Rotation Officielle - P4

#8170

For a more detailed feedback, send a PM to this account with your map code. I haven't write better reviews because most of the maps submitted had a very low quality with repetitive designs and gameplay.

Left as is:
@7114390 - Tohpy - There is nothing really exciting or fun for the shaman to build on, mostly because the solutions are always going to be the same and the concept offered isn't special at all. Therefore I don't think this would be a great addition to the rotation, so I'm keeping it as is.
@7098994 - Pjfsamora - Firstly, I don't like how the clouds are utilized in this map (they are just floating supports that shamans definitely don't need to use, as well). Pathways to cheese are kind of unbalanced, where it's easier for the shaman if they go building to the upper one.
@7115089 - Tarciomaneri - The gameplay is quite basic and alright for newer mice, but I feel like this wouldn't be great just because it's not exciting to build on and solutions are basically always the same every time it plays. Lava design is a bit awkward too.
@7115124 - Pelitemaija - Too much of building for a single shaman, Keep in mind that most of the players are beginners, so it's not good to have time consuming maps, especially in a single shaman category, Otherwise the map is very tedious and not exciting to play, it's just too repetitive in terms of solutions.
@7115134 - Maxislow - This map somehow reminds me of some already existent ones... Both water grounds are too pointless and I would say that maps like this are usually better when there's another shaman for cooperation, since it's considered large.
@7113208 - Flyingwr - This map seems to be very random, I hate that almost all the map's space is too limited for only one kind of solution because it hasn't been well explored. The map is easy and simple, but really tedious to play on.
@3633488 - Dextech - Removing cloud grounds, firstly, wouldn't affect the map's gameplay since it definitely doesn't need clouds for solutions. They don't even offer much of an obstacle, so I'm recommending you to remove them. Otherwise the map is well done, might be a bit too limited and long, biut I'll think about considering it after edits.
@7111113 - Viniciusdara - This map has somehow a cooperation design, since it's kinda too large. Solutions aren't interetsing or fun, by the way, since they consist basically on building a bridge cheese-hole only, which is nothing but tedious over time, so 'i'm keeping it out of rotation
@7115545 - Nerveeju - FLAMENGO!!!!!!!!!! Not a shaman map. Read the category guidelines before posting a map in this thread, please.
@7115549 - Skydark599 - Not a shaman map. Read the category guidelines before posting a map in this thread, please.
@4457780 - Danielmago - Again, the cloud grounds don't offer much of an obstacle and much less a support for the shaman. Gameplay isn't interesting, it's just too bland and repetitive, therefore this map isn't going to be a great addition to the rotation, even as P1.
@7115979 - Poteerfotter - Too many cloud cubes. This is a different concept, but just doesn't work well and results frustrating.
@6772308 - Provincias - Already P1, and it's fine a sit is. Nothing else
@7113998 - Fuzzyfirsdog - Too much of building and time consuming for a single shaman. Your map has a cooperation aspect and even for that, solutions are rather tedious and basically always the same every time the map plays, which is frustrating over time.
@7111177 - Eyux - Could be a better map if it's space were better utilized, there are some free space that shamans use for anything, which isn't exciting. The concept executed isn't new or either very outstanding, but not terrible considering our current standards for a perm. Try to slightly make it batter improving the variety of solutions and the space.
@7116367 - Pikakoz - Too unoriginal and tedious.
@7116429 - Flowiiz - Not a shaman map. Read the category guidelines before posting a map in this thread, please.
@7116732 - Yuugiooohhhh - Cooperation style, not single shaman.
@7108579 - Kwf - Defilante tokens are almost useless and barely offer much of an obstacle. This map has a great amount of free space for solutions, but the concept isn't well implemented.
@6290095 - Framnm - Certain grounds could be removed for variety of solutions, the pathways are decently balanced, by the way.
@7114432 - Tioyudis - Bad use of skulls tokens, they don't offer anything special to the maps gameplay.
@7117743 - +Telol - The simplicity is cool, but quite unoriginal nowadays. Water ground is pretty useless by the way.
@7117838 - Ymdsf - All grounds seem to be randomly placed, too cramped to build on at certain places, as well.
@7118645 - V_Ntage - Doesn't really seem to be a shaman map, too tedious and doesn't require any sort of building.
@7119024 - Lucysicy - Too unoriginal and generic.
@7119111 - Edgaruu - Off-screen building in the corners might be a bit painful and frustrating for the shaman.
@6579462 - Bataatiinha - Definitely cooperation style, not single shaman.
@7119273 - Thiago3434 - Mediocre gameplay, nothing exciting for the shaman.
@7110025 - Ldn - Too cooperation style, not single shaman.
@7119382 - Sahuru - I would say that the concept itself isn't well executed in this map, this one requires too much of building for a single shaman and the dynamic grounds barely offer a special gameplay.
@7115957 - Viptoto - very awkward decoration and gameplay is very similar to already existent maps.
@7119472 - Makudomakudo - Personally I hate the mix of clouds and anti clouds. This map is jut not fun or exciting to play on, it annoys most of the shamans. Having attachable grounds is ok, but actually not well executed since there's quite too much of vertical building for a single shaman.
@7119598 - Jestem1polak - Gameplay is way too tedious and consists on building a bridge, only.
@7119883 - Rkubi - [•] Map not found.
@7120201 - Yahhir - Even while this map requires a shaman for solution, since it has art, you should submit it for P5 instead. There is a exclusive category for art maps, and we accept any kind of gameplay there, as long as it has art.

P1'ed:
@6014853 - Sekui - Too unoriginal and not exciting enough for rotation, the concept explored isn't that special anyway, otherwise P1 is neat.
@6918325 - Reppam - Interesting challenging, the map has a medium difficulty but might be somehow hard for really newer player.
@7107858 - Zackybear - Nothing really outstanding, P1 will do.
@7119801 - Lzereturn - I would prefer having a better use of the map's space in right spot, but P1 will do.
@7115118 - Papelio - The map itself is ok, but I feel like this is going to be a bit messy and boring over time.

P4'ed:
@7112373 - Gamog - quite alright map
@6936198 - Okpatinhos - fine portal using concept, even while it might be a bit difficult for really newer mice.
@979667 - Garyarcanine - pretty fine map
@6966126 - Wersacho - Cool design with a friendly gameplay, i don't see why not.
@4851661 - Thegbc - Quite alright map for rotation, there are some variety of solutions and there's a decent use of the map's space. Cloud ground somehow helps the shaman with their buidling and it's utilized in a harmless way. P4

Ignored:
@7089832 - +Mlw - Posted more than 1 map (#8137)
@7104350 - +Mlw - Posted more than 1 map (#8137)
@6925196 - Miirp - Posted more than 1 map (#8131, #8165)
@7025166 - Miirp - Posted more than 1 map (#8131, #8165)

Dernière modification le

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue