fun to play on. I like the mix of building + the use of portals (which actually isn't rather boring or repetitive) involved.
@7030543 - Mousechris - Will give it a shot because of concept, not sure if this is going to work wll in public though, but the simplicity and use of space are appreciated.
@7013624 - Amaciadoo - Looks harmless, will see with the others.
@7022248 - Okpatinhos - Fun for for a bit more average shamans and newer ones.
@7033409 - Tdft - Want to give it a chance, the concept is simple and overused, but shaman friendly.

Ignored:
None

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue