Map Feedback

I noticed that there was no thread specifically for getting feedback on your maps. The Map Asssistance Team is no longer around, there's not always a Map Crew member available ingame, submitting maps for a review usually takes a lot more time to get reviewed, and asking for help in your showcase threads doesn't always get noticed.

In comes this thread.

Feel free to post a map or two of yours here that you'd like feedback on (bare in mind not to post too many at once) and people checking this thread will give their opinions on the maps for you. Anyone can give feedback here, it's not limited to just certain people.

Please post the category you're aiming for with your map, if you don't then people may (for example) assume that you're aiming for a bootcamp map while you felt it was meant to be racing and base their opinions accordingly.

A thread like dat is back! Thanks for making it!
I have no idea what else to make in this map, any advices?
@4990682

Arber a dit :
A thread like dat is back! Thanks for making it!
I have no idea what else to make in this map, any advices?
@4990682

I would add some sky in the top of the map and maybe make the hole more visible.
You could also make the grass look better.

Arber a dit :
@4990682

I like this map a lot :] Unfortunately it seems more like a proof of concept than a genuinely playable map that'd fit into rotation seamlessly.

I like how there's multiple layers of water that lets you stand still in any position of the field, but maneuvering around in it isn't like you'd expect when playing Transformice, nor does it play well when you have cheese in the area.

Ontop of that, the collision on the fences and grounds can be confusing and unexpected. Parts of the map are very detailed but there are other parts that are extremely plain and minimalistic, although it seems you've used a lot of grounds and joints making this map already.

Nicoronaldo a dit :
I would add some sky in the top of the map and maybe make the hole more visible.

I beg to differ with the sky thing, this is a top-down view of the map. If you look down at your feet, do you see the sky?

Although I agree with making the hole more visible, the first time I played I assumed it was inside the little building.

@4880133 How about this? I live in Canada and visited The Maritimes a lot. I love the lighthouses there. Annywayys, tell me what I should change.

Epicsouris a dit :
@4880133 How about this? I live in Canada and visited The Maritimes a lot. I love the lighthouses there. Annywayys, tell me what I should change.

I think it's cool but the lighthouse could use some work while it's weird that mice can just run off the boat lol. I expected to push it and stuff. That random flying bridge though :p

Hello I would like some advice for gameplay on these 2 maps.
1) prison map - @3667188
I'm not sure what to do here; I tried making it a portal shaman map but it's kinda too easy..yeah.
2) peacock map - @3688007
This map is a struggle; I'm at a loss for gameplay ideas.

@5007654 (P3) , what do you think ?

Fkrthebest a dit :
@5007654 (P3) , what do you think ?

First of all I suggest you fix this big shortcut

With this shortcut, every single ground at the bottom is useless.

@5008560 P17

#10

Epalk a dit :

2) peacock map - @3688007
This map is a struggle; I'm at a loss for gameplay ideas.

Mmm, very nice.
I find it fine already, with the bottom part.
Easily can make a sham map, and decent game play enough. Probably difficult enough to be a dual sham map. I see no problems however.

Er, can I get suggestions for this: @4409686
Whether its too easy/too simple, i dunno, i submitted it, and got denied. But i still want to submit something like it.
Should I replace the hole with a cheese and make them have to return some how?

Also, gj on reviving the thread shamousey

#11

@Defilantegod, most of the left map is empty, and the map can be short to complete it, i bet good bootcampers would even complete it in less than 10 seconds

#12

Hi everyone ^^ I'd like to know what do you think about those maps below:

@4709422 (P5)
@4598787 - Art-shaman map (P5)

Thanks!

#13

@3165575 - P17
@3106618 - P5

#14

Siilverpack a dit :

@3106618 - P5

The art's simple and cute but the gameplay can be a little annoying. Maybe remove some of the wind?

#15

thank you!and can you be my freind!plz!

#16

Uskil a dit :
Hi everyone ^^ I'd like to know what do you think about those maps below:

@4709422 (P5)
@4598787 - Art-shaman map (P5)

Thanks!

@4709422 - Nice art :)

I think the gameplay is a little bit long and not so fun. The caves look a little bit empty. Also I did not notice the water, I would suggest making it more visible by changing the background or something.

#17

Uskil a dit :
Hi everyone ^^ I'd like to know what do you think about those maps below:

@4709422 (P5)
@4598787 - Art-shaman map (P5)

Thanks!

Cute map. Adding on to Nico's advice, I think the "water" should be foreground and transparent. It would be more ideal for me. The arrow between legs also looks weird as foreground; however, the gameplay was kinda fun even though it felt like half wj. :-)
--------------
Pooh map is also cute. However, I found it difficult and cramped to build for mice to get up. The non collision branch should be a bit darker too. That's all. :]

@defilantegod Thanks :* I'll see what fits.

#18

@988050 (P22/P5*) H="800"

#19

Arber a dit :
@Defilantegod, most of the left map is empty, and the map can be short to complete it, i bet good bootcampers would even complete it in less than 10 seconds

Mmm, I know that, but that was my point. I wanted it to be quick and simple. But, I will try and switch it up so that you have to make it back with cheese; thanks.

#20

Hello, I need some feedback on this map.
@2352101 - P5 (art)

I want to improve the gameplay but I don't know what to do.

English	Français
Português do Brasil	Español
Türkçe	Polski
Magyar	Română
العربية	Skandinavisk
Nederlands	Deutsch
Bahasa Indonesia	Русский
中文	Filipino
Lietuvių kalba	日本語
Suomi	עברית
Italiano	Česky
Hrvatski	Slovensky
Български	Latviešu
Estonian

Langue