Rotation Officielle - P4

Rotation Officielle - P4 - Chamane

#10621

@7515415

#10622

@6286462

#10623

@7522937

#10624

@7516147

#10625

@7508983 edited

#10626

@7523886

#10627

@7473672

Dernière modification le

#10628

@7524653

#10629

@6625321

#10630

@1122982

#10631

Sorry was so focused i go into wrong rotation XD

Dernière modification le

#10632

@7525105

#10633

@7525240

#10634

@6308835

#10635

@7525841

#10636

Desculpe, eu errei ao postar dois mapas para avaliaçao, mas ja apaguei um.

Dernière modification le

#10637

@7526249

#10638

Left as is:
@7515655 - Hiimanto#9700 - The layout seems random and isn't appealing. The cheese area is too cramped and will most likely be messed up.
@7519514 - Ezeq#8120 - Not a shaman map.
@7519677 - Sharkguest#0000 - I think the concept is interesting but still too complicated and consufing for players who don't understand how to act on it.
@7515112 - Incidius#2735 - Weird concept. Even though I understand the idea, building on this is tricky and will be messy and not enjoyable at all.
@7514987 - Lonson#0000 - The layout is pretty generic, nothing really stands out here.
@6355241 - Tytnc#0000 - Same concept as last time, once is nice but twice gets pretty repetitive.
@7520376 - Keyx#0000 - Weird concept with a weird execution, big clouds are more annoying than useful in any way here.
@7520389 - Ta_Orginalna#5873 - Not a shaman map.
@7520398 - C0xinhaa#5351 - Not a shaman map.
@7520545 - Tears#9260 - Weird layout, quite not aesthetic at all, and pretty cramped to build on; shamans can't be original on it.
@7409877 - Dariusseby_Y#1467 - Looks like a generic grass/ice map which won't add much to rotation.
@7520668 - Mathwarm#0000 - Doesn't have much interest, too simple for a portal map.
@7521017 - Luan#4122 - Too simple and uninteresting for a portal map.
@7501549 - Chatoonette#0000 - Nice game but not a shaman map.
@7522137 - Sekui#0000 - Le concept est sympa et dans le thème du moment mais j'ai l'impression que le mecanisme est cassé. En poussant le bouton marron l'arraignée ne s'enlève pas.
@7515415 - Amk#5312 - Random layout, hard to make a stable construction here.
@7522937 - Comen#2581 - The properties of the yellow grounds aren't clear and the layout is too generic to be allowed to build in a creative way.
@7508983 - Abelgam3r#0000 - The concept in itself is nice but appart form spwaning few boxes and building a ramp, the shaman doesn't have much to do. I think the execution could and should be better.
@7473672 - Eyux#0000 - The map is ok but the concept is overused.
@7524653 - Kjguid#0000 - The map is so random. The cloud in the background shouldn't be here, the grounds are not aligned properly, the water near the hole is useless... Many things are going on and they just don't fit together as a whole.
@1122982 - Viniciusdara#4015 - I feel like the skull tokens are useless here, glass grounds would have been the exact same. Besides the decorations seem a bit too random.
@7525105 - Hea#0000 - Meh the grounds are too huge to be interesting here in my opinion.
@7525240 - Jefedelsol#0000 - Not really a shaman map.
@6308835 - Jota#0676 - P1 is enough imo.
@7525841 - Wed#0000 - Too many clouds to be interesting to build on.
@7526249 - Qehenna#0000 - Too cramped, the concept is understandable but the execution is bad. It would be a mess to sham on it.
@7510005 - Mckeydown#0000 - I like the concept but I tested it couple times and even practiced shamans couldn't finish it, so probably a bit too hard for now.

P1'ed:
@6421179 - Vintage#0246 - Simple but effective, althought it will most likely be solved by a ramp and a bridge.
@7313444 - Vlump#0000 - I P1'ed it back but even though I like it I feel like once again it won't make it through discussion.
@7516147 - Krome#1204 - Sympathique mais similaire à pas mal d'autres cartes.
@7523886 - Star#8558 - Ok.

Will be discussed:
@7245287 - Smutny_Nalesnik#0000 - Maybe P8 will be better.
@4262205 - Namelessh#0000 - Ok.
@7523744 - Nikkita#0208 - I really like the idea of it, so I'll give it a shot at discussion.
@6625321 - Brenow#4577 - Nice.

Ignored:
@6367739 - Fram#4747 - Posted more than 1 map (#10600, #10622)
@6286462 - Fram#4747 - Posted more than 1 map (#10600, #10622)

Dernière modification le

#10639

@7524045

#10640

@7522137 - J'espère que le mécanisme ne bug plus. ^^'

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue